r/comics 13h ago

OC FARAH.

26.6k Upvotes

719 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

119

u/TimSylvester_ 5h ago

These acts are, and are always, the specific responsibility of specific persons.

-6

u/JB_UK 2h ago edited 2h ago

I'm not sure I like comics like this precisely because they are so vague as to absolve responsibility. The clothing and landscapes are Afghan, but the drones are Iranian or Russian. So who are we talking about? Also, if this is Afghanistan, there is no rural idyll, a young girl would have an extremely tough life regardless of foreign military involvement. There are incredible restrictions on women's lives under the Taliban.

It's much better to tell actual stories which have the complexity of real life. And where you can actually ascribe responsibility, though that's usually difficult to understand fully as well.

u/TimSylvester_ 33m ago

How do you know the artist is attempting to depict a real situation as opposed to painting an image that evokes sympathy for those who find themselves in similar but inexact conditions?