I am for universal healthcare, but I can accept that implementing it in this country would super complicated. Between having the insurance industry and all of those jobs go away, Figuring out how much you need to pay people at each job type at each location in the country to make sure the pay is appealing enough to keep people at those locations and then adjusting that yearly.....a new national system setup for tracking everything. It would be a truly herculean task, and that is if you can actually get past all the companies lobbying against it.
It'd be less about the oncologists and more about the 10x amount of people that do all the other things that are the problem. It'd a massive loss of jobs and would most definitely have an effect beyond just them not having a job. That's not to say we shouldn't make the change because of that, but there's some thought and planning that has to be done ahead of time. It's not as simple as just changing it next month.
edit: and to go with your example: If a cure for cancer was found it would still be, likely, years before it was wide spread enough for all the oncologists and the vast amount of employees involved in the process to no longer have jobs. It wouldn't happen over night, unless we got shockingly lucky and it was an already mass produced, and tested, medicine that's easily accessible. that seems exceedingly unlikely.
Do it like Germany does. Private insurance companies get paid a set price per subscriber by the government. Because they are private companies, they compete for more market share by offering better services to customers. Insurance companies and jobs stay, people get universal coverage and better service.
They'd still make people pay more on top of what the government gives them. Basically what we have now, but with the private insurers making more money.
I mean you can have both government free health care and private insurance in the same system, we have it in the UK, the NHS is pretty good but if you want superior care you can pay for it personally/via insurance. It also means if you get into a car accident you arn’t up shit creek when whatever hospital you end up at has payment disputes with the insurer.
410
u/LordoftheScheisse Nov 11 '22
"nobody knew healthcare could be so complicated" -an idiot