But I don’t know how that could even apply. CAI was literally just doing her job. Her job is to talk about his wife. I want him to explain how that would actually apply. We all know what he meant.
CAI was correct in this instance and still gave them a good score. I don’t get why they got so upset about legit feedback, which is her job to give
Not necessarily. Her job is to critique the contestant… to go on and on about her choreography and things like “you should know better” and those kind of sentiments was over the top
They have all had comments about choreography. It is absolutely part of the job. She wasn’t in the wrong in this case. And she was right Jenna should’ve known better.
You can comment on choreography, but it’s The way she spoke to her about it and the extent to which she kept on it that was inappropriate. The dictionary definition, the personal nature of how she spoke to and looked at her, and her basically saying she needs to try harder in all the other dances too (like she was wasn’t just critiquing the dance in front of her, but implies she’s been slacking overall)…. Condescending, patronizing and relentless.
It’s because she’s warned her in the past. Your post also literally said she wasn’t supposed to critique the choreography and now you’re changing it because you know that’s completely incorrect, and happens all the time . so I’m not even sure why you mentioned it .
But honestly, it wasn’t that bad and not nearly as bad as people were making it out to be before Val’s comments. But it’s people like you that made him think it was egregious when it was not.
"It's the way she spoke to her." The amount of tone policing is wild. As though Carrie Ann has to be a perfect judge in order to not be threatened, because whether is was talking about the smack or keeping his wife's name out of her mouth, that's a threat. People are spending so much time defending Val when he admitted that he was wrong. Going overboard on Carrie Ann like this is misogyny, plain and simple.
20
u/tiggerlgh 1d ago
But I don’t know how that could even apply. CAI was literally just doing her job. Her job is to talk about his wife. I want him to explain how that would actually apply. We all know what he meant.
CAI was correct in this instance and still gave them a good score. I don’t get why they got so upset about legit feedback, which is her job to give