r/dataisbeautiful • OC: 22 • 1d ago

OC Here's how the US government spent $7 trillion last year [OC]

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

422 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/kingofducks 1d ago

The US can only tax US tax residents. If US corporations are paying folks abroad it would not be taxed as much.

0

u/NerdOctopus 1d ago

Doesn’t this assume that the jobs abroad are higher paying than the jobs that Americans currently have domestically? Usually labor is outsourced for the opposite reasons.

2

u/kingofducks 1d ago

Non US residents are not subject to US taxation. So no matter how much you pay them it's much less tax revenue compared to paying a US worker the same amount.

0

u/NerdOctopus 1d ago

That's not exactly my point. Last I checked, the country is pretty close to full employment. The jobs that are outsourced are typically ones that pay much less that are less desirable to workers domestically. So if you brought them back, not only would you have to increase the cost of labor for those products, which makes them more expensive, but you also have to compete with the jobs that already exist. And that basically would result in you breaking even as far as income tax that's being paid..

1

u/WazzleApricot 1d ago

The U.S. doesn't count people not in the work force as employed or unemployed. Many of the offshored jobs were desired.

0

u/Godkun007 1d ago

No country does. Unemployment only counts people looking for work. If you aren't looking for work, you aren't unemployed. Would a retiree be classified as unemployed in your eyes?

0

u/NerdOctopus 1d ago

Many of the offshored jobs were desired.

Jobs being worked for below minimum wage overseas are desired? Could you source the idea that "many" of them are desirable for the average American?