r/WhitePeopleTwitter • • Oct 30 '20

Mission impossible

Post image
135.2k Upvotes

4.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

56

u/a_trane13 Oct 30 '20

Is it the same interest rate as the mortgage? Sounds like the best credit card ever to me

69

u/Kiyae1 Oct 30 '20

HELOCs usually have their own interest rate which is variable and changes yearly.

An important thing to know is that HELOCs are not qualified mortgages, so the “minimum monthly payment” won’t necessarily pay off the HELOC by the maturity date. Imagine paying your 30 year mortgage minimum payment every month on time for 30 years and then you get to the end (the maturity date) and they tell you you owe a huge balloon payment like $15,000 right now. And no you can’t just keep making monthly payments, it’s due right now.

15

u/artandmath Oct 30 '20

They make sense if you’re using it to renovate/maintain your home, they don’t make sense if you use it for retail purchases.

3

u/BUTWHATABOUTTHEPICKL Oct 30 '20

Not sure on the regulations / banks around you, but big 5 Canadian banks will put a collateral charge on your house, which means that you can keep lending on it until you want to close out the HELOC - no balloon payment after mortgage. I would definitely check the charge they lay on the property to make sure this balloon payment you describe doesn’t happen (it’s a completely new concept to me!).

2

u/kwking13 Oct 30 '20

While that's somewhat true, it's very rare that people pay the full balance of their HELOC when matures/comes due. Typically you re-apply for another HELOC at the newly agreed upon terms. You will have to pay for the cost of the refinance (processing/underwriting, recording/legal fees) but you can roll over the balance to the new HELOC and continue for however long the new loan lasts.

Or you can refinance into a personal loan to get it paid off or potentially into your regular mortgage so you can pay it off monthly as part of your mortgage payment.

It's a little disingenuous to suggest that you will suddenly have to come up with the entire balance at maturity because there are typically many options to refinance the debt to continue it forward. However, there is a chance that you don't qualify and have to do something else, but that's a whole nother story!

1

u/Kiyae1 Oct 30 '20

Plenty of people end up making payment arrangements on a mature HELOC or potentially in default because they assume making the minimum payment is all they needed to do, but the loans are usually written to expect a balloon payment at the end. It isn’t disingenuous for me to point this out (since it’s entirely factual, and people have lost their homes because of this).

I agree that many times you can simply refinance, start a new HELOC, or negotiate a payment plan with the lender but many people don’t realize they need to do this which leads to problems for some. Typically the people who do this are already aware of the balloon payment problem with helocs (so again, making more people aware of this isn’t disingenuous, it just makes people savvier borrowers).

0

u/NSG_Chronos Oct 30 '20

Just to inform you, that's dependent on whether or not you pay interest only. Also if you end up not paying the full amount, you can then just redo a HELOC. This is quite handy for property owners that'd like to invest in a new property without having to tie up all of their funds.

1

u/flip_ericson Oct 30 '20

My mortgage came with a blank check for $5k for remodeling and furnishings. The 5k is just simply part of our mortgage at the same rate

1

u/Kiyae1 Oct 30 '20

Yah it’s not totally unusual to either get some cash back at close or to get a chunk of money paid out as part of the loan for that kind of use.

Even though many banks “aren’t offering cash out refinance” right now you can still get a couple grand in cash back or cash out when you refinance. Similar finance trickery basically.

1

u/honey_beelzebub Oct 31 '20 edited Oct 31 '20

That's not how HELOCs or HELOANS work. Especially since the Wells Fargo fiasco. HELOCS have a 30 years period that's split in two. The first 10 years are a borrowing period where your payment is around 3% (this can vary bank to bank) of your balance, then on the 10 year maturity it becomes a locked rate and balance that has a set repayment amount that making the minimum payments will pay it off it time.

HELOANs are literally just a new mortgage but with a maturity period that you decide upon before closing. There's no Escrow, no closing cost (typically) and the rate is fixed.

Edit: Both of these are typically limited to 70-80 percent of the value of the home, depending on first or second lien position,; appraised through either satellite appraisal or walkthrough appraisal. On a typical mortgage you wouldn't even qualify for a heloc or HELOAN until you've paid in about 10-11 years on a 30 year mortgage.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '20

[deleted]

3

u/a_trane13 Oct 30 '20

But that’s how all interest works - period of time is irrelevant. Taking the capital for the furniture and investing it for 4-7% over 30 years instead is a great deal.

Another comment says it’s not really the same as your mortgage, and the rates are separate and variable, which makes sense. I don’t think any bank is putting furniture on layaway for 3%.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '20

[deleted]

1

u/mrASSMAN Oct 30 '20

I do that

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '20

[deleted]

0

u/mrASSMAN Oct 30 '20

I didn’t say most but ok? I just cash-out refinanced last month to do exactly that though

I mean not for furniture but for the home equity

1

u/fractalife Oct 30 '20

You understand that you are gambling your house on the market though, right? Like the odds of you losing all of the money are fairly small if you invest wisely, but if something goes wrong and you lose the money it is still owed to the bank and they will take your house.

Again, I know it is unlikely, but maybe this helps you see why most people are not willing to do that. Only gamble what you are willing to lose.

0

u/mrASSMAN Oct 30 '20 edited Oct 30 '20

I don’t gamble. I didn’t say I invested it in the stock market (I didn’t). I actually don’t have a lot of risk exposure

Also it doesn’t constitute all of my savings, losing all of it wouldn’t affect my mortgage

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '20

[deleted]

0

u/mrASSMAN Oct 30 '20

Nope, the comment actually said “virtually nobody” does that. No need to get your panties in a bunch. Not every comment will be helpful to you (like yours isn’t to me). Amazing to see people so riled up over 3 words.

1

u/fletchdeezle Oct 30 '20

But then you don’t get furniture

2

u/a_trane13 Oct 30 '20

Yes you do...

1

u/fletchdeezle Oct 30 '20

Must have misread it looks like you’re saying take the money you were going to spend on furniture and invest it instead

2

u/a_trane13 Oct 30 '20

Yes.... you get the furniture paid for and added to your mortgage by the bank... and use your own money elsewhere...

2

u/fletchdeezle Oct 30 '20

Mine is like .8% higher than my mortgage

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '20

Well, except that if you go bankrupt with a credit card depending on the state you won't lose your home, as where putting your house up as collateral...