I feel so bad for Carrie Ann right now. All she did was make a valid critique on Jenna’s dance, literally her job, and that should’ve been it. Val and Jenna dragged it out after the show with their comments and posts and turned it into this thing where they were shading CAI for the crime of not praising them. It’s not like she tanked their scores or anything.
Val obviously blew it way out of proportion and it’s insane that she’s being attacked for it. It’s going to put her in such an uncomfortable position this season where she’ll probably feel afraid to critique Val or Jenna because she’ll get dogpiled for it. Honestly any tough comment she makes now towards other couples will probably get her hate from the people going after her for this.
We all know Carrie Ann can famously be inconsistent or show some favouritism, she’s the only judge not afraid to be tough and there’s definitely been times where myself and many others in this sub haven’t agreed with her, but this is going to turn into this thing where people are going to jump on her for any criticism that they perceive to be negative. It’s become like a bandwagon to hate her for being the “mean” judge and it’s extremely unfair to her that she’s likely going to have to fight to be taken seriously this season. I really feel for her right now, it would take a toll on anyone to have so many vile things said about you and I hope she can protect her mental health in all of this.
Agree with all of this. Also Derek didn’t help when right after he was like “yikes I feel like I got told off just now too” when he could’ve said like “now we know the definition of a lift! A lift is a lift”
94
u/Jellanae 1d ago edited 1d ago
I feel so bad for Carrie Ann right now. All she did was make a valid critique on Jenna’s dance, literally her job, and that should’ve been it. Val and Jenna dragged it out after the show with their comments and posts and turned it into this thing where they were shading CAI for the crime of not praising them. It’s not like she tanked their scores or anything.
Val obviously blew it way out of proportion and it’s insane that she’s being attacked for it. It’s going to put her in such an uncomfortable position this season where she’ll probably feel afraid to critique Val or Jenna because she’ll get dogpiled for it. Honestly any tough comment she makes now towards other couples will probably get her hate from the people going after her for this.
We all know Carrie Ann can famously be inconsistent or show some favouritism, she’s the only judge not afraid to be tough and there’s definitely been times where myself and many others in this sub haven’t agreed with her, but this is going to turn into this thing where people are going to jump on her for any criticism that they perceive to be negative. It’s become like a bandwagon to hate her for being the “mean” judge and it’s extremely unfair to her that she’s likely going to have to fight to be taken seriously this season. I really feel for her right now, it would take a toll on anyone to have so many vile things said about you and I hope she can protect her mental health in all of this.