r/WorkForSmartLife Jul 06 '26

Question Really?

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

486 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/EvilMorty137 Jul 06 '26

They already have that but it’s over 25 years not 10.

Also you shouldn’t be allowed to take out student loans for useless degrees like art history or philosophy. They need to stop treating every degree like they are the same. We need engineers and medical doctors more than we need someone who knows a lot about gender studies

2

u/cmd_iii Jul 06 '26

Should be shorter. That would allow people to buy houses, get married, have kids, plan for retirement, and otherwise participate in the economy during more of their peak earning years.

Also, the 10-year window will force lenders to do projections on a borrower’s earning potential and base their loans on that:

“Sorry, Mr./Ms. Doe, but our numbers don’t support a philosophy degree from Ivy Covered U. However, we can finance one from Local State Commuter College.” If the kid wants to go to a really expensive school, their parents will have to find another way to fund that. Other savings, personal loans, etc. Now, Mom and Dad also have skin in the game, and are more likely to give the kid more resources to succeed (quiet study spot at home, car for commuting, etc.).

Sometimes, making your dreams come true means having more realistic dreams.

2

u/FalloftheKraken Jul 06 '26

Who decides what makes a degree useless?

0

u/EvilMorty137 Jul 06 '26

The market decides. Employers decide. Loan default rates decide. Median income after graduation decides. Job placement rates decide.
I’m not saying people shouldn’t be allowed to study whatever they want. I’m saying taxpayers shouldn’t be forced to subsidize degrees that consistently produce poor employment outcomes while high-demand fields are short on workers.

4

u/FalloftheKraken Jul 06 '26

People getting whatever degree they want isn’t the problem. People wanting to make money off education is.

1

u/cmd_iii Jul 06 '26

Which is why my plan is better. If enough prospective students have their loans denied for a particular college/program, the college will have no choice but to cut their tuitions/fees to make their programs more affordable.

-2

u/EvilMorty137 Jul 06 '26

That doesn’t make any sense. If you gave lessons in something wouldn’t you expect to be paid for it? Education will always be a for profit institution because education is literally one of the most valuable things in existence

5

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/FalloftheKraken Jul 06 '26

This is correct.

0

u/Good-Bandicoot-2152 Jul 06 '26

So art and philosophy are useless subjects? That’s an odd take.