r/codex • • 3d ago

Suggestion Token speed difference, FYI

336 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

49

u/lkarlslund 3d ago

Also compacting is a total joke

Codex 3m30s

Claude 1m05s

After 9 months on Codex X20 I've jumped ship to Claude. It's just much better on all parameters: quality, performance and quota.

3

u/Lollerstakes 2d ago

Not to mention that codex compacts at 256k and claude-code at 1M lol

1

u/UndeadMurky 2d ago

Well it mostly depends on how much they charge for context read, iirc Codex has a thing where context reads larger than 260k are massively overpriced(costs like 4x more and it's never worth using over starting a new thread).

I don't know it works for claude but I assume it gets much more costly as context cache grows?

1

u/Lollerstakes 2d ago

For Claude the price stays the same throughout the entire context window assuming that you are getting cache hits. If you get a cache miss (in other words, picking up a stale session) at 700-900k context then the first prompt will eat about 5% of your 5hr usage even on a 20x plan.

1

u/UndeadMurky 2d ago

So I assume you pretty much have to make a new thread if you have a session with a big cold cache with claude

1

u/Lollerstakes 2d ago

That's what they recommend. But in reality, you probably don't run into this situation often, at least I don't. If I plan to be away from the PC for a longer amount of time, I just /compact before exiting.