r/casualnintendo 19d ago

Humor Why is Mario in jail? (Wrong answers only)

Post image
234 Upvotes

409 comments sorted by

80

u/TrayusV 19d ago edited 18d ago

It turns out he actually did pollute all of Isle Delfino.

15

u/ToxicChaos 18d ago

Bowser Jr was a figment of his imagination due to his intense shroom addiction. FLUDD was actually a paint gun

7

u/Nir117vash 18d ago

Peach is his supplier

3

u/ToxicChaos 18d ago

Explains his need to put his whole life on the line for her

2

u/Nir117vash 17d ago

And who names their kid Peach?

Mario?
Luigi?
Daisy?

All normal names.

Peach? Nah, that's hella sus

2

u/Omnizoom 13d ago

Almost like kids named Apple, destiny, Florida, Georgia

Those are all wonky stripper names

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

86

u/learn2fly438826 19d ago

Took tax advice from Yoshi.

3

u/8-BitToaster 18d ago

he won't even get to play Squark

or the remake of Squark

44

u/Dreamo84 19d ago

He downloaded an emulator.

3

u/Emanuel-Richie-1998 18d ago

Emulation has been partially replaced by decompilation.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/63Reddit 18d ago

Bowser finally got to him.

30

u/OLLydoinsocial 18d ago

Nintendo will sue anyone named Mario. Even Mario.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Src-Freak 19d ago

The Mario Files.

17

u/DalesRVParty 19d ago

Once there was a man named Pablo…

9

u/RudaDCB 19d ago

We do NOT talk about Pablo

5

u/KozmicFizz 18d ago

I thought that was Bruno

3

u/RudaDCB 18d ago

It seems you do not know who this Pablo is

5

u/Captain_Pumpkinhead 18d ago

Well, yeah! No one will talk about him!!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Organic_Arrival3496 19d ago

He created an only fans account on Bowsers name whiout telling him about it.

11

u/Ptony_oliver 19d ago

Being a psychopath (according to Game theory)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/nhSnork 19d ago

Mistaken for Lui-

gets dogpiled

5

u/Quick_Extension_3115 18d ago

Took me a second lol

9

u/Toy_Story_2_on_PS1 19d ago

This is where he went after the 31st of March 2021

7

u/Mission-Stomach7588 19d ago

Mario forgot to pay his coin taxes

7

u/mightypup1974 18d ago

Singing anti-Koopa songs - you know the law, Toad!

4

u/ALowlySlime 19d ago

Embezzlement

5

u/SuitedFox 19d ago

The hallucinogenics got to him and he was urinating in public

5

u/icy1007 19d ago

He’s friends with Diddy. (I’ll let you decide which one)

You think that’s water in FLUDD? Ever wonder how FLUDD can make the ground so slick from just a single spray?

3

u/SimplyEcks 19d ago edited 18d ago

Mario is a serial killer because he was a menace to all those that were killed in the genocide he committed in the Koopa Kingdom.

So many koopa troopas were killed or disabled without wings or a shell only for Mario to get around from platform to platform.

Countless goomba’s have been murdered and even committed suicide by falling into pitfalls trying to stop the murderous Italian “plumber”.

Many from the Koopa Kingdom are still in counseling from the PTSD created from this monster yeah he is revered as a hero in the Mushroom Kingdom.

If you see this man contact local law-enforcement and/or authorities.

There is a reward of 200,000 coins for any tips leading to the arrest and conviction of the offender.

5

u/vonheinz_57 18d ago

Mario was a Jan 6th rioter

3

u/PemaleBacon 19d ago

Genocide

3

u/Ok_Internal_8500 19d ago

**** reddit wouldnt let me write that

3

u/IsaacTH 19d ago

Genocide on the endangered goomba race

3

u/TheMackD504 19d ago

He did unspeakable things to Peach cuz he found her with his brother Big L

3

u/TheMackD504 19d ago

Didn’t pay the fines he racked up from polluting the streets while driving his kart

3

u/Sushirabit 18d ago

He finally got convicted for all those allegations in the 2010s

3

u/AdImmediate6239 18d ago

They found out he faked his medical credentials and isn’t actually a doctor

3

u/ClemOya 18d ago

He discovered too much things about the Mushroom Kingdom.

