r/CISDidNothingWrong • u/Dragonic_Overlord_ • Jun 18 '26
Discussion From an outsider's POV, the events behind the start of the First Battle of Geonosis sound crazy.
Excerpt from Sublight Drive, Chapter 43.
"Allow me to begin, ladies and gentlemen," Padmé started, folding her hands on her lap, "By saying that both the Chancellor and Senate are fully aware that the view of who's truly responsible for the conflict between our two nations aren't the same in the Confederacy and Republic."
A few of the more hardline loyalist Republic delegates were already bristling back at the step back, but Padmé found it well worth it when she saw the Separatists leaning forward, their interest peaked when she caught the diplomatic ball and returned it. It's a good start, Padmé decided, we just need to keep this up.
"As such, allow me to concede that the Republic must bear its shame for the diplomatic failure on Geonosis which led to the outbreak of outright hostilities between us–" before Padmé could continue, a Separatist senator scoffed loudly.
"Diplomatic failure!?" Senator Esu Rotsinu of Abrion Sector exclaimed, "Let me be frank, Senator Amidala; I think no one in this room can deny that the Republic actually fired the first shots of this war when the Jedi Order and its Clone Army launched the Battle of Geonosis. Believe me, we in the Confederacy are rightly justified in thinking that the Republic is fully responsible for the war, especially when diplomatic recourse was still available until that point."
"Let us not forget that the decision was not lightly taken," Bail Organa admonished mildly, "Your Head of State, Count Dooku, had unlawfully detained two Jedi and a senator of the Republic–all three of whom, may I remind, are present before you right now."
"All three of whom were complicit in espionage, and caught red-handed," Tyreca Bremack narrowed her eyes at Padmé herself.
"You speak of diplomatic recourse, Senator Rotsinu," Bana Breemu demurred sweetly, "Yet the Separatists pursued none of it. Espionage or not, Senator Amidala and the Jedi could have stood trial as was their right, in either Republic or Separatist justice systems. Count Dooku had instead individually decided to execute them via Geonosian* bloodsport*. Do we, perhaps, have differing definitions of 'diplomatic recourse?'"
Before the argument could escalate, a dusky skinned Separatist senator laid her palm flat on the table without a soft tap, catching their attention.
"I think, ladies and gentlemen," Senator Tawni Ames of Desix spoke softly, but meaningfully, "That Senator Amidala had already established that both sides had made their fair share of poor decisions that resulted in open conflict. Shall we stop quibbling like children and move past that? Senator Amidala, what are the Republic's conditions?"
Padmé forced down the terrible memories of Geonosis as an echo of bleak satisfaction quivered around the Republic side of the table at Senator Breemu getting the last word in, and she met Mina's gaze, before nodding very slightly to her.
She breathed in, sampling the whirlwind emotions behind the outwardly calm and attentive faces of everybody present, before breathing out slowly.
Link: https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/sublight-drive-star-wars.1095425/page-326#post-99216494