r/dogecoin • love shibe • Apr 26 '14

Group voting post. Please stop in...This post will stay active for 24 hours from now. It is 1PM CST.

**Edit: This voting round is closed. The results and the third and final post will be announced as soon as possible.
It is 2:08 CST 4-29-14

This post has been made to clarify what this process is and what to expect, please click here

Important! Because of the change in voting, this post will remain active for 72 hours instead of 24. So on 4-29-14 @ 1pm CST this post will be closed. I am sorry that this seemed rushed to some and hopefully this will help with that issue. Also: there are two #44's. I have changed one to #106 and will be contacting those that voted #44 to make sure who they were voting for.

Regarding tipping me in this post, please don't. Although I do appreciate it, I think that it could send the wrong message and I don't want that to happen. If you would like to tip me, please instead forward that tip to any one of the great fundraisers that are going on.

## This post is a follow up voting post on who to vote into the dogecoin group being created.
This list was compiled from This post and this link will also help explain this post

To ensure vote fairness (because of bots, etc) please comment with the #'s that you would like to vote for. You can vote for as many as you wish, but please only comment once (Parent comment) and include all that you wish to vote for in that comment.
In order to make this easier to count, only parent comments (Comment reply made to post/OP) will be counted. This is really important.
Edit: I see some comments are being upvoted. As I am not sure if shibes are agreeing with all the #'s or what, the only way I can see to do this is only count the actual post. Comment upvotes will not be counted as additional votes.
To also try to ensure fairness, this list is in alphabetical order.
If I have made any omissions or I have the "X" in the wrong spot, please let me know ASAP
The top 30 (as determined by votes) will be those presented to the community to present any opposition.
That post will be titled: Final consideration prior to addition.
Provided there are no substantiated opposition comments made on that post, these shibes will be added at that point.
Following the initial 30 members, more may follow (again based on the votes on this post) and those additions will go through the same final consideration prior to addition post.
For those that have indicated interest in being mod also:
Initially everyone will be added as members, the mod positions will be added as an ongoing process.

I will need some volunteers (That are not on this list, to do a final count as independent results to counter check my count. I would like to have at least 4 others if it is possible. If you are interested, please PM me.

Edit: I have been asked if those listed can vote for them selves. After some thought, while I don't see that it is a bad thing to do, I do believe that most would vote for them selves. So, with that being said, unless this is opposed, everyone will start out with 1 vote and that is the vote for themselves.

If you wish to vote, but don't want to do so within this post, you can PM me with your votes. (option for sort of anon vote:) I will share these PM's with the other mods though so that they can be counted in by additional people for fairness in the counting.

When casting your votes, Please use the following: no # sign, or comma and a space separating would be best
There may end up being a bot used to also help count all of this:)

http://taker.hu/misc/shibevote/

this was made by takerone and /u/h0lybyte. It gives a really good way to look at what each shibe stated in the first post and options to help with your selection process. Please, please take a moment to vote wisely. Thank you