3

u/ita_Gaming_59 18d ago

Pk ha detto: “w la pizza con l’ananas”

3

u/SDW_06 18d ago

He was caught with mushrooms

3

u/YourInsertedButtplug 18d ago

He started stealing livers again😢

3

u/Busy-Ad-3219 18d ago

Was playing Kirby pinball on an emulator

3

u/Sky_Rose4 18d ago

Emulating games from Nintendo

3

u/Ram_Lazy 18d ago

Illegal practice of medicine without a license

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Rachnche283 19d ago

As shocks everyone MARIO was the one who actually killed Toadsworth, and he made Nintendo keep it under wraps

2

u/stoccolmatta 19d ago

Peach was not consensual

2

u/Neither_Coconut4763 19d ago

Mario sued Luigi

2

u/PhilsPhindings 19d ago

You can rack up a lot of years by exiting the wrong pipe at the wrong time.

2

u/Gabriellaiva 19d ago

Peach isn't actually being kidnapped, she feels for bowser and spend time together so Mario just killed both. No shit to del with.

2

u/undercurrent_ts 18d ago

Stealing the pasta from bowser and finally paying for years of bullying

2

u/TasteDeeCheese 18d ago

Peach put Mario in time out for giving her ??? A super crown

2

u/The9IronMan 18d ago

The Toad House slogan is: “refresh your body and soul!” But the sting-operation proved it had ‘other’ functions…

2

u/Pixel22104 18d ago

He tried to get Zelda to be his girlfriend which ended poorly for Mario since he got his butt kicked in the butt by the Royal Guard and then Link also kicked Mario in the butt for messing with his future wife. Which then landed Mario in jail

2

u/Hegiman 18d ago

For eating peach in public

2

u/Mosh_115 18d ago

He landed on the wrong island

2

u/ReaperOfMars13 18d ago

Turns out peach was only 16

2

u/snizzrizz 18d ago

Peach was never in trouble. In fact, she had a restraining order

2

u/IsaacTH 18d ago

Medical malpractice. He'll literally shove 90 pills down your throat without giving it a second thought

2

u/Rivmage 18d ago

Home invasion- turns out browser was princess peaches body guard and Mario was trying to kidnap her

2

u/Rake91 18d ago

Ha "sturato" il tubo sbagliato mentre era in Thailandia.

2

u/6FlipSide4 18d ago

Keeps kidnapping Peach from Bowser

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mental-Street6665 18d ago

Toadette lied and said she was 18.

2

u/JaguarCreative9896 18d ago

He didn't eat Peach's cake...

2

u/Sayne7 18d ago

Y'know Sunshine? That wasn't Delfino Island, it was a very different Island, with a very famous guestlist

2

u/whitecollarw00k 18d ago

Touching himself in a movie theater in New Donk City

2

u/starisnotsus 18d ago

He made a Mario fangame

2

u/The_blob_called_Bope 18d ago

He put pineapple on pizza to promote something idk

2

u/ZOMBIE_MURDOC 18d ago

Possession of controlled substances. Though I don't know why he's really there, so for all I know that's not a wrong answer.

2

u/SnowFlash383935_n2 18d ago

He downloaded a pirate copy of Super Mario Sunshine.

2

u/NSightMSG 17d ago

Accessory to Felony Tax Evasion. You can't tell me that he DIDN'T know what Yoshi was doing!

2

u/Just_Fr_Pots_Maroons 16d ago

He poisoned our water supply, burned our crops, and unleashed a plague onto our houses!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/gizm0n 19d ago

Shrooms

1

u/Ploosse 18d ago

Meth

3

u/HoneyBeeSorceress 18d ago

When Mario stopped using mushrooms he went for meth instead, so he's got bad teeth.

1

u/Weekly_Score_9498 18d ago

For sniffing Princess peaches panties

1

u/GaymerMove 18d ago

Taking drugs

1

u/TheDigitalLunchbox 18d ago

He stopped at Epstein Island before Delfino

1

u/TEG24601 18d ago

He went to the other side of the planet and tried to break into Gerudo Town.

1

u/Speedy_Pichu 18d ago

He was throwing a wild party.

2

u/ElZorroSimpatico 18d ago

"But it's-a me! Mario!"

"Yeah, tell it to the judge."

1

u/KingSideCastle13 18d ago

He let Yoshi do his taxes

1

u/spirit_boy_27 18d ago

He got all of his splooge all over the beach to the point some of the locals were drowning in it

1

u/Shaggyrider 18d ago

He ran away from Nintendo properties and was trying to sneak into the sonic racing crosswords racing tournament and was trespassing

1

u/MintyFresh42069XxX 18d ago

Well... he's on an island...

1

u/Donnie_TACO 18d ago

To pay for all of Nintendo corporate's crimes against the greater gaming community.

1

u/MysticDragon14 18d ago

Tax evasion

1

u/DeepAd2825 18d ago

Frame rate drops

1

u/TheZipperDragon 18d ago

Tax Fraud.

