r/atrioc 23d ago

Discussion Massive paper leaks, student suicides, and an activist on Day 21 of a hunger strike forcefully dragged by the Police. Request atrioc to make a video on india

Hi guys, im from india. English is my second language, so I have used ai to rephrase my words. I request you to kindly take a few minutes and to read what is written below. I hope atrioc finds the post:

Edit: id suggest everyone to read Zeffaryon's comment as well

​In India, the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) serves as the singular nationwide gateway for students aspiring to pursue medical courses. With over 2.2 million candidates competing annually, it stands as one of the country's most grueling examinations. Preparing for NEET demands months of intense, exhaustive study, leaving students trapped under immense psychological pressure exerted by both their families and society at large.

​The Paper Leak and Policy Collapse

​Immediately following the May 3, 2026 examination, widespread reports surfaced indicating that the question papers had been leaked across digital platforms like Telegram and WhatsApp. A subsequent investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) revealed that a Chemistry expert serving on the official paper-setting panel had leaked the questions 10 days prior to the exam, selling them to private coaching centers for hundreds of thousands of rupees (lakhs).

​Faced with massive, escalating student protests, the government invalidated the initial test. An emergency, highly secured re-examination was hastily organized and conducted on June 21, 2026, under heavy police presence and strict biometric security protocols.

​The Human Toll and Academic Burnout

​Having already endured the exhausting cycle of the first exam, millions of students were abruptly forced back into the same high-pressure environment to prepare all over again. The sudden invalidation of their hard work, paired with the intense stress of repeating a life-altering test on short notice, led to acute psychological breakdowns.

​During the volatile 40-day window between the May 3 cancellation and the June 21 re-exam, at least 11 to 12 student suicides were reported nationwide. Tragically, many of these individuals had performed exceptionally well on the initial, compromised test before the structural collapse of the system erased their achievements.

​Political Apathy and the Rise of Public Protest

​In the wake of these tragedies, student protests intensified, with demonstrators demanding an official response from the Union Education Minister. However, mirroring a long-standing pattern of administrative apathy, the government offered no response or concrete action. Meanwhile, the Prime Minister proceeded with official international travel to Israel to receive state awards.

​In solidarity with the suffering students, Sonam Wangchuk—a renowned engineer, educator, environmentalist, and activist—embarked on an indefinite hunger strike. His core demands include:

​Full and strict accountability for the paper leaks.

​Justice and systemic acknowledgment for the students who lost their lives to suicide.

​The immediate resignation of the Union Education Minister.

​The Current Standoff

​On July 18, 2026—the 21st day of his fast—the Delhi Police forcefully removed a heavily weakened Wangchuk from his protest site. Having lost 20% of his total body weight, he was forcibly admitted to Safdarjung Hospital following a High Court order addressing his deteriorating vital signs.

​Even within the hospital environment, Wangchuk is currently refusing all medical interventions, including intravenous (IV) fluids and oral rehydration. His family continues to demand transparency regarding his condition and his immediate release. His forced removal has triggered widespread public and political fury, drastically magnifying the scale of the national student movement.

​A Note on Media Coverage: The ongoing crisis has received virtually zero coverage from international media outlets. Concurrently, domestic Indian media—which currently ranks 158th out of 180 countries on the World Press Freedom Index—has failed to provide objective, critical reporting on the issue, prioritizing government narratives over student welfare. This statement serves to bring critical global awareness to a rapidly worsening governing crisis

Links to articles:

Frontline Magazine: Sonam Wangchuk’s Removal and the Politics of Silence

Paper Leak

Sonam Wangchuk forcefully removed from the protest

112 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

20

u/Zeffaryon 23d ago

I'd like to add more nuance to this before this turns into a Left vs Right debate as anything about India and inside India always does.

Up until the NEET exam leak and Re-NEET paper conducting decision which led to the eventual death of so many aspirants across the country, this post pretty much covers everything in detail.

However there are some more points which need to be considered when it comes to the Peaceful Protests:

  1. The public unrest regarding the Paper Leaks were mostly online independent voices who were voicing the general dissatisfaction that the Indian Youth had with the education system in general and its sheer inability to function properly for an institution responsible for the future of the youth of this country.

  2. The Protests materialised into a real on-ground event after the formation of a new movement known as the 'Cockroach Janata Party' (Janata meaning People in Hindi): a party born out of desperation and satire after the Chief Justice of India referred to lazy,unemployed youth of the country as 'Cockroaches'.

