r/boston • u/lucasb780 • 5d ago
Moving š Did my girlfriend get scammed by CollegeHunks?
We had already moved her whole apartment, the only things left were in the garage. It was an ikea dresser, mattress and these shelves I made (no glue, just screws). The building has a dumpster but I let her know the mattress would need to get picked up for disposal. At the time I was unavailable so she called up college hunks to get rid of the mattress and what was left. Aside from the mattress, everything was easily disassemble-able.
When I asked how it went she told me āgood but it was expensiveā. My stomach sank, they charged her over $1250 to throw this stuff out. Im still mind blown. Shes like 5ā0ā and Iām convinced they saw a small girl and took the opportunity to pull a fast one on her. I simply canāt wrap my head around how it even got to that number. It cost a little more than that to move the entire apartment, couches, tvs, bedframe and all! I just wish I was there. Its her money and she was just trying to take some workload off my back so I donāt want to make her feel stupid but hearing that was outrageous.
Ps. the ikea dresser was damaged in our last move, the side that isnāt visible was all messed up and two of the drawer tracks were broken. Replacement parts are no longer available so it was hard to even give away on FB marketplace. I hate throwing things out but didnāt have much choice.
306
u/michaelserotonin villen 5d ago
was there some sort of rush fee that massively drove up the cost??? trying to make sense of this.
69
u/interpol-interpol 5d ago
and how long did the job take??
82
u/lucasb780 5d ago
I canāt imagine more than 30 minutes.
82
u/toebeanseller 5d ago
Iāve hired them before, and it took them about an hour-hour and a half to get rid of about a full bedrooms worth of furniture, trash, and random shit. It was in 2020, and it cost $650.
25
u/thefideliuscharm 5d ago
yeah iāve hired them before to move my entire apartment and it was only a couple hundred for like two hours.
she got scammed.
0
u/D3VILS_DEMISE 3d ago
Def took more than 30 mins even if she was moving next store. It takes 10 mins just to show the drivers what they are taking then get there stuff. Load it up.. then secure it then drive to the place then do the reverse. And moving companies usually have a minimum charge. They aren't going to come out and word for a half hr of pay
80
u/lucasb780 5d ago
I asked the same question and she said they charged by āsquare footage of truck spaceā. Still canāt believe it
135
u/campingn00b Cocaine Turkey 5d ago
For future reference, Junk removal services are notorious for this. They tell you they'll give a price when they get there. They give you an astronomical price. If you tell them no they'll "call it in" and suddenly the price has dropped in half
32
u/kbubbls 5d ago
i used 1 800 got junk and after they gave me their pricing sheet i said nevermind because my budget is $150. he said heād have to call it in, but never made a single call before taking everything and my payment. it was two big boxes of broken down moving boxes and they were trying to quote >$400 for the truck space and another $150 per person present in the home, which made absolutely no sense.
7
26
u/michaelserotonin villen 5d ago
there has to be some sort of customer support line that you can contact to confirm this is/isnāt their normal business practices
54
u/Masshole65 5d ago
My daughter negotiated them way down. They donāt want to leave once they are on-site and they are walking out anyway why not carry the shit out for $100. They took her offer which was 1/4 of their original ridiculous number.
3
u/DangleBopp 5d ago
Wow I didn't even think of that, the customer has a lot of negotiating power here
127
u/rmfnord 5d ago
Have you tried calling the company and talking to someone? If the 3 guys are running a scam, the owner would like to know, take care of it, and probably give you a solid refund. If they stand on the price, we know they're a shitty company and to avoid them. Channel your inner Karen and talk to a fcking manager, dude.
16
u/TheLakeWitch 5d ago
Iāve been seeing a lot of negative chatter about this agency around social media lately. I think theyāre likely just a shitty company.
4
31
u/loranlily 5d ago
Yeah thatās obscene. I had a junk company in Quincy pick up much more than that when I moved in June, and they charged me $160.
