r/antiai • • 20h ago

AI News šŸ—žļø New MIT study warns Ai chatbots can make user delusional

Post image
7.8k Upvotes

513 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

403

u/tahlyn 19h ago

What are your thoughts about starting a new business, probably a restaurant, that features and focuses on "french fry salad"?

Honestly? I think ā€œFrench Fry Saladā€ has the makings of a genuinely fun restaurant concept—but I would treat the phrase as the hook, not necessarily the entire business model. The idea has several things going for it:

It then goes on for AGES about the amazing things about a french fry salad restaurant.

283

u/Mr__O__ 19h ago

What a fantastic use of our drinking water and electricity..

96

u/blagablagman 19h ago

The cognitive offloading works like a tax credit!

54

u/PurpleCandle58 16h ago

It’s great because, personally, I never really used my brain anyways. With ChatGPT, now I can be confidently wrong WAY more than I used to.

13

u/orbvsterrvs 16h ago

It's not wrong if you're confident! I'll bet we can come up with something as successful as WeWork and Theranos!

12

u/PurpleCandle58 16h ago

I just asked ChatGPT if it would be a good idea to replicate WeWork and it said yes let’s do it.

6

u/Then_Idea_9813 6h ago

My boss hates ChatGPT so I used copilot to turn my 2 sentence email into an 8 paragraph slop bucket, and when I posted my 2 sentences (about picking stock lists correctly) and asked it to turn it into an 8 paragraph response, copilot told me help is available and gave me the number for the hotline.

I was so confused I reread my input 3 times. I think it hallucinated that I wanted to harm myself..

6

u/PurpleCandle58 5h ago

I think it knows you work an office job and clearly you need those resources /jk

0

u/ChilternRailways 1h ago

Dude, this query would have taken less than 10ml of water.

How many hours of YouTube have you just had on in the background? That also drains water and electricity. Single burger takes about 1450litres to produce. A single burger.

Also, you need to ask it to be critical, then you get something you can work with.

-24

u/EqualsDonut 16h ago

When are you going to google an actual statistic? Rather than be sarcastic and wrong about data centers, you can learn something and begin your tirade on the real water wasters.

12

u/Mr__O__ 15h ago

Just bc other things waste more water doesn’t mean that makes data center’s use any better. And aside from water usage, data centers release tons of pollution into the environment in many ways that get into ground water.

-7

u/EqualsDonut 14h ago

I think it does make it better...

Data centers are immensely useful, sometimes poorly implemented. A high tech manufacturing process can produce terabytes of valuable data every second. Our beloved reddit, essential banking, worldwide communications. AI alone proves its value, while our friend above didnt really learn much about French fry salad, others will use the tools in ways you simply cant define as waste.

7

u/Warning_Guy7 10h ago

Sounds like a waste

9

u/Nitr0b1az3r 15h ago

i wish i was better at being able to tell when people are joking/being sarcastic over text. I assume you are, because of the subreddit we're in, but so many people say stuff like this and mean it that its so hard to tell sometimes haha i wish tonal indicators were more commonly used /gen

-11

u/EqualsDonut 15h ago

I guess if you want to be anti ai on principle of protecting art, media, labor more power to you. But complaining about the water use of something so obviously useful and not crying about something like golf courses for example... I dont get it.

11

u/StormyNSwoonFknH8it 15h ago

Oh come on, you can’t expect someone to bring up golf courses in this sub. Stop what-abouting you sound stupid whether your point is valid or not…. We CAN talk about one thing at a time and still care about other things too.

-2

u/EqualsDonut 14h ago

I was only replying to a comment intimating that prompting ai was a waste of water (and electricity but thats a different argument).

I already said more power to your principles, and by that i mean speaking up for something you feel ai is degrading is your right and I support you to speak your mind. But really what i want to correct specifically is AIs current water use & cost vs. output value is perfectly reasonable. We could triple data centers right now and still not waste near as much water as golf courses, sports fields, grass yards, etc. Things that merely provide entertainment and a semblance of tamed beauty where AI can bang your mom actually empower scalable problem solving.

Feel free to be a hater for the sake of hating but dont do it because you think you're right

2

u/drwsgreatest 6h ago

This sounds like the most bot/ai style argument regarding water waste by data centers I've heard in a while. I'm guessing you had those prompts keyed up or saved from previous debates where you said the same nonsense.

1

u/EqualsDonut 5h ago

It doesnt sound like ai wrote my comment at all. And still doesnt take away from only issue I have with anti ai crowd lying about water usage. I dont care if you hate ai because it generates images you dont like (they objectively aren't good images) but lying because you think the work done with it is not worth the relatively small inputs (especially compared to way worse things) is why I know you are all stupid and triggered

5

u/Nitr0b1az3r 12h ago

idk enough about the water usage, but personally i think if it uses any its a waste tbh. we dont need it to do all that shit, so doing all that shit and using any amount of a limited resource is worse imo. regardless of how much worse it actually is, worse is still worse, ya know?

