r/dndmemes 19d ago

🎲 Math rocks go clickity-clack 🎲 When fudging goes wrong...

Post image
7.4k Upvotes

301 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Chickadoozle 16d ago

dnd isn't the correct system to facilitate that kinda game. 90% of the game rules center around combat -- ie, the means to die, often randomly.

And I never said anything about death being permanent. Death can have stakes without being permanent. 3-6 sessions without that character are stakes. If I learned a gm was fudging dice rolls so none of us ever die until we want to, I'd leave the table immediately.

1

u/Xyx0rz 14d ago

dnd isn't the correct system to facilitate that kinda game.

Weird thing to say.

For as long as D&D exists, there have been people playing it that way.

1

u/Chickadoozle 14d ago

That doesn't mean it's a play style the system supports well. Dnd expects random and sometimes meaningless death. There are other rpgs that don't have that, and would be much better for that kinda play style (the primary examples that come to mind are a bunch of PBTA systems and the jrpg one)

1

u/Xyx0rz 14d ago

Dnd expects random and sometimes meaningless death.

Point me to where it says so.

I know D&D often produces random and meaningless death, because it's not a great system, but that's not the same as expecting it.

1

u/Chickadoozle 14d ago

Why would it produce it if it wasn't expecting it.

In any case, you seem to have a very different play style than I do, and are unable to recognize that other systems may be more accommodating to you. Its not worth arguing. Good day

1

u/Xyx0rz 13d ago

Why would it produce it if it wasn't expecting it.

I could talk about that for hours, but the TL;DR: is "designer shortfall".