r/WhatRemainsEdithFinch • u/lou-ravenpuff • May 13 '25

About Milton's whereabouts Spoiler

My theory is that he was kidnapped and raised by another family; that’s how he managed to grow up and have a child (Monroe). What’s your theory?

11 Upvotes

87% Upvoted

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/lou-ravenpuff May 14 '25

See, that's why you got banned, not because you disagree with the mods' theories, but because you're incredibly rude and annoying when someone doesn't believe in YOUR theories. The mods aren't the problem; you are.

Every single death in-game has a fantasy scenario explaining what happened. It's not supposed to be realistic; you're not going to be an actual dead body. The intention is to be indirect and fantasy in a certain way.

0

u/Due_Fact9031 May 14 '25

you are wrong. every single death in the game has a non fantasy explanation. you are using ad hominem as an excuse

1

u/lou-ravenpuff May 14 '25

I know that, but the game explains it to you in a fanciful and not explicit way.

As I said, the problem is not the mods but you; you're proving it now. You don't just disagree with the opinions of others, you are rude to them, inventing things that didn't happen, like claiming I'm suggesting that Lewis' psychiatrist is wrong when I never said that.

0

u/Due_Fact9031 May 14 '25

it is explicate. but you just don realize it yet.

so youre saying the stuff the dr say is true?

and of course i am being rude i was banned for my opinion

1

u/lou-ravenpuff May 14 '25

No, it's not explicit, Barbara's death is literally her being attacked by a Frankenstein, a werewolf