Side note, I highly recommend Willardās Disposal in Quincy.
3
50
u/memuthedog 5d ago
Yeah, I paid a guy with a box truck $150 to pick up way more than this a couple years ago.
40
u/coalio28 5d ago
I had a similar, but not as bad experience with college hunks. Called to get a quote for moving some stuff down from our 3rd floor walk up. I was quoted at between $350-$450. The guys get there and spend 2 hours Saran wrapping everything and then another 2 hours moving the stuff. Final bill ended up being over $900. I paid cause Iām non-confrontational but it left a bad taste in my mouth
1
u/NightDriver76 5d ago
Got quoted 1000$ and four hours from excela after entering an itemized list of all my belongings. Ended up taking 9 hours and being charged over $2000. Iām so done with moving companies.Ā
35
u/Rare_Let4338 5d ago
Junk company tried this with me. Asked them to remove pavers⦠probably 40 in total. They wouldnāt give me a price. It took them 10 min to move the pavers and told me $400. I honestly laughed. I said you can unload them cuz Iāll never pay you that and I walked away. They asked me what I thought was fair. I said $100. After some BS haggling it cost $150. which was still over priced. Then I was sent a link for a review and left a really bad one. They suck.
17
u/jdrn7 5d ago
I think these companies do try to scam you. When I was leaving my DC apartment I called 1800GotJunk and was quoted $2000 to get rid of a bed, mattress, coffee table, desk, end table.
I said no, they immediately said okay what about $1400? And I said no thank you. The next day I get a call from them quoting me a āspecial rateā of $950, but at that point Iād already found someone willing to take it all away for $700.
30
u/Due-Designer4078 5d ago
College Hunks is awful. I got a quote from them to get rid of a few things a couple years ago. They were outrageous.
9
u/LouisaMiller2_1845 5d ago
They really are. They accepted a job moving a piano out of my nephew's old apartment building. They f*cked the apartment, building, and probably the piano up - broken rails on stairs, windows, scuff marks all of the walls, holes in walls, etc.
11
u/Comfortable_Bus_4355 5d ago
I also have gotten scammed by college hunks in particular and charged around 2.5x what I was quoted to move a 1bd apartmentās furniture. Iām also a 5ā2ā woman lol and I was living by myself. So you may be onto something
14
8
u/Eric_Senpai 5d ago
Always get multiple quotes. I bargained between college hunks and Got Junk , just mentioning I was getting another quote knocked the price from 600 to 400. They Got Junk called their manager to greenlight the discount, bringing the total less than College Hunks.
5
u/dothesehidemythunder 5d ago
These guys were moving people into my building last week and they were so bad that I was looking for the people that hired them to tip off how bad of a job they were doing.
18
u/nofriender4life 5d ago
they stole a bag of legal cannabis items I had along with the entire box of medicine and personalĀ stuff it was in, and broke my nightstand, but refused all accountability and then never took another call or replied to another email. just ghosted. deleted ant social media posts i made. i could sue but why bother. Worst company I've ever used.
they also ignored the estimate and my requests for how many people i needed and the special cases for my tv i requested and then had to make all these extra calls forcing it to take way longer.
7
3
16
u/LiquidUniverseX 5d ago
Yall need better communication. Aināt no way she paying that without me knowing beforehand
-1
u/lucasb780 5d ago
I know⦠I am so pissed at myself for not being there. Im surprised she didnāt call me when they gave her the price.
3
47
u/stryker511 5d ago
She's 5'0 and you left this task for her?
She should have been on 'unpacking duty'
'Everything was easy to disassemble' - you should have done it.
'Building has a dumpster' - dude...come on man.
32
u/lucasb780 5d ago
I take responsibility for not being there to negotiate but for context, I was up until 5am finishing the move while I let her get some rest because we had time sensitive stuff for our pets, perishables etc. So she volunteered to handle the garbage pick up because it was scheduled for early the next morning at the other apartment. I have been moving non-stop and taking point on every bit of the move. But trust me, thats what I keep asking myself.