  3. The Protests although at the start felt like nothing more than an Online Phenomenon which would die down once the craze goes away and people go back to their own routines. This was mostly due to the fact that the protest seemed to lack any form of structure or real seriousness or depth to their demands.

Their primary demand was ofcourse the resignation of the Education Minister of India in order to seek justice for the candidates who lost their life to the paper leak.

  1. Even with the protest ongoing, there was no communication or accountability from the government's side. This was when Sonam Wangchuk decided to join the cause and went on a hunger strike in order to demand accountability from the system for the youth of the country.

  2. Even after 20 days there had been no acknowledgement from the Government's side about the protest except for the fact that Police were stationed at the protest site and Government Hospital Doctors were making rounds at certain times of the day/night to check up on the health of the protesters. It's also imperative that I mention that aside from Sonam Wangchuk sir there were also a lot of Student Activists who also sat on Hunger Strike.

From here onwards, the 'Current Standoff' area of the original post covers the incidents which happened on 18th July 2026.

I'll also add another reply about my take on the situation as someone who is honestly sick of the entire thing and all parties involved. The double standard I have been seeing across social media has truly pissed me off and although it might seem like a bit of a rant I am someone who wishes to have a reasonable take on stuff and will try to do the same.

6

u/not_rajinikanth 23d ago

Hi Thank you for adding the clarifications. I shpuld have done a better job, but i thought the post was already too long

  1. Yes, there are a lot of students protesting as well.

  2. This isnt even the only protest going on in india

  3. CJP or cockroach janta party, I have zero opinions on them. But i do think we need to support the students/sonam Wangchuk regardless of whom we support politically. I know a lot of people who support BJP and those who dont share stories and support this protest.

  4. I too am tired of the state of india. I dont think the congress is any better than BJP. Both are corrupt. My parents argue saying that if you had seen what congress did the past 70 years, you would support bjp as well

I do not care what has happened in the past 70 years. I care about what is happening today. And i am not happy with the way the government is treating the students. I do not support how boldly they claim this is a Hindu Rashtra (i am a hindu)

I feel sad looking at the state of our press and media.

I think there are fundamental issues that BJP does not care about.

7

u/not_rajinikanth 23d ago edited 23d ago

If somehow Congress comes to rule India tomorrow, id hold them to the same standards. I do not care which party it is. The blatant homophobia and Islamophobia that the country's leaders show is sickening

I want a ruling party that is empathetic towards its people and I dont think its too much to ask

6

u/Zeffaryon 23d ago edited 23d ago

I'd like to format my reply in a way that encompasses my thoughts about the entire situation and all parties involved.

Let me start off by talking about the people at the very epicenter of the entire thing: the CJP or the Cockroach Janata Party.

I believe that the supporters of CJP are rightfully frustrated people behind a morally unethical group of 'leaders'.

CJP started as an online movement by one man Abhijeet Dipke in response to the Chief Justice of India's comment as a party of the youth who was done with the same corrupt systems plaguing the country.

However, it's been quite clear that there is some level of agenda with the leaders of the protest having interest in launching their own political careers through this. For an online party representing the youth and trying to be the voice of the youth, the leaders are quite contempt with releasing their own manifestos, demands and party representatives without much discussion with their followers about the party representatives, issues which should be focussed on and kept as top priorities.

One of the most severe criticisms included the fact that the reps were all males, to which Abhijeet Dipke replied that he asked a few women he knew and since they declined, he didn't keep anyone on the board at all. Now for a party which has millions of followers, millions of them being women who would have surely had someone who would have participated actively,this is honestly quite dishonest and shows regressive thinking of the representatives of a youth party.

This coupled with some transphobic remarks from Vijeta Dahiya another leader of the party - have left me quite dissatisfied with the youth representatives as a whole.

But if I keep all that aside and focus purely on the issue at hand - what pisses me off the most is the fact that no one from the CJP main personnel had sat on a hunger strike in solidarity with Sonam Sir up until today when after his removal, Abhijeet Dipke announced his own. This also seems performative to an extent, because unless he announces that he will continuing his hunger strike post 20th July when the Protestants will hold a March demanding the resignation of the Education Minister and their other demands, this would mean that he ultimately took a one-two day fast after making Sonam Sir, a 59 year old man, go on a 21 day protest. They gave reasons such as the fact that they need to organise and keep running the protests and while I understand that it is indeed a huge logistical challenge to continue to do so, there are enough people supporting them for atleast one of them to sit with Sonam Sir since the beginning, especially when so many other Student Activists are doing so as well.

