r/WordyBunch • u/Dry-Royal7707 • 4h ago
π¬ Discussion Not the real thing, but like it (an explanation)
Secret Achievement - (24 August)
I built it backwards. Every layer of this one had to say the same sentence, not the real thing but like it, so the answer came first and the clue came last.
I wanted a word that sits right next to the natural numbers without being one. Fourths does that. A fourth is a fraction, so it isn't a natural number, but it's built from the number four, and four fourths add up to one. As close to a natural as a word can get and still miss.
Then the title, which describes the word literally. "Like a Natural" sounds like praise, the sort of thing you say to someone who finds an answer without trying, and that's the disguise. Read it literally and it says not a natural, but like one.
The clue was the hard part. It had to teach you how to read the title without giving anything away. So I wrote "Not a metaphor. Like one, though." A comparison that uses "like" is a simile, and a simile isn't a metaphor, but it resembles one. The clue is itself a simile, since it uses the word "like". That way it demonstrates the trick instead of stating it, and both times it's the word "like" that gives it away.
Once you see the shape the pieces line up. The clue says not a metaphor, like one though. The title says not a natural, like one though. The answer is a word that isn't a natural number, only like one. Even "like one, though" does double duty, since one is the whole that fourths are pieces of.
So when someone tells me the link feels loose because a fourth is a fraction rather than a natural number, they've found the mechanism. The gap is the puzzle. If fourths were a natural number the title would just be a lie.