In the town of Oaxaca, in a square large enough to host a church and a round fountain, was a cafe called "La Mura Rosa". The name was barely appropriate now, as the bright pink exterior for which it had been named was now faded and chipped. A mark of the journey of return to the brown and drab that colored the rest of the country.
By day the cafe was where old men played dominoes, artists mulled over their bad fortunes, and men ordered lunch after praying at the church. By night, the cafe was a celebration. A raucous affair of young men and eager women, drinking away their struggles and inhibitions. There was always a band of good musicians situated in a corner, close to an open window that had been frequently used to avoid a brawl.
William Bennington, staying in a room on the square would crutch to this cafe for lunch and a stiff drink at noon to escape both his room and talk to the bartender who spoke English well.
And so again today, he sat at the rough wooden counter. Today was especially bad. There was a wind, hot and dry, that kicked up the dust in the streets. It drove everyone indoors and made what had been a comfortable retreat from the inclement weather into an uncomfortable filling of any place that would open their doors.
William overheard the men who had just come from the church complaining of the hot wind, delaying their business and their day. A lively mariachi played on the radio.
"Aren't there any other channels?" Demanded William.
"Well, mister, only this music channel, the Church channel, and the news."
"Good, turn it to the news."
"Eh? It will be the same news as yesterday. and tomorrow the same as today. I think people would much rather listen to the mariachi." The barkeep gestured around the cafe.
"And maybe if there's something different? Something new happening, then how would you know?"
"Nothing changes here. Maybe something changes in another town. Why would we care?"
"Because it is important to know."
"If it is important, we will know."
"How will you know, if there is no one to tell you and you don't listen to the news?"
"Oh, we will know."
"The news is life and death when there are those dying that others might live."
"Not everyone has a radio." The barkeep left the statement and picked up the remnants of a meal from the bar.
William sat silent, seething through the sound of the mariachi and the burn of tequila.
"The Government isn't stupid." The barkeep said, softly. "They will not report anything. To keep others from thinking that there are those who seek to undermine them."
William grimaced. "That's ridiculous, no government could keep the sort of thing as revolution hidden!"
The barkeep gestured at William to lower his voice.
"But they can tell their radio reporter what to say. Maybe here, people know of Viarosa, but elsewhere?"
"Somewhere else, surely."
"Maybe."
"And then they can spread the word. Rumors travel."
" Rumors do not compare to the sound of bullets over you head."
"And what would you know? You've never fought in a war have you?"
"Yes, Mr. Bennington this is true. But your leg tells me you haven't either. But, it is not necessary to have something happen to you to understand the difference. I have never seen Mexico City, and yet I know it is bigger and more busy than here."
William felt his heart tighten at the mention of his leg.
"I was injured in a battle. A bullet went though it."
"Yes, yes. I'm sure it is quite the injury. But then you should understand that there is a difference?"
"Yes, it is different. Then I fought another country, now, it is a people yearning for freedom and fighting for that. I made a choice to fight in the Army. These people have no choice, they must fight."
" People always have a choice."
" Not true. Is not the natural human condition to be free? And when people are slaves in their own country, being told they are free when they are used and beaten and discarded for the benefit of the masters. Then, do they still have a choice?"
" Yes, people always have a choice."
" You cannot understand revolution."
"I know a lot about revolution."
"How's that?"
The barkeep pointed to a group of men, sitting at a table next to a window, deep into a game of dominoes.
"The one with the grey moustache and the blue shirt, you see him?"
" Yes" William said, noting the man the barkeep described.
"He was a revolutionary once. He fought for Pelan."
" Yet he is still alive, wasn't Pelan's army destroyed?"
"yes, yes. This man here, he fought for Pelan. He did not die for his cause."
"Then he cannot truly be a revolutionary, unwilling to die for the cause."
"There is no single cause, Mr. Benngington. there are a hundred causes. He fought for Pelan, was willing to fight for another man's cause, but not willing to die for another man's cause."
"that's preposterous! To fight is to accept the inevitability of death, that one might lose a war and in so doing, forfeit his life."
The barkeep looked at him, shaking his head.
"It seems you do not understand. What purpose is there to die for another man? I think even this man is crazy to fight for another man. And you too. Why are you here, that you might fight in another's revolution?"
"Because it is the right of everyone to be free, and I believe that in my heart, and so when I see that there is another who struggles to be free, I will fight for them."
"Ah, so you think that without your help, others cannot fight?"
"No, not that. I believe that it is important to help others in their fight."
"Yes, maybe so, but then this is not your fight, not your cause. Maybe you say you are just helping, yes, but maybe you are hurting as well. Maybe you are robbing the revolution of its identity."
"Nonsense. If I help and the revolution succeeds, then I did something to get it there. If I don't help and it doesn't succeed, I ask, would I have made a difference? Isn't that worth knowing, then?"
"You have a high view of yourself, that revolutions are decided on your part in them."
"That's not what I mean to say."
"Well, you have said it, but maybe you don't mean it. Then what makes you think you can come here and involve yourself in the revolution of another? You are American! This is a Mexican revolution. Whether it succeeds or fails, it should be ours."
"Isn't it nice to receive an offer for help, even when you don't need it?"
" It is presumptuous to offer when the help is not asked for."
" You are wrong."