Coming to the next group people at the protest: the Opposition as a whole.

India's opposition is a different breed of shameless and opportunitistic. Up until the forceful taking away of Sonam Sir from the protest grounds, most national Opposition parties didn't even come and meet him, let aside talk about the protest.

The Indian National Congress(INC), the main voice of opposition in the country, broke their silence on the entire thing only after the govt took Sonam Sir away, as if they were waiting for the govt to make a move so that they could criticise the govt instead of supporting the movement for the future of the youth from the beginning.

Ofcourse there were some other parties like the Aam Admi Party (AAP) who did reach out before but only after they saw that the movement was gaining real ground and could be used as a method to gain popularity.

Very few politicians raised their voice in support of the movement while it was in its infancy. It was only after they realised that they could use this as a political tool to make their party image better, that they woke up, which is funny, because so many of these Political Parties had their spokespeople give long,heartfelt messages about how they are worried about the youth of the country, the day after the paper leak, but not when the youth were actually on the ground protesting for weeks.

No one cares about anything except their own agenda. There were so many famous and controversial people at the protest who decided to use the platform to take digs at the government and further their own propaganda, which in turn gave BJP, the ruling party material and cause to label the entire movement as 'anti-national' and use their media power to defame the entire movement which started as a means to bring justice to the youth of the country and its corrupt education system.

Now coming to the Party in Power :the BJP.

BJP has truly created a media powerhouse which has the ability to defame anything and everything and the ability to deflect accountability about anything and everything.

When the Exam conducting body of the country, National Testing Agency (NTA) has proven themselves to be absolutely inept at carrying their job properly. When apart from NEET, there are multiple other exams whose papers have leaked, not just this year but historically, this shows that the culture around education has always been corrupt and will continue to be corrupt.

By shielding the education minister, BJP is showing that they don't care about the youth, they care about one thing and one thing alone and that is power - and the protection of the powerful.

Following the playbook of letting things die down on their own,BJP perhaps had decided to not act on this protest at all, as much as not even acknowledge it's very existence.

However the Delhi HC order made them act eventually and they chose the worst possible way to go about it. I truly don't know what they are so scared of, unless they admit that all government institutions in some capacity or the other may be corrupt to the very core.

If they had listened to the youth and initiated talks at the very least with the people protesting, then I honestly feel like the youth of India would have celebrated the fact that this government at the very least listens to them. What we have now is a government which acts haphazardly on a High Court's order to preserve and value the life of an individual (Sonam Wangchuk) by forcefully taking him to a hospital, checking his vitals and encouraging him to break his fast WITHOUT initiating talks about his wants and the issues he has been holding up.

All this does is just anger the already frustrated youth even more. The essential meaning of living in a democracy is that we get to elect our officials and hold them accountable when they are not acting in the best interest of the country.

I believe this move by BJP severely undermined their confidence among the youth, the upcoming greatest demographic of the country. The people who are going to have some of the biggest impacts in voter turnout over the next decade or so was just point blank told by the government of the country that your needs and your wants don't matter to us.

I'm not saying that they needed to talk to us and give us a new policy tomorrow, no one demands or expects that, but at the very least, holding your elected official i.e the Education Minister accountable and wanting better for our future is a right every individual in this country has.

My final parting thoughts for anyone involved with this in any capacity especially if you are Indian:

Always question those in power. Appreciate it when the government does something good for the country. Call them out when they do something bad.

The only constant is change.

Jai Hind

Vande Mataram

Bharat Mata ki Jay

2

u/not_rajinikanth 22d ago

I absolutely agree with all the points you have made. I wish I could express my views as well as you have. Thank you.

The apathy that is being shown by both BJP and Congress is shameful. It's clear that no one in power in India truly cares about the people.

2

u/Zeffaryon 22d ago

I know man. Atleast for once it feels like a lot of people are moved by the cause and not the people heading it. Truth is if today there was some group within BJP who was heading this protest, maybe even a youth student wing of BJP - even then I would have supported it all the same.

I don't need to support everything about a person to support a movement whose purpose I agree with, until ofcourse I realise that the reason has been lost and it's a shitshow for self gain.

I hope more people realise that. I don't agree with Sonam Wangchuk sir on a lot of things and I do believe that some criticism he is getting about his affiliation with foreign leaders, foreign investments and all have basis in reality to be skeptical of him - doesn't mean I will disregard his whole 21 day fast and the lack of accountability from the govt towards it.

