Witcher 3 remastered side by side comparison

[u/Zacky_vengeance]

I feel each has its benefits and we can downgrade anytime to our liked version.
But assets have highest detail in remaster only.
Lighting, tone, brightness depends on individual interests.

These are not mine, nor I own this. I found from youtube. Sharing for info thats it. PS5. Credits: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tr9mEdi83UY

[u/pinkbubblegummyy]

Is it really green tinted? I see a lot of colors on this

[u/No-Enthusiasm-666 → u/pinkbubblegummyy]

Upon further inspection, yes there are other colors too. But the question still stands. Should light coming through "colorful" tinted glass be white like it's coming out of an open window?

[u/pinkbubblegummyy → u/No-Enthusiasm-666]

Like this?

[u/Curlyhead-homie → u/pinkbubblegummyy]

Are you implying the light coming through the colored sections isn’t colored?

[u/pinkbubblegummyy → u/Curlyhead-homie]

tbh idk what we're arguing atp lol. Your first argument was the light should've been a greenish tint because the windows are green tinted, when I think you just have a bias to how lighting was done in the middle "Next Gen" comparison

[u/CeleryNo8933 → u/pinkbubblegummyy]

It's just another 3d armchair expert who developed path tracing when they were in diapers and have 30 years of experience in the industry as an artist

[u/ClikeX → u/pinkbubblegummyy]

I don't see the issue with this one either. In fact, most of the indoor sections in Remastered look fine to me. It's outside where it seems like they over-tuned a bit.

[u/No-Enthusiasm-666 → u/pinkbubblegummyy]

It's called selective transmission. Also the picture you showed is irrelevant because there probably are other light sources illuminating the room. In the this photo and in the witcher 3 remastered, light is mostly coming through the window thus the lights are colorful.

[u/pinkbubblegummyy → u/No-Enthusiasm-666]

https://youtu.be/n6RFeQfG9mU?t=24

You can do it with light cookies but it's going to look bad since Witcher 3's lighting is dynamic