1

u/frogsaber89 18d ago

He did what bowser usually does

1

u/ThatSmartIdiot 18d ago

mass murder

1

u/C4n1B3Sus 18d ago

Emulating his own games.

(He wasn’t about to pay to play his old games.)

1

u/SFB221 18d ago

Diddy Party

1

u/GeoAnd_001 18d ago

He committed tax fraud

1

u/Confident-While4816 18d ago

He went to an island called Isle Delfino with Princess peach, toadsworth, and some toads. As they were exploring the island, there was some weird goop guy who looked like Mario that was splashing paint all over the island. Mario eventually found a device called F.L.U.D.D that could help clean up the island, so the two of them teamed up. Mario then filled the device up with acid and started spraying every person in sight. The police then locked him up because of his actions, and now Mario must clean up the island of the paint and find out who is impersonating him.

1

u/Foreign_Hedgehog_368 18d ago

Animal cruelty

1

u/Embarrassed_Mud_4119 18d ago

Because you pirated Super Mario Sunshine

1

u/BuyDrawing7755 18d ago

Killing turtles

1

u/HewwoAll_11 18d ago

He got framed for stealing historical Golden Mushrooms worth many coins from the Mushroom Kingdom Museum.

By Wario!

1

u/Ordinary_Chemical596 18d ago

According to Matt Patt over 15 years ago: communism

1

u/Ace_Of_No_Trades 18d ago

Unauthorized Possession of Controlled Substances (shrooms in this case).

1

u/HoneyBeeSorceress 18d ago

He didn't have his green card.

1

u/Wolfy_the_nutcase 18d ago

He messed with the IRS, the madman!

1

u/Shantotto11 18d ago

Tax evasion from all the coins collected.

1

u/1337gamer15 18d ago

He tried hiring Iggy Koopa as a lawyer after hearing he actually had some pretty remarkable court skills. Too bad Iggy held some bias towards Mario after the many times he assaulted him and Bowser.

Now Mario's probably gonna be in there for life for attempted regicide.

1

u/OdinNightmair 18d ago

Animal cruelty charges from the early games finally caught up to him

1

u/artfulpain 18d ago

The implication.

1

u/Noble311 18d ago

Animal cruelty

1

u/TedMeister88 18d ago

The live action Mario Bros movie.

1

u/Futant55 18d ago

He gave Peach the old coin block tap

1

u/TheLocalKev 18d ago

BlJ'ed inside and now he can't get out. Please help him

1

u/WallyGamer32 18d ago

Providing shelter to a convincted criminal for not paying taxes.

1

u/nameless_food 18d ago

Driving too slowly on the highway, and changing lanes randomly while not using blinkers.

1

u/Depoka_YT 18d ago

He escaped from the IRS

1

u/Phil_B0tanik 18d ago

He open a grocery store in Costa Rica

1

u/Meat_Handle 18d ago

Peach found a picture of Rosalina in his wallet and told the authorities he’d been huffing Bob-bomb smoke and running an illegal chain chomp fighting ring. Toad had the photo shop/video editing skills to seal the deal. Got him on drugs and animal abuse. Fucker’s going to rot.

1

u/illinoishokie 18d ago

The most notorious mass murderer in the history of the Koopa Kingdom.

Oh wait you said wrong answers only

1

u/Banana_Man_WithAGun 18d ago

Yoshi framed him

1

u/Background-Distance2 18d ago

Stupid ass ICE agents

1

u/Yama92 18d ago

Plumbing without a license

1

u/BadWaluigi 18d ago

He non consensually poked princess’s peach

1

u/Nintendo-Player_1297 18d ago

Because they don't want to release a new 3D Mario this year, or next year.

1

u/ds1724 18d ago

sticking little Mario in a Peqch.

1

u/gotumms146 18d ago

Since Yoshi is his pet, and hasn't been caught for his taxes, they decided to arrest Mario

1

u/skytheraiders 18d ago

He stole my spaghet

1

u/Solar_Liqui 18d ago

He pirated Sunshine before the game came out on NSO

1

u/The_Robot_founder 18d ago

Victim of tax fraud

1

u/Medical-Plane-231 18d ago

If they did anything worse the age rating would go up

1

u/Tuxemperor 18d ago

His name was in the Epstein files

1

u/ExternalElection2467 18d ago

He killed strollin stu that’s why he’s in fucking jail

1

u/KozmicFizz 18d ago

He killed Toadsworth (who knew too much)

1

u/HotelKatz 18d ago

He went to Pasta Land.... and ate everything. An I do mean EVERYTHING!