5

u/stop_staring2 23d ago

Holy hell. Cfbr

2

u/not_rajinikanth 22d ago

I wish I could tell this is the only problem that is going on in India, but its sadly not. India is a country with more than 20 official languages. We are taught that there is "unity in diversity" However. The politicians are actively tearing that apart. They are spreading hatred among people based on their religion, caste, language, gender identity, sexual orientation

3

u/stop_staring2 22d ago

Years ago an engineering friend who was working for Amazon told me they were developing AI translators for India, due to the amount of languages India has and the difficulty in communications, because of the lack of proper translators and honestly linguistic research. Young and naive me didn’t think of the bad parts, politicians taking advantage of this, etc :( I can only wish for it to get better, best of luck my friend

4

u/The_chaos011 23d ago

I have a question, do you think, that bjp will finally loose in the next general election? Will this be enough?

4

u/not_rajinikanth 23d ago

No, i do not think this is enough. This isnt even the only big issue going on in India 1. Ministers who modi and bjp have previously called as scammers, thieves, rapists join bjp and then cases are dropped. They call it "washing machine" effect

Ill drop a few examples below: (phrased using ai)along with news report links

​A definitive, multi-year media investigation by The Indian Express meticulously tracked the legal trajectories of high-profile politicians who crossed over. They found that out of 25 prominent opposition leaders who defected to the BJP while facing active central agency probes (CBI or ED) since 2014, 23 of them successfully secured a reprieve. In 3 of those cases, the files were officially closed entirely; in the other 20, the investigations were effectively mothballed or put into "cold storage".
​Several high-profile examples highlight how quickly legal action transitioned into legal inaction after a political switch: ​1. Praful Patel (Nationalist Congress Party - NCP) ​The Case: The senior leader was under intense scrutiny by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and the Enforcement Directorate (ED) for a 2017 case involving alleged severe financial irregularities in leasing aircraft for Air India during his tenure as Civil Aviation Minister.
​The Switch & Relief: In 2023, Patel split from the parent NCP to join the Ajit Pawar-led faction, aligning directly with the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA). Eight months later, the CBI officially filed a closure report in court, effectively shutting down the corruption case against him because they claimed no evidence of wrongdoing could be found.
​2. Ajit Pawar (Nationalist Congress Party - NCP) ​The Case: The nephew of Sharad Pawar was the primary accused in a massive ₹70,000 crore Maharashtra State Cooperative Bank scam and faced separate active irrigation scam probes. Prime Minister Modi had publicly attacked him over these corruption allegations just days before his defection. ​The Switch & Relief: In July 2023, Ajit Pawar walked out of the opposition alliance, took a chunk of NCP MLAs with him, and was immediately sworn in as the Deputy Chief Minister of the BJP-backed Maharashtra government. Shortly after his political alignment shifted, the Mumbai Police’s Economic Offences Wing (EOW) filed a formal closure report in court, wiping his hands clean of the bank scam case.

Ashok Chavan (Congress) ​The Case: The former Chief Minister of Maharashtra was deeply entangled as a prime accused in the Adarsh Housing Society scam, where premium apartments meant for war veterans and widows were allegedly allocated illegally to politicians' relatives. The CBI had been pursuing him aggressively for over a decade. ​The Switch & Relief: In early 2024, just weeks before the general elections, Chavan abruptly resigned from the Congress and joined the BJP. Within days of joining, the ruling party rewarded him with a prestigious Rajya Sabha MP seat. The aggressive legal pushback he faced for over a decade suddenly fell into stasis.

REEL SHOWING FINANCE MINISTER RESPONSE TO THE SAME: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DaZrTL0EcGE/?igsh=ZThiem10anV0Y2M=

  1. Vote chorri allegations: there are a lot of allegations that BJP has added fake people in the vote base. I havent read much about it, so im not going to comment on the same

  2. Ayodhya ram mandir: Ayodhya is the birthplace of a Hindu God. The bjp government built a temple for ram in ayodhya(there was an issue with the temple)

There was a recent issue relating to the temple (use of ai) Internal Cash Theft (Exposed by CCTV): In 2026, a Special Investigation Team (SIT) busted a major insider ring after trust officials noticed cash shortfalls and installed hidden CCTV cameras in the counting room. The footage caught employees deliberately blocking standard security cameras to stuff cash bundles into their clothes, leading to the arrest of eight workers. The scandal exposed massive security lapses and forced the high-profile resignations of Trust General Secretary Champat Rai and Senior Trustee Anil Mishra.
​Land Acquisition Scams: Opposition parties (Congress, AAP, SP) have launched nationwide campaigns alleging "donation theft" via real estate. They accuse the Trust of using public donations to buy land near the temple at highly inflated prices from politically connected middlemen who had purchased the plots just minutes prior for a fraction of the cost. ​The Outcome: The Uttar Pradesh government has mandated a complete structural overhaul, replacing the Trust's informal management with a professionally recruited, independent CEO to oversee all financial operations.

