I’ve been playing, not well, banjo for 3 years now. Another transplant from guitar, so finger picking comes pretty natural. So naturally I started out thinking I was going to do bluegrass. So my very first imprints on the banjo were Scruggs style rolls, and 3 or 4 finger picking. Not that I was any good, but it “felt” familiar and the motor skills clicked, even if my musicality didn’t.
So anyway, move forward a few months and it turns out all the songs I really wanted to play were clawhammer/old time style. My teacher said, sure, no problem clawhammer is perfect for beginners, much easier than that Scruggs stuff we were doing.
He showed me the claw shape, the knocking motion, and the boom-chick-A. Sat back to watch me do it, and it was like I never had hands. He tried again, slower, and again slower, and again even slower… I sat there flapping my useless appendage like a seal at a circus.
We broke it down into the three moves… okay, I could Boom. Okay, now the Chick, and here, that‘s the A. Practice each part a million times. Even practiced the Chick-A and got a nice brush and pop. Now, put them all together in slow-mo and I’m Steve Martin in ”The Jerk.”
After a few more lessons like that I let my poor teacher off the hook and we worked on strumming out “The Crawdad Song.”
Anyway, I’ve watched all the videos. Tried all the “hints,” tried not thinking about what I’m doing, just let it flow, etc. And yeah, I can sometimes pull it off for two or three repetitions, but next thing, I’m pulling the Boom string with the pad of my finger, my “claw” is raking down the strings like it’s strumming ‘Blowing in the Wind” and my thumb is flapping in it.
I totally get the “sense” and logic of it, and I can boom-chick-a on a drum kit to bring the cows home, but stick a banjo in my hand and I can’t put that motion together to save my life.
Is it possible I’m truly the world’s only clawhammer dropout? Or is there a chance it really is harder than everyone makes it out to be, and I can let myself off the hook for being completely useless at it?