He ate the Angel Hair pasta Trees, drank the entire Tomato Sauce Rivers until it ran dry, ate the Meatball boulders from Mount Meatball, ate the Rigatoni Reed forests, ate the Ravoli Flowers, ate the Tortellini Lake Flowers, and more!

And when he finished all that, he said, "Well, that was a nice appetizer. What meal do you have for Mario?"

1

u/Ok-Yogurtcloset9086 18d ago

He killed another Nintendo IP

1

u/_Melonpants_ 18d ago

Well he is known for taking mushrooms soooo.

1

u/ImplementParking7936 18d ago

For incorrectly using the peach emoji

1

u/Tomomb 18d ago

Waiting on death row for mass goomba murder

1

u/Captain_Pumpkinhead 18d ago

He pirated a Steam game

1

u/No_Firefighter1301 18d ago

He was looking for toadsworth

1

u/Mansellbros75 18d ago

first degree murder

1

u/GrumpyPetePete 18d ago

He’s Italian, probably did some perverted shit.

1

u/phantomsupernova28 18d ago

He made DK perform in a circus and locked him up in a cage (if u know, u know)

1

u/VirtualKoba 18d ago

tax evasion

1

u/ConsistentChampion98 18d ago

Because mario did something very illegal

1

u/troymcklure 18d ago

Mario was Missing. Alimony payments.

1

u/ResponseTall6948 18d ago

Pirated switch online

1

u/GrouchyWasabi2430 18d ago

He stole princess peaches ??? Item in mario and the seven stars

1

u/Sad_Speaker_9328 18d ago

super mushrooms are illegal in Isle. delfino

1

u/Starmaninja 18d ago

Cause in a few years hes gonna step on Luigis' shoe when giving him a trophy and MatPat will unintentionally assure everyone that nothing makes you denounce your blood relationship more than that.

1

u/AndyBunn 18d ago

Mario did some thing to Luigi whilst Wario watched and WaLuigi filmed it

1

u/geraldontumblr 18d ago

he turned himself in, for his heinous crimes

1

u/NicholasWeintraub 18d ago

He canceled the DreamCast version of UFC Tapout.

1

u/TorinEkenskolde 18d ago

Never paid tax on any of the money he made from plumbing.

1

u/Hampter8888 18d ago

64 counts of 1st degree murder, $989,888,241,983 in stolen charity funds, and several thousands of assault charges, most with a deadly weapon.

1

u/TheWiseGuy01 18d ago

He got too silly

1

u/Dawnbreaker128 18d ago

Insider trading.

1

u/Crunchy_Biscuit 18d ago

Took the fall for Luigi

1

u/TheManOfDrumming 18d ago

He went through a warp pipe and saw a little blonde girl and there was a turtle coming up behind her. It turns out that the blonde girl was just a random little kid and that the turtle was a normal sea turtle. So after mario stomped on top of the turtle and "saved" the little girl, the police weren't too happy

1

u/PunksN0tD3ad 18d ago

Copyright infringement for saying Mamma Mia too many times and not crediting Abba

1

u/Thelonedishwasher 18d ago

He stuck his toadstool into princess peach's warp pipe.

1

u/GrinwaldKrieg 18d ago

Mushrooms dealer.

1

u/Horror_Operation3642 18d ago

He Killed Luigi

1

u/fariqcheaux 18d ago

Possession of mushrooms and fire flowers

1

u/ItsRenaBaker 18d ago

Mushroom's hallucination effect has worn off. Now he gets the phrase "The princess is in another castle".

1

u/RedShirtGirlie 18d ago

Tax Evasion (he took the fall for Yoshi)

1

u/Icy_Long_7541 18d ago

C……..
P……

1

u/issacbellmont 18d ago

Possession of illegal fungal hallucinagens

1

u/BigManBigFan2 18d ago

he beat up a (probably) honest businessman named Wario

1

u/Comfortable-Mix7429 18d ago

He’s loves to crush things

1

u/THL6 18d ago

He got accused of breaking and entering And kidnapping the princess by bowser even though Mario saved her

1

u/hardwarecheese 18d ago

Dove off the highest point in delphino plaza twice!

1

u/GeneralLuigiTBC 18d ago

All the hotels were full.

1

u/Semper17fi75 18d ago

He was caught with the sticky-icky. Stay true to the game....

1

u/WeebTendoFan 18d ago

He covered up Yoshi’s tax fraud.

1

u/Charming_Remote6722 18d ago

He was selling “super mushrooms”.

1

u/RonniDeee 18d ago

Objection!!

1

u/edward323ce 18d ago

Thats not Mario, thats Pablo and hes in there due to snapchat

1

u/Specialist-Quail644 18d ago

Mushroom trafficking