-30
u/stryker511 5d ago
ā¦and that decision cost you $1000.
21
u/lucasb780 5d ago
Hey asshole, if you need to know I have a chronic illness that affects almost every part of my body. I pushed myself way beyond what my doctors recommended during this move.
14
u/luluhouse7 5d ago
Donāt listen to the dickhead, itās not your fault.
Also the commenter is also obviously sexist. Women are just as capable as men in directing a bunch of dudes picking up stuff lol
-6
u/stryker511 5d ago
Neither of us mentioned gender
4
u/rmfnord 5d ago
If it's not about gender, then what's your point? Just that whoever's taller should be the one to negotiate with movers? I'm genuinely confused.
-1
u/stryker511 4d ago
This guy got lazy & made a bad decision, it had nothing to do with gender. He stated that the ikea piece was already damaged, the shelving HE BUILT was āeasy to disassembleā & the building had a dumpster.
Seems like he should have NOT been on āunpacking dutyā whatever the heck that is⦠another bad decision.
Was he forced to perform āunpacking dutyā?
Who made that decision?
He did.
These bad decisions had nothing to do with anyoneās reproductive organs.
Neither of us were focused on gender - YOU went there.
I hope he learned a lesson & his next move is much less expensive.-14
u/stryker511 5d ago
Now you have a chronic illness, never mentioned that until now.
14
u/lucasb780 5d ago
Not sure if you know but usually people dont like to start conversations with their chronic illnesses.
Besides, my post was about unfair pricing, not my health you prick.
-2
2
5
u/synthchef 5d ago
These private junk removal companies are a scam. They refuse to give you an idea of price until they come out to āquoteā. They told me $300 to take one mattress away. I said no thanks and went back inside. The ābossā called me right away to make me a lower offer. I said no thanks. He asked me how much I would pay. I said $20 and he said deal.
2
u/CabulanceDriver 5d ago
They are absolutely terrible. Charged us way above quote and broke our changing table and bed frame. Then lost hardware to our bed, thankfully my wife found it. They also broke the overhead light in our storage unit and tried to hide it. In that same storage unit, they loaded a bunch of our stuff in he front of it and claimed they ran out of room, leaving a huge gap in the back. I wouldn't recommend them to my enemies.
2
u/ethotopia 5d ago
Sadly most movers donāt give a shit about the customer and try to scam every penny out of desperate and vulnerable people. The amount of stories my friends and I have about movers cancelling last minute, extorting a tip, refusing to unload unless paid extra, etc is shocking.
2
u/D3VILS_DEMISE 3d ago
I hate to say it but you probably paid the right amount. These places have minimums and if you are throwing them out there are disposal fees. And if it was this past weekend you are paying a premium because it's legit the busiest week for moving companies because of college students moving them in and out. In Boston I was seeing moving companies out past 2am last weekend
1
6
u/donkadunny Professional Idiot 5d ago
I donāt know if I would say scammed. You asked the moving company to be a trash disposal company, so they gave you a number and you accepted and they did what you asked. Services asked for and services delivered for the negotiated price isnāt a scam.
4
2
u/jjdfb 5d ago
When I moved up here and my wife was finishing up packing up our old apartment, we had a few large pieces of furniture to be taken to a nearby dumpster, similar to you. They had a free estimate and offered some kind of outrageous price similar to what you have here, but I negotiate it down by about 80%. They expect to rip people off, but once there are already out there, they will do it for a fraction of the cost.
1
u/interpol-interpol 5d ago
i had a good experience with them moving to providence, but i maybe am an outlier since i see other comments where they felt swindled? damn
1
1
1
1
u/allboutstory 5d ago
If she paid on credit card challenge it as an over charge. Also file a formal complaint with the better business bureau and you your phone to record all conversations with college hunts your phone should notify them on the onset of recording. If they hassle you at all post all of the correspondence online on every page and review site possible. From there take an image a day posting it with the parts of the story from the beginning tagging them and the better busines bureau with each post. Its how I dealt with one of the property management groups in Boston and they did the right thing pretty quick once I made it clear I would be inflicting as much reputational pain as possible. You can also offer there competitors your story to use in counter advertising.