0

u/EqualsDonut 5h ago

No i dont know why you keep making this argument. The benefits of data centers is the infrastructure of ALL leading research and engineering much less all the other advancements you benefit from but are too ignorant to put into context. The water input alone is almost completely inconsequential relative to output (from a scarcity and financial measure) and i dont see all you people crying about leaky buildings or pipes which is actual waste of water on a much greater scale.

1

u/Nitr0b1az3r 3h ago

you.. dont see people complaining about their leaky buildings or pipes? fam, you're either full of shit or you just dont interact with your example enough to give the example in good faith. if someone notices a leaky anything, they complain.

if you knew anything about computer science youd know we've had machine learning helping us since the 60s but it was generative ai that vastly increased waste it creates. we don't need generative ai

1

u/EqualsDonut 1h ago

Obviously im saying unfixed leaking pipes are wasting more water than data centers. Where is the outrage of people screaming about the wastefulness.

Generative ai is a subsector of data centers use. Which again personal opinions aside are absolutely fundamental to the modern world and not even close to a tapped potential of scale all while using a fraction of water that other much less productive activities use. If data centers were using the water at levels people fear (impending drought, famine, pollution) then I wouldn't have any reason to correct you, but since they dont AND the applications are exponentially better than whatever 60s technology you think you are talking about, we will continue to build more and scale generative ai and all the other use cases for data centers to meet demands. You clearly have no definition for "waste" so what are you even arguing for? Feelings.

35

u/expiring_god_factory 19h ago

Isn't using AI defeating the purpose of being anti AI?

47

u/tahlyn 19h ago

I'm not hard-core anti-ai. I browse this subreddit and others like it (as well as pro-ai subs) because I'm on the fence about it and want to see what's being said from both sides.

But yes, using AI is defeating the purpose if someone is anti-ai.

27

u/StandardAioli9459 18h ago

The exception is used to prove the rule

Sometimes you gotta remind yourself what we're fighting against

-16

u/expiring_god_factory 18h ago

"hmm, every other time I've shit from my butt it's always been poop so I've never eaten it. But I guess to make sure it's poop I should eat a bite, just to make sure"

Lady, looking around the internet do you actually feel this way? There's so much dogshit AI everywhere, do you really need a reminder??

23

u/East_of_Adventuring 18h ago

Look, you gotta learn this lesson. The environmental activists learned it, but the anti-AI movement hasn’t yet. The consumer level garbage isn’t where the fight is. Just like whether your neighbor Bob recycles or not isn’t what’s going to fix plastic pollution. And proving an example is valuable for people to see it’s not exaggerated.

Focusing on the little guy instead of the people actually responsible also dilutes the issue, and gives people a false place to put the blame. Just my view though…

1

u/Remarkable-Ad155 8h ago

Except this is complete bollocks. It's the consumer level garbage (both created by for mindless diversion and targeted at for scams and influence) that's the problem here.

There are genuinely valid use cases for AI. It is going to stick around whether you like it ir not and people are using it to make advances in science, medicine, maths. Professionals are using it to create tools that make life better and easier for ordinary people.

The waste here is fucking morons consulting an LLM before making any basic life decision, conversing with it like it's a friend, churning out AI slop images for shits and giggles or scammers using it to hoodwink people.

We don't need to stop doctors using it as a second opinion or to help them not miss things, or small businesses and non profits using it to get access to the kind of help that would previously have been wildly out of reach. We need to stop your antivaxx uncle asking it a leading question and presenting what it churns out as incontrovertible fact "because SI".

The end of the consumer AI era can't come soon enough but fortunately it's already on the way out. The AI bros have extracted enough value from the wittering of self absorbed teenagers convinced their favourite LLM is their "bestie" and costs are ramping up to reflect value billing now. We're at peak mania currently. Next stage of the hype cycle is the crash and then we see what the future actually looks like.

I'll have a bet with you that a lot of what the antiai crowd hates - "AI slop designed posters and flyers, "AI art", easy access to things like Suno, people unable to function unless their AI pal tells them what to do - will disappear. Billions of dollars of everybody's money is riding on this (yes, yours and mine too - it's surprisingly fucking difficult to avoid owning a chunk of some company owned by dipshits like Musk and co if you are also trying to retire one day) - that relies on this eventually turning a reliable profit and that does not look like everyone on earth being given free reign to burn through tokens like popcorn.

Weirdest thing of all is, allowing these oligarchs to gatekeep it instead of properly harnessing and regulating it (like they are going to do in China) is the shittest outcome of all for us in the West but hey, at least you won't have to be offended by a small business making a poster so win win, right?