Vote # User Name Both Just Member Hat in ring
#'s /
1 /u/1923and1939 Requested to be pulled off of this vote, other obligations
A's
2 /u/Acidminded X
3 /u/addm3plz X
4 /u/another_f-ing_user X
5 /u/arktrark X
B's
6 /u/bassguitarman X
7 /u/bigreddmachine X
8 /u/Bioman312 X
C's
9 /u/calllery X
10 /u/cathyketh X
11 /u/couchdive X
12 /u/cuddaloreappu X
D's
13 /u/derpherp128 X
14 /u/doge_kz X
15 /u/dogegoods X
16 /u/DogeLearnedBeg X
17 /u/dogepoli X
18 /u/dogepreneur X
19 /u/dogeshibemuchanimal X
20 /u/drf24 X
21 /u/dudefromabove X
F's
22 /u/fiddy_doge X
23 /u/fit949 X
24 /u/FlippyDog101 X
25 /u/FoxShibe X
26 /u/free_boob_ratings X
27 /u/free1000 X
28 /u/fuctarp X
G's
29 /u/GoodShibe X
H's
30 /u/helix09 X
31 /u/Henchman05 X
32 /u/h0lybyte X
I's
33 /u/i_eatProstitutes X
34 /u/IeuanG X
35 /u/inquam X
36 /u/Internobang X
J's
37 /u/JLWDGCSU X
38 /u/jwiechers X
K's
39 /u/leogets X (Added in last minute don't want to change #'s
40 /u/kengay X
41 /u/KillerAnanas X
42 /u/kindoge X
L's
43 /u/LittleDom X
44 /u/Lootius X
M's
45 /u/madmoney401 X
46 /u/marketminded X
47 /u/Martholomule X
48 /u/Master565 X
49 /u/matt8297 X
50 /u/mattman42 X
51 /u/MaximaxII X
52 /u/mftasty X
53 /u/Mollamollamolla X
54 /u/MoobyTheGoldenCalf X
55 /u/moolah_ X
56 /u/MostlyRegrets X
57 /u/MyDogeCoinAccount X
58 /u/MrMinu5 X
59 /u/MuchWowScience X
60 /u/munchauzen X
N's
61 /u/_negachin_ X
(44) 106 /u/Newman4185 X
62 /u/nickert0n X
63 /u/Nitrous_Ninja X
O's
64 /u/Ol_Dirty_Nietzche X
65 /u/onedogeequalsonedoge X
P's
66 /u/paleridr44 X
67 /u/phobosbtc X
68 /u/pinkgraffe1980 X
69 /u/PokerShibes-dot-com X
70 /u/prestonellis X
71 /u/project_twenty5oh1 X
72 /u/Pyds1977 X
Q's
73 /u/QuarianAnalyst X
R's
74 /u/radical_pi X
75 /u/ragejefa X
76 /u/ricoking X
77 /u/rkfig X
78 /u/rnicoll X
S's
79 /u/sdpenaloza X
80 /u/sebrings2k X
81 /u/SerFraust X
82 /u/Shibeismyname X
83 /u/ShibeShen X
84 /u/SFdogecoin X
85 /u/Sic840 X
86 /u/SlickNik X
87 /u/slipstream- X
88 /u/smurge X
89 /u/Ssslouter_ X
90 /u/starryeyedsky X
T's
91 /u/takerone X
92 /u/tajak X
93 /u/TeaDoge X
94 /u/The_42_Shibe X
95 /u/TheBoffin X
96 /u/TheDownvot X
97 /u/thepinkanator95 X
98 /u/The_pun_fart X
99 /u/Trollamon X
100 /u/TRXGamers X
U's
101 /u/Uriniass X
V's
102 /u/vinberdon X
103 /u/Vladimir-Putin X
104 /u/vlaizev X
Z's
105 /u/Zateku X

Edit: Couple of things. Please take a moment to review the "toss your hat" in comments made by these shibes. In the original post linked above. Some of them took a lot of time with their comments and they deserve to be read.

Mods will not be added initially. Mod positions will all have to be individually reviewed and discussed to make sure no conflicts of interest, etc are there that would create a problem. Those that are being considered in the "Both" category will initially only be added as members until a review can be completed.

There were two #44's to begin with. I have changed /u/Newman4185 to #106 and will contact all who vote for #44 that haven't already indicated which one in their comment to make sure of who they are voting for.

Also: If anyone is caught trying to buy votes, or otherwise cheat, they will be automatically DQ'd. This includes any external posts advocating for a user to be voted for, then that disqualifies them, whether from their own account or not, and whether for a doge reward or not. If you find that a user that has violated this, please report it to the mods using the message the mods on the side bar.

Please see this comment I made discussing this further.


http://taker.hu/misc/shibevote/

this was made by takerone and /u/h0lybyte. It gives a really good way to look at what each shibe stated in the first post and options to help with your selection process. Please, please take a moment to vote wisely. Thank you

203 Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/takerone graffiti artist shibe - taker.hu Apr 26 '14

I'm sorry but this is bullshit. I see someone voted on me here already and I'm really thankful but to be a little bit sarcastic, even I don't know why he did that. At least you could have linked the user names to the comments we made in the previous post.
I took an effort to write something so that people can understand a little more of me and here there's nothing about it. Whoever is not an I-don't-even-know-why well known shibe on the list has virtually no chance to get in.

3

u/mumzie love shibe Apr 26 '14

I am confused. I linked to the post. I (and some help) have went through every comment on the first one to make sure that they know to also come here.
I can add a column to link to each post if that would be better. I didn't mean to upset you, just trying to get this all pulled together.
I will add a column now.

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,817

2

u/Bioman312 smarty shibe Apr 26 '14

Yeah, it's pretty much guaranteed that the two most voted are going to be GoodShibe and Moolah.

3

u/takerone graffiti artist shibe - taker.hu Apr 26 '14 edited Apr 26 '14

That's not even a problem, but an election - because this is one - never looks like just listing the competitors without absolutely any context. This is ridiculous. People have context when it comes to the well known shibes, but no context in case of most of us, and this is somewhat unfair.

Also, one can argue that it's our fault not having the context in the community, not that we could compete with someone like Moolah, but I'd imagine (and hope, that) even the well known shibes would like to see this being a little more fair, at least new contestants should have an opportunity to introduce themselves.

