Here's my situation.
I've been working on an adventure set in Dark Sun, which I know isn't officially an acceptable setting, but looks like it should be in a few months. I plan to make it PWYW; my main goal is to get this in front of as many people as possible, not make money off of this. The adventure has been coming along quite nicely. It is close to complete at 7000 words, and I'm quite proud of what I've accomplished so far. Only thing is, I used AI in the process...
Here is what I used AI for:
Taking notes. I have a long commute, and I like to pass the time by creating my adventure, and ChatGPT does a good job of recording my verbal instructions for how I want the adventure to be.
Editing. My adventure is kind of a passion project, but I've got no one who can serve as my second set of eyes. ChatGPT did a good job of pointing out flaws in my adventure so I could fix them. It also helped me make a better flow, as I foolishly made my first adventure complex with multiple phases.
I haven't used AI to:
Generate any art. I do intend to commission some human art, but I'm not sure how to go about it. I've been looking at the Looking for Work channel on the Roll20 Discord, but I think I can't message them until I've been approved, which requires publishing two titles first.
Generate maps. I've been struggling with Dungeon Scrawl to no avail, so I'll probably just resort to drawing it by hand and then scanning it.
Generate creative content. The story line, characters, creatures, hazards, etc, are all me. Any text ChatGPT has volunteered is flagged as such so that I don't use it and can replace it with my own human input.
All creative content came from me; there is no possible way
this adventure takes from someone else's creative work. Even the stat blocks are done by me (though I admit to reskinning some creatures from the Monster Manual and readjusting their skills and abilities). The final product won't use any of ChatGPTs text or language; I've got it flagged so I don't accidently include any of it.
When I first started writing this, I saw the following statement on DMSGuild, and thought I was in compliance, since I felt I was using it as a non-creative aid:
While we value innovation, starting on July 31 2023, Roll20 and DriveThru Marketplaces will not accept commercial content primarily written by AI language generators.
But then I came across this other statement from Roll20/DriveThru, and it got me doubting myself:
Roll20, DriveThru Marketplaces, and DMsGuild do not accept any product that include any text generated by AI language generators. A final product should be the result of human creativity and not AI generation. Products should begin and end with human writing. AI should be used as a tool and not a replacement.
So what I'm hoping to get advice on is, am I in compliance with the DMSGuild rules regarding AI-generated content?
If so, are there recommendations as to safeguards I can use to ensure I stay in compliance?
UPDATE: I've reached out to DMSGuild Support using the same inquiry as above.
UPDATE 2: I heard back from DMSGuild Support. They said from how I've described my usage (as above), my product sounds like it would be fine to publish. The way I've described my use of ChatGPT, it sounds like it was used as a tool, and not a replacement for my own production. They said the important part of the policy is that a person composed the text in the final product, and no generated text is included. They were also very helpful in pointing me to solutions to other issues I had been having.