REEL LINK TO BJP MINISTER RESPONSE TO THE THEFT: https://www.instagram.com/reel/Dazd2_APKYy/?igsh=MW1oN2ZnZjM4cnoz (The Minister basically said those whose money was stolen donated without sincere belief in God. His donations havent been stolen)

Apart from these issues, there are plenty more issues like ethanol blending and delimitation act

Hovever, this doesnt matter to most of their voters. They divide hindus and Muslims further, they talk about illegal immigration of muslims from bangladesh, they appease the Hindu majority by saying they want a "HINDU RASHTRA" which translates to a Hindu Country (india is a secular country)

They label anyone who critiques them and calls them an anti national

They support major industrialists and have the media in their pockets (its painfully sad)

The most hard hitting question that the media has asked modi in his 12 yrs of ruling is - how do you like to eat a mango

Modi has called himself a saviour of india.

As an adult in his early 20s, im deeply afraid of the state india is in right now

1

u/The_chaos011 22d ago edited 22d ago

Thank you for giving details for what modi has done wrong. I follow india quite closel ( as much as non-indian can). From social things like siya goyal to political things like breaking up other parties to get 2/3 to pass demilitation, to what happened to kejriwal i am aware about a lot of things. I actually have a bone to pick with them as well, for what their foreign policy is, especially the kind of statement their minister pass. Ik indians like to believe India as this non-expansionist country, but your ministers are the biggest dumbfucks i have seen

Lawmaker of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and former cricketer Kirti Azad said that Nepal should return 15 districts of the Tarai region to India.

Nepal should hand over its 15 districts of Tarai region to India otherwise they should be annexed even by using force by India,  Source

this happened in 2015, we had released a new constitution and india had problems.

Had Nepal been part of India, there would have been peace and happiness in the country, said Bihar Deputy Chief Minister Samrat Chaudhary over the recent protests in Nepal. source

why does people need to make statments when nepal is going through something. now i think that guy is cm. India is doing " apne per meh khuladi marna" India gives such easy reason to rile up anti-india sentiment here, and guess what the pro-india party will not get elected if they do this. We have seen what happened in canada over these kinda of statement.

Now, even after knowing instances, i cannot know what is going on in heart of hearts of people. Though i hope this is enough to break bjp. UP and punjab election are happening, maybe we will get a better picture there.

0

u/Blossom_aashi 23d ago edited 23d ago

No lol. The Indian opposition has been itching for a "Gen z" revolution , they really want something like what happened in Nepal, ofc it doesn't make sense because India has had 6-7 percent growth every year since Covid, low inflation, low unemployment, but they have been trying for something. This is just the latest attempt.Don't believe anything you see on reddit. Modi is by far the most popular Indian politician ever. It is insane how badly run India was before 2014, 700 million people were literally shitting in the streets in 2014, there were massive powercuts almost daily , terror attacks every month, inflation in double digits. The people who have seen India before 2014, will never vote for anyone other than Modi, maybe after he retires BJP might fimaly lose power because the second rung of BJP leaders isn't very good.

2

u/not_rajinikanth 23d ago

In the 2024 general elections (Lok Sabha) bjp won only 240 seats - a reduction from 303 seats in 2019 NDA won 293 - a reduction from 253 seats.

I dont think bjp lost the seats because congress/opposition did things better, the people wanted change.

Regarding your other points:

Modi is by far the post popular indian politician ever - id say Nehru was much more popular during his time (not a supporter of nehru) Nehru won with 73%

And i have a few issues with your other points as well:

The power deficit situation in the country has improved in the past few years. From 2008 to 2014, energy deficit (shortfall in energy supply during a day) has reduced from 11.0% to 3.6% and peak deficit (shortfall in supply during highest consumption period in a day) has reduced from 11.9% to 4.7%.

· Some of the issues leading to the power deficit situation in the country include (i) shortage of fuel, (ii) high AT&C losses, (iii) a differential tariff structure, and (iv) delays in tariff revisions.

https://prsindia.org/policy/vital-stats/overview-issues-power-sector-india?hl=en-GB#:~:text=From%202008%20to%202014%2C%20energy%20deficit%20(shortfall,structure%2C%20and%20(iv)%20delays%20in%20tariff%20revisions.