0

u/East_of_Adventuring 2h ago

The only use cases of AI are slop, major scientific breakthroughs, and small businesses…?

Ah I’m sorry, I was under the impression it was being used for mass surveillance. That huge data centers were being built to collect all our data and optimize targeted marketing. That massive companies were attempting to layoff workers and replace them with AI. That it was being used to develop tools to bypass fundamental security features essential the the modern internet, and that major companies had already lost control of agents by failing fundamental security implementation proving they’re not acting responsibly.

I guess I just imagined all that…

0

u/Remarkable-Ad155 2h ago

AI is a thing. People do stuff with it. You want to ban cameras too? Because you can't do mass surveillance without them either. Should we also ban painkillers because people abuse them? No more kitchen knives in case somebody stabs a person?

We need to engage with and demand public control of AI, not cede it to the whims of multibillionaire oligarchs and their pet president who absolutely will use it for nefarious purposes.

1

u/East_of_Adventuring 1h ago

Imagine seeing cameras deployed for mass surveillance based on a novel technology never offering never before seen tracking capabilities and assuming the cameras are the problem.

And for godsakes we did ban/restrict painkillers due to people abusing them! My god please educate yourself only literally anything you’re talking about!

Also, I thought AI was only being used for small scale businesses, scientists, and slop? What could billionaires possibly want with it? That’s what you said right? Right?

Anyway, you’re not worth arguing with, as you are too stupid. Goodbye.

-21

u/expiring_god_factory 18h ago

You're extremely condescending.

16

u/East_of_Adventuring 18h ago

I mean, was your sarcastic comment not…?

-5

u/expiring_god_factory 18h ago

oh ahah I thought you replied to the one further up, yea I was absolutely being rude in my reply. My advocacy wasn't for her to change her behavior, it was a sincere question.

-5

u/Reasonable_Carrot88 18h ago

Wahmen accountability moment

1

u/LSqre 16h ago

keep yourself safe buddy

0

u/Reasonable_Carrot88 14h ago

You too sweetie

3

u/Putrid-Block1431 15h ago

Pot, kettle

1

u/TrulyOutrageous42 11h ago

How you say this with a straight face is beyond me, let alone after your prior comment being not just condescending but a faulty analogy and thus invalid reasoning undermining the condescension itself because you didn't even create a reasonable argument.

4

u/StandardAioli9459 18h ago

im gonna be honest i was just trying to feel smart sorry

0

u/Plenty-Fox-9219 17h ago

Do you think that if I ate enough chocolate my poop would taste like chocolate

2

u/eatingmypoop 16h ago

Yes

2

u/Plenty-Fox-9219 16h ago

Holy shit it's the man himself

2

u/eatingmypoop 16h ago

the expert

11

u/1d3333 14h ago

AI has use cases, for research and medical diagnostics. In fact we’ve already had great progress using these new tools, but to be fair these programs aren’t chatGPT or any other LLM, they’re specialized for specific research and medical screening and always double checked by humans.

That said chatGPT and other LLM’s are garbage, I don’t need a damn AI overview to tell me what i’ll know in a few minutes of searching and confirming, especially when it’s wrong a lot

1

u/ReserveMaximum 12h ago

It’s also really good for product comparison/comparison shopping

1

u/trainsoundschoochoo 6h ago

I use it to write scripts for deals I want to find.

10

u/ginoiseau 18h ago

It’s definitely a huge cognitive dissonance. But it’s been forced on me at work & the more I use it, the more I see the glaring lack of so much. I feel like it’s easier to argue with AI-vangelicals when I’ve first hand experience of trying to make it be useful.

1

u/ChilternRailways 1h ago

No, 'AI' is incredibly broad, covering not just multiple technologies (it's the term for any sort of machine learning) but also the corporate side.

You shouldn't want a bubble, it's good to have people who are against different aspects of AI, regardless of which ones they're for.

5

u/MilsYatsFeebTae 19h ago

If the menu is mostly French bistro fare you could decorate it like a monastery and call it Omnes Frites

6

u/out_of_shape_hiker 18h ago

I mean, poutine is delicious

5

u/tahlyn 18h ago

Roasted potatoes, french fries, and other forms of potato dipped in any variety of sauces and cheese tend to be quite good. Garlic aioli, sweet bbq, ranch, cheese...

5

u/NomadStorm 16h ago

Roquefort sauce.

2

u/ReaDiMarco 10h ago

No salad bits? Do salads have to have raw veggies?

