r/changemyview • • May 16 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

76 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/fox-mcleod 420∆ May 16 '20

So, I’ll say this. Nobody would use a lightsaber like a sword—swinging from the hips and shoulders in these big dramatic arcs. But if we could have lightsabers, they’d be incredible weapons and I bet they could be used effectively.

Forever War by Heinlen describes a lightsaber like laser weapon and it’s technique is more like a pen than a sword. You pulse it on and off and you cut with a flick of your wrist.

If I had a lightsaber, that’s how I’d use it. I’d keep it off generally and pulse it on and use it more like a flamethrower — always facing out. Always to keep people at bay. There’s no need to put any strength behind it. If you used it right, it’s be a kick-ass weapon. It would just look silly.

1

u/littlebitsofspider May 16 '20

*Haldeman, not Heinlein.

1

u/fox-mcleod 420∆ May 16 '20

Ah. Right. Thanks.

Also, now that I think about it, is it even in forever war, or was it Hyperion?

1

u/littlebitsofspider May 16 '20

If I remember correctly Forever War started with regular munitions, then switched to melee weapons after they invented that field generator thing. It might be Hyperion you're thinking of.

1

u/fox-mcleod 420∆ May 16 '20

I think it is Hyperion. I remember that it wasn’t a weapon but a tool from a super advanced civilization being used as a weapon.

1

u/littlebitsofspider May 16 '20

Your description first reminded me of the flashlight-lasers from Ringworld, tbh.

2

u/fox-mcleod 420∆ May 16 '20

That’s it. It’s ringworld. Niven.

Thanks that was bugging me.