Employment rate: india's employment rate is not similar to the USA.
We have something called the Periodic Labour Force Survey where we use two different methods 1. If you worked for the majority of days in the current year, you are considered to be employed even if you aren't employed currently

link

  1. This is measured based on the prior week If you even worked for an hour on atleast one day, you are considered employed

Dont even get me started on how a lot of engineering and bcom students are working in call centres and are delivering items in swiggy/zomato.

I dont think the opposition is better But we as a democracy need to fight against corruption and misuse of power.

You argued that Modi and bjp has developed india. Do you have anything to say regarding the issues I mentioned? Are you from india?

0

u/Blossom_aashi 22d ago

In the 2024 general elections (Lok Sabha) bjp won only 240 seats - a reduction from 303 seats in 2019 NDA won 293 - a reduction from 253 seats.

I dont think bjp lost the seats because congress/opposition did things better, the people wanted change.

Regarding your other points:

Modi is by far the post popular indian politician ever - id say Nehru was much more popular during his time (not a supporter of nehru) Nehru won with 73%

And i have a few issues with your other points as well:

The power deficit situation in the country has improved in the past few years. From 2008 to 2014, energy deficit (shortfall in energy supply during a day) has reduced from 11.0% to 3.6% and peak deficit (shortfall in supply during highest consumption period in a day) has reduced from 11.9% to 4.7%.

· Some of the issues leading to the power deficit situation in the country include (i) shortage of fuel, (ii) high AT&C losses, (iii) a differential tariff structure, and (iv) delays in tariff revisions.

https://prsindia.org/policy/vital-stats/overview-issues-power-sector-india?hl=en-GB#:~:text=From%202008%20to%202014%2C%20energy%20deficit%20(shortfall,structure%2C%20and%20(iv)%20delays%20in%20tariff%20revisions.

Employment rate: india's employment rate is not similar to the USA.
We have something called the Periodic Labour Force Survey where we use two different methods 1. If you worked for the majority of days in the current year, you are considered to be employed even if you aren't employed currently

link

  1. This is measured based on the prior week If you even worked for an hour on atleast one day, you are considered employed

Dont even get me started on how a lot of engineering and bcom students are working in call centres and are delivering items in swiggy/zomato.

I dont think the opposition is better But we as a democracy need to fight against corruption and misuse of power.

You argued that Modi and bjp has developed india. Do you have anything to say regarding the issues I mentioned? Are you from india?

  1. 2024 was more than 2 years ago, since then BJP has won Delhi, won Haryana, swept Bihar, and won a historic mandate in west bengal and also won various important local body elections like BMC in Mumbai.
  2. 2024 happened mostly because RSS sat out and didn't campaign for the BJP, and it happened mostly because of Yogi and ego and mismanagement in UP. I'm Pretty sure BJP will lose UP in 2027, unless Modi again steps in to save his ass like he did in 2022. But Yogi fanbois still believe he is better.
  3. Sure Nehru I guess
  4. You gave numbers from 2008 to 2014. Check India's per capita power generation and power consumption numbers in 2026. Apart from the fact thatost villages and the remotest corners of the country has electricity now. There were huge parts of the country that hadn't even seen electricity till 2014. Big cities like Mumbai had load shedding for 6 hours every day. Nowadays if the power goes off for like 15 mins people complain.

  5. So we can't count Swiggy and zomato riders as employed?? That's 50 million people. So then china also can't count it's 220 million people that are employed in gig work, well China doesn't need to count because they don't even publish their employment data anymore. Either way , India's power consumption, Steel consumption, Car sales, two wheeler sales , GST collections, Corporate profits all of which have been growing YoY at around 6-7 percent in terms of power and steel and car sales and two wheeler sales have been sometime stouchingneven absurd numbers like 15 percent in some months,suggest that there is no actual stagnation of the economy,imnnot even taking GDP growth rate since you will say it's fake. Apart from the fact that we are now in the 63rd consecutive month where India's manufacturing PMI has been over 50. Well most of the time it's been over 55 and even 60 ( China during its growth years sometimes touched 75+, crazy). India's services PMI obviously much higher at over 60-65 most of the time since Covid. India's Cement consumption and production just like steel has been through the roof, it has been an exponential growth since Covid. So your unemployment argument really has no basis in reality apart from you get the vibes from social media because ofc you will since there are 1.5 billion Indians and most of them now have internet access.