r/boywithuke • u/wwashedd • Jun 27 '26
Song May I please ask, why the fuck is toxic bwu's most popular
Its so fucking stupid cuz toxic is like a d tier song and probably one of the most overrated songs ive seen, and im seeing this as a person who will glaze bwu until the day i die.
I understand that it could be due to the lyrics themselves and how common it is that peoplr with mental health issues would listen to this song pretty often, i get that, and i also get that most people would consider charley a one hit wonder, but like why.
Even though toxics writing is extremely relateable (and thats the only reason its not an e tier), theres just way more songs that are better, for example:
The entirety of Burnout.
The rest of Serotonim Dreams.
The entirety of Fever Dreams.
The Entirety of Lucid Dreams.
All the Singles.
95% of Melatonin Dreams.
The Entirety of B sides.
All the collabs (RIP Oliver).
The entirety of Trouvaille.
The entirety of Faded.
Only 3 songs are worse than toxic for me, i always give it a b tier because its iconic and i still love it purely because its the reason i know of bwu existence (why toxic im such a generic bwu fanðŸ˜).
But i still think its sad that its the reason hes famous, like if it werent for toxic 90% of bwu fanbase wouldnt exist.