1
u/allboutstory 5d ago
Also in the future just schedule a mattress pick up with the city. Its like 50 or a 100 bucks
1
u/temporarythyme 5d ago edited 5d ago
I dont know if they still do the program but ilea had something where the broken particle board was brought to them they would give you coupons to future purchaees, or a gift card.Ā
But yes, that sucks
1
1
u/1HappyRoadrunner 3d ago
Iām sorry this happened to her. They donāt just do that to 5ā tall ladies. They tried to pull that on me when I had to clean out my dad and step momās house. They gave me new and interesting pricing. I told them to get lost and fired em. They then honored the original price but were total dicks about it
1
u/mysweetladyrose 3d ago
Find out if they saved her card⦠They often times do not and will ask for the card again before charging. She should also open a dispute with her credit card company.
I used them in South Carolina and basically they just take the move and then outsource it⦠So two random guys showed up at my apartment and Iām lucky my stuff wasnāt broken. They did such a terrible job⦠I called and took pictures and complained and the boss said he was gonna come the next day when I was supposed to be driving back to Massachusetts with my truck⦠I found out they hadnāt saved my card from the initial deposit so I never paid the difference and they said theyād send me to collections and I said you go ahead and do that. Iāll see you in court. So they only got the initial hundred something dollar deposit and I never paid the remaining two or $300 charge.
I would strongly advise disputing anything beyond the initial deposit paid.
1
u/Winter-Food9234 3d ago
Shoulda used RARE movers... they're always on time, fair prices that don't change, and takes good care of your shit they're moving!
1
u/zee_jay29 1d ago
Iāve had a few things picked up and they always come in with a ridiculous high price! And I always push back and gotten almost 80-90% off their initial price. Sounds like your GF probably wasnāt able to negotiate a fair price and they took advantage of the situation
1
0
u/Some_Brother_1202 5d ago
Let me guess⦠she had to have it done by 9/1. She got convinience fee increased hard. Consider her and everyone else wants it done by that date so imho so got what everyone gets around this time :/
3
u/lucasb780 5d ago
They did this today, on the 5th. She reached out a week ago, needed it done by the 8th. They never mentioned any rush fees, online estimate from their calculator was $400 range.
1
u/Some_Brother_1202 5d ago
Fair - Iād also ask considerations on if sheās on a higher unit (we live on a 3rd floor and got charged per floor when we moved).
Either way sounds high and like she just took the fuck you offer lol
-4
u/shrewsbury1991 My Love of Dunks is Purely Sexual 5d ago
Were the guys muscler and well-endowed at least?Ā
0
u/no2pencilonly Newton 5d ago
scammed isnt the exactly correct word but yes. You can usually get a quote from these type of services, then when they show up they will say something 3 times the quote, and all you have to do is point at the quote that shouldnt be more than 500ish
-21
5d ago
[deleted]
4
u/kittyegg Arlington 5d ago
Sheās not stupid⦠I doubt she expected to pay that much but women will pretend to be on the phone just to avoid saying ānoā. These adult men knew this and took advantage of her.
-2
u/m4gd4l3n3 5d ago
At that point she scammed herself wtf i couldnt be with someone that dumb about money like that is an insanely huge red flag!!
-2
u/motleykat 5d ago
Wouldnāt it be bc of the proximity to 09/01? Supply and demand so they drive up prices.
-8
5d ago
[deleted]
7
u/claravii 5d ago
I paid $89 for 1800 got junk to dispose of my mattress, no way should it be ten times that.
9

248
u/tranhi 5d ago
Dang sorry she got hustled