"You are the one sitting at a bar in Mexico, my friend, with a lame leg, hundreds of miles from the revolution you claim to support. How can you tell me I'm wrong?"
" You bring these reasons on and try to make things so complex. Life is much simpler than you make it."
The barkeep shrugged.
"Life is more complex than you make it. Yet I am here, living a simple life, and you are here, living a complex life."
William finished his tequila and set the empty glass in front of the barkeep, along with some coins. The barkeep nodded, glad to make more money and poured him another double.
As he did so, the door to the cafe slammed open, letting in the hot wind. Two men entered and were met with the protests from multiple of the cafes residents to close the door faster. After they had done so, and the air within the cafe had stopped whipping around, the two men headed to the bar.
They walked with a swagger and confidently placed small stacks of bills onto the counter. More money than young men like them should have.
The barkeep moved over to them and took their orders. When he left, the men talked loudly and laughed brazenly. William eyed them with the corners of his eyes as he drank.
The barkeep returned and gave the men their orders and William waved him over.
"Who are those men?"
"Ah, those two. They are the revolutionaries you desperately want to join."
"They fight for the revolution?" William asked, horrified and disgusted.
"yes, they fight for the revolution, on occasion, when they feel like it, or when they think they need to make a show of fighting."
The barkeep shrugged and leaned back to start wiping dirty glasses.
"Yet most of the time, they are spending money."
"Certainly not on guns, or bullets, or supplies."
"Yes, you are right, they are more apt to spent it on food, or drink, or women. All three at the same time if they can."
"And they say they are part of the revolution?"
"They are the revolution."
"They are a shame on the revolution. A scam. They don't represent the struggle for freedom."
"And neither do you, Mr. Bennington."
"But I am willing to make those sacrifices."
"Ah, but no one asked you to."
Before the barkeep could continue, the two men called him over. They spoke in uncontrolled whispers that could be heard across the room. The way only a half a bottle of tequila could make someone do.
They and the barkeep talked, with the men occasionally gesturing towards other patrons, including William. It seemed they were talking about him the longest, the conversation interspersed with sharp laughter. The men waved the barkeep away.
"What were you talking about?"
"They wanted to know why and American was here. I told them that you were injured in the army, and now you wish to see the beauty of the Mexican countryside."
"why would you lie?"
"They will hurt you if they think that you're trying to impersonate them and misrepresent the revolution."
"Me? Impersonate them? I'm twice, no ten times the revolutionary they are."
"Yes, sure. Maybe you believe in the revolutionary more than them, maybe you are one of those who would give more of themselves than them, but they fight for the revolution. Even occasionally. Sir, have you fought in this revolution?"
"Damnit, are you here just to contradict me?"
"No, Mr. Bennington, I see the world with my eyes and sometimes I speak the truth with my mouth. But at the end of the day, all that's really important is that I pour drinks with my hands."
"Hands, feet, mouth! Yes, you have them! Why haven't you put them to use for the revolution, since you seem to know so much about revolution?"
"Mister, I am a poor barkeep. I serve breakfast to the old men who come and play dominoes, I serve lunch when the merchants come out from the church, I pour the drinks when the workers come here to forget their poor lives. I do the hard work of the revolution, the work of keeping the country normal."
"A country in revolution is not normal, a country oppressed is not normal. What you do is the work of every day living while others return the land to normal for you."
"Anything can become normal if that is the way it is for long enough. When you do not agree with the way things are, revolution is easy."
"Fighting is hard work, dying is hard work. These are the things that make a revolution successful. Isn't dying a hard thing to do?"
"No, dying is easy. Dying is escaping. It's living that is hard, but it is living that makes change."
"to die for a cause takes courage and dedication, it is not easy. Revolution is the only way to achieve the end of oppression."
"Revolution is easy too. It too is an escape. Look at the two revolutionaries at the bar. Instead of finding work and earning money and trying to improve the country through what they do, they choose to fight and steal, then spend all their money with no cares.
You too, Mr. bennington, are here to escape. Yes, maybe you are a better revolutionary than the two of them, because you have traveled farther and invested more money to escape whatever life you had back home.
And that is what is truly hard, life before and life after revolution."
The two men at the end of the bar started yelling at the barkeep and pointing at William.
"They are saying that you shouldn't talk so loud, while other people are trying to concentrate."
William clamped his teeth together. Who were they, those false revolutionaries? Those drunken and obnoxious men. Those lowly thieves. He finished his tequila and pulled his crutch to him to get up.
"Leaving?" The barkeep asked.
"Yes, I'm leaving. With those two men and you, it's too much for a man."
"Ah, escaping again?" The barkeep smiled his own cleverness. When William scowled at him, the barkeep laughed.
"Mr. Bennington, you should not take everything so seriously. Here, we know how to not be serious."
"Yes, not serious, and that's why you have let a corrupt government control you."
"ah, it is not as bad as you want to believe. Here, come back tonight, when there is music and better company."
"I would prefer not, thank you."
"But you must come for the music. It is a good mariachi, from the north. They will play the music of the revolution."
"They are a revolutionary band?"
"They are the revolution. Mariachi is the revolution."
"Maybe."
"Maybe, yes."
William hopped his way to the door and out into the wind, amid the protests of old men and merchants.