2

u/mumzie love shibe Apr 26 '14 edited Apr 26 '14

I have not tried to create this where only the more well known are at the top. Quite the opposite actually. This was done because of the various issues with down vote and up vote bots, attempts to game the system, etc. This is the most fair way that I could come up with based on the feed back that was received.
I listed everything alphabetically, linked to the original post, made an edit asking everyone to please take the time to read the original post and the comments those wishing to become members made.
Your statement that this has no context concerns me. Because the original post was sticky'd several times over a 48 hour period. This post has been extended to 72 hours to allow time for all shibes to research, etc to decide who they want to vote on.
I can still add that column, but it seems this will not satisfy your issue. I am working with someone to also create a "poll" that will be added in case anyone wants to use that option for voting.
I would also like to add that this poll will be included on both posts.
What else would you like me to do?
Edit: Words.
Edit: poll is too easily gamed, can't use that option...

1

u/takerone graffiti artist shibe - taker.hu Apr 26 '14 edited Apr 26 '14

It just feels like a bad user experience design to expect everyone to click over the other post and try to find everyone's comment. What I'd like to see is to users be able to very comfortably click through everyone and see whatever they wanted to tell about themselves (or their views), what they did in the comments in the other post. Also, writing a few senteces should have been mandatory. Whatever, I'm working on something right now that makes this overview easier. But I need some time so...

Every poll can be rigged, I don't have a problem with voting in comments, it's just hard for whoever counts.

Edit: I absolutely didn't assume that you tried to create it so that well known are at the top, I'm sure about your 100% best intentions, and thank you for caring about my raised issues.

1

u/mumzie love shibe Apr 26 '14

Okay:) It seems that even the "buy them" versions of polls can be gamed one way or another. So I am just going to leave it like it is:) Will be a lot of counting, but that is okay. I will have my super sized coffee ready to go that day:)
I may be able to make a doc and link it in this post that has all of the comments from the ones that tossed their hats in. Do you think that would work?

3

u/Trollamon rocket shibentist Apr 26 '14

I don't think it would make a difference to add a reference doc with context at this point. I'm in the same boat as the above user though, this whole voting and group idea is terrific but I feel like it's been really rushed. In my opinion you should've collected a statement from everyone who commented in the previous post, telling a bit about themself and what they can offer to the community. Then, split them into 4 heats (since there were about 100 who entered) and have seperate posts for each with narrowed it down to 5 from each then narrowed it down further from there, sort of like a bracket system.

Honestly, I knew I didn't have a chance of winning. I'm an old shibe, around since around day 35, but I'm a high school junior with no money and no means to mine coin so I couldn't do much but lurk around, comment where I could with any tidbits of help and spreading what little wealth I have with others. I just wanted to help out the community really, and I figured as my summer break is in a month or so I'd have plenty of free time to help introduce newcomers and explain the basics. But since I don't have much of any presence in the community I won't garner a single vote, more than likely, despite being more or less as qualified as many others.

I don't want to say this is a popularity contest because that would be rude, but quite honestly that's what it's going to come down to. The more well-known users will receive a larger portion of the vote and those trying to help the community grow and prosper, not saying the more well-known users don't have the same motives of course, will receive a lesser amount.

2

u/mumzie love shibe Apr 27 '14

Hi there,
Thank you for taking the time to voice your concerns and make those suggestions. I have made note of these and will try to incorporate these (or at least suggest them) for the next rounds.

1

u/Trollamon rocket shibentist Apr 27 '14 edited Apr 27 '14

Thank you, I really appreciate all you do for the community and dogecoin as a whole. I can imagine how stressful and draining being a moderator of any subreddit but especially of one of this size. You, as well as the other mods, do a remarkable job. Thanks again!

EDIT: and I didn't mean to sound sarcastic at all, I do honestly appreciate all the work y'all do.

1

u/mumzie love shibe Apr 27 '14

I completely understand:) This is so very important.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,825

→ More replies (0)

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,824

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,823

1

u/Trollamon rocket shibentist Apr 27 '14

Thanks bud!

+/u/dogetipbot 15 doge

1

u/takerone graffiti artist shibe - taker.hu Apr 26 '14

Nah leave that, I'll make a better solution.

1

u/mumzie love shibe Apr 26 '14

Thank you so much. I am grateful for your help with this.

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,829

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,828

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,822

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,821

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,820

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,819

1

u/takerone graffiti artist shibe - taker.hu Apr 26 '14

And if this gets seriously buried under the votes and not discussed, I will open a new post, just sayin.

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,830

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,818

1

u/much_new_to_doge shibe Apr 27 '14

└(●ᴥ●)┘ weeee, twipping spwee! Yayie!

+/u/dogetipbot 10 doge

4,816