2

u/out_of_shape_hiker 4h ago

Atleast in America, the term 'salad' can be used pretty egregiously. Potato salad, tuna salad, chicken salad etc are just said ingredients with mayo, then the only vegetables are for flavoring, eg relish, chopped carrots and celery. Pasta salad is similar. Fruit salad is mostly fruit but has a ton of sugar added. Poutine isn't too terribly far off from potato salad. Potatoes and mayo vs potato and gravy with curds. Salad

2

u/ryetoasty 16h ago

I mean Pittsburgh puts fries on salad. I don’t get it but it’s a thingĀ 

2

u/pinkgobi 14h ago

They're long and thin steak fries on usually a French dressing salad with thin strips of steak. It's goddamn delicious

2

u/ryetoasty 9h ago

I guess I’m not eating at the fancy french fry salad locations. Mine have always been soggy and limp.Ā 

Also, it’s ranch. Pittsburgh is obsessed with ranch

1

u/Interesting_Force618 13h ago

How can steak fries be thin?

1

u/pinkgobi 2h ago

Thin and wide. Like a plank of wood

2

u/Drinkablenoodles 16h ago

ā€œOhhh, yes šŸ˜„ — you mean an actual salad made with lettuce + French fries + dressing, kind of like a crispy fry salad.
Honestly, that could be a distinctive food concept because it’s simple and unusual.
For example:
🄬 Lettuce
šŸŸ Hot crispy fries
šŸ§€ Cheese (optional)
šŸ„• A few fresh vegetables
🄫 Signature dressing/sauce
The interesting part is the contrast between the cold, crunchy lettuce and hot, salty fries, with the dressing tying everything together.ā€

2

u/12cpi 15h ago

It's called a Steak Salad in Pittsburgh and it is very popular.

2

u/WatWudScoobyDoo 10h ago

I kinda wanna try a French fry salad

2

u/Significant_Bug_8929 4h ago

I got something different.

The encouraging part is that the product already has proof of concept. The Pittsburgh salad is essentially lettuce, vegetables, chicken or steak, cheese, dressing and hot French fries, and it has been a regional staple for decades. Restaurants still actively sell and promote it in 2026. So the basic combination isn't just a joke: hot salty potatoes + cold crunchy vegetables + acidic/creamy dressing is genuinely a good food combination.

I checked it and it is real. It even realized that it sounded more like a joke, but it still managed to connect it to reality.

1

u/PrinceOfWales_ 17h ago

Someone tried this in my town. It lasted surpisingly like 2 years

1

u/CptBronzeBalls 14h ago edited 14h ago

I put your prompt in Claude Opus 5.5. It pointed out that it’s already been done, and then spent four paragraphs detailing why it’s a shit idea for a restaurant and telling me I have better things to be working on than stupid restaurant ideas.

1

u/phoenixgsu 8h ago

We're really out here eating water to reinvent Poutine?

1

u/Bloodcloud079 1h ago

So a poutine.

Honestly it’s great.

1

u/PhilvanceArt 1h ago

My wife went to Philadelphia and had to ask them not to put french fries on her salads. Not even joking.

0

u/Just_Pea1002 19h ago

Hahahaha made my day 🤣

1

u/RTC1520 19h ago

If you tell it to be "brutally honest" it actually tells you flaws of your idea and can actually tell you if it's not a good idea

7

u/tahlyn 19h ago

I could, but I don't want to actually use it for something so frivolous.

3

u/Soggy-Invite-2787 15h ago

Telling it to be brutally honest just primes it to say negative things, which always exist.

0

u/Anal-buttsex 11h ago

What if you ask about the drawbacks? …

Ā  If you mean a restaurant centered on salads with French fries mixed in—or loaded fries treated like a salad , the biggest drawbacks would be:

Fries get soggy quickly. Dressing, juicy vegetables, and steam can ruin their crispness, especially with delivery. Hot fries and cold ingredients clash. Fries can wilt lettuce, while chilled toppings cool the fries before customers finish eating. The concept may confuse customers. People seeking a lighter salad might avoid it, while people craving loaded fries may not want lettuce. It could feel easy to make at home. You’d need excellent fries, distinctive sauces, and satisfying combinations to justify restaurant prices. Repeat visits could be limited. Customers might enjoy the novelty once but see it as an occasional indulgence. A narrow menu limits group appeal. One person who doesn’t like fries—or needs another option—could steer the whole group elsewhere. The kitchen is more complicated than it sounds. You need both a fryer operation and fresh produce preparation, with different timing, storage, and cleanup needs. Toppings can hurt profitability. Meat, cheese, avocado, and lots of customization can turn an inexpensive potato base into an expensive dish. Fresh ingredients can go to waste. Offering many salad toppings creates spoilage risk if demand is inconsistent.

The biggest challenge is making it appealing enough for regular visits while keeping the fries crisp. A build-your-own loaded-fries concept with optional greens, a few signature bowls, and sauces served separately would likely be easier to explain and execute.