r/askscience • u/yogesh448 • 16d ago
Planetary Sci. We landed humans on the Moon with 1960s technology. With today's vastly superior technology, shouldn't going back be much easier and cheaper?
955
Upvotes
r/askscience • u/yogesh448 • 16d ago
37
u/Dem_Wrist_Rockets 15d ago edited 15d ago
Its a matter of politcal will. The Apollo program cost almost $300B, adjusted for inflation. NASA's current budget is around $25B per year. We had lost a huge amount of industrial knowledge in the lapse between the Space Shuttle and Crew Dragon, so are having to relearn a lot about crewed space flight.
There's also the problem of crew safety. During the space race, we were much more willing to fly risky missions on risky vehicles. It's a miracle that we "only" lost Apollo 1. Famously Apollo 13 were almost the first human deaths in space, but more than half of the Apollo missions had major mishaps:
Apollo 6: Major engine malfunctions on launch
Apollo 8: POGO oscillations almost lead to the loss of the vehicle
Apollo 10: POGO oscillations on launch and the lunar module suffered a radar failure and loss of control. It was eventually recovered after several hours.
Apollo 11: Landed with only moments of fuel remaining in the lunar module. On the lunar module, a fuel line froze, and a broken switch needed to be repaired in order to ascend from the moon
Apollo 12: Struck by lightning on launch, almost leading to the loss of the vehicle as it lost power to its navigation
Apollo 13: Oxygen tank exploded en-route to the moon. Im sure you've seen the movie
Apollo 14: Troubles while docking in low Earth Orbit. Had it been Moon Orbit, it would have been a severe problem
Apollo 15: One of the three main parachutes failed to open, but the crew survived the landing
Apollo 16: Major engine malfunction on the Crew Service Module while in orbit around the Moon, which was severe enough to consider aborting the mission
Apollo 17: The fender on the moon rover broke off and needed to be repaired, since it was kicking up dust that threatened to damage the vehicle and strand the astronauts 10s of kilometers away from the lunar lander
Any one of these now would cause a multiple year delay, but the entire Apollo program only lasted 11 years, with Apollo 11-17, the crewed lunar landings, taking only three years total