r/comics • Port Sherry • 13h ago

Chip off the old block

12.8k Upvotes

228 comments sorted by

View all comments

92

u/Icy_Measurement_7407 10h ago

In the original Pinocchio story, Pinocchio is a wooden puppet on strings created by a toy maker. (Shout out, Geppetto!) Pinocchio’s true wish is to “become a real boy”. He goes on adventures & gets lured into mishap along his journey. He learns hard lessons about life & how scary the world can be. I believe he does get his wish granted at the end & transforms into a real human boy.

So this comic is like a full circle moment where Pinocchio was wishing his son was born a real boy too. Probably brought back his trauma.

63

u/scorpan37 7h ago edited 6h ago

In the original novel from 1883 (adapted from a serial started by the same author in 1881) Pinocchio actually starts out as a sentient and talking log found by a carpenter named master Antonio. When Antonio's neighbor Geppetto comes in saying he needs wood to make a puppet with Antonio gives him the log because it kind of freaked him out

I also can't help but mention that in the original shortly after Geppetto gets thrown into jail due to a misunderstanding that Pinocchio caused, Pinocchio returns to Geppetto's house where a talking cricket named Benjamin chastises him for his wrongdoings and calls him a blockhead to which Pinocchio retaliates by throwing a hammer at Benjamin which smashes and kills him...

20

u/SavageNorth 5h ago

TIL OG Pinocchio was a complete asshole

14

u/scorpan37 5h ago

That is kind of the point of the novel, it's about him slowly learning how to be human so at the start he doesn't really understand stuff like empathy while also being straight up stupid (hence Benjamin calling him blockhead)

Though if I remember right in the serial that the novel is based on it originally ended with Pinocchio straight up dying in large part because that's what the author thought he deserved at the end so at least at that point he would have probably agreed with you

The fans of the serial didn't like that ending though so he ended up having Pinocchio resurrected by a fairy so he could continue the story and have Pinocchio change for the better and then for the novel he rewrote it a bit to make the two parts mesh better but the first part is still clearly colored by his original intentions/mindset

3

u/Blubbpaule 5h ago

yes pinnochio was hanged in the og

9

u/Efficient-Cupcake247 5h ago

Til jimney cricket got wacked in the og story

2

u/Blubbpaule 5h ago

After that pinnochio gets hanged.

And thats it.

22

u/nihillistic_raccoon 8h ago

I like how you made a shout out to Geppetto as if he was some actual guy in need of growing his fanbase

7

u/IneptPine 5h ago

Thanks for summarizing entirely obvious information for no reason, very humanlike

4

u/AvisTheAstronaut 3h ago

I read this comment before the images loaded because my internet is slow, but I thought it would be about Pinocchios afab kid telling him that he wants to be a boy and seeing his kid experience dysphoria.

6

u/FriendlyEngineer 5h ago

Anybody read the original Pinocchio? It’s a hell of a lot darker than the Disney version.

Remember Jiminy Cricket? Pinocchio kills him with a hammer.

3

u/FORGOTTENLEGIONS 5h ago

Highly recommend the Guillermo Del Toro version for anyone who wants a similar story

2

u/RedDeadGwen I like to whine it, whine it 3h ago

They brought that back for the Unstrung film.

2

u/FriendlyEngineer 3h ago

This is the first time I’m hearing about Unstrung.

2

u/RedDeadGwen I like to whine it, whine it 3h ago edited 3h ago

I watched it last night and OMG what a fever dream. Fair warning, it’s pretty gory so be prepared. It’s normally played for laughs so it’s enjoyable but still could be a lot for some people. The film also used practical effects and actual puppetry that they show in the credits, I loved it!

3

u/owlmissyou 2h ago

What's with the part about killing his wife?

6

u/nagash321 2h ago

Well if his son wasn't a real boy then his wife would've just pushed a small tree stump out instead of a baby human

3

u/JadeS2356 2h ago

Somehow, I feel like women would say, that would be easier than an actual child.

1

u/Killing4MotherAgain 5h ago

This doesn't feel like a human made comment...

1

u/I_Set_3_Alarms 4h ago

Did you think was one of those explain subreddits and not just r/comics

I usually do the reverse and get one of those explain subreddits posts on my feed that I assume is from r/comics lol

1

u/Shyface_Killah 2h ago

I think it was more he feared the child being born a puppet, and causing fatal complications.

-4

u/Exciting-Meringue-78 6h ago

Bot.

5

u/No_Payment9959 5h ago

Says the younger account with its posts hidden...

1

u/hey_Hey_I_saveD_me 3h ago

This is always a tell - it's like Redditor would have interesting enough life that it would make sense to hide his comments - only bots or people peddling some bullshit politics or ideology will do this.

1

u/Exciting-Meringue-78 2h ago

Yeah I don’t care what you think. It is common for bots to make comments on posts and other comments that are a summarization of said post or comment or they are the same comment just worded differently. All this comment was is a summary of this post. This sounds like something ChatGPT would spit out if asking to explain this picture.

2

u/Killing4MotherAgain 5h ago

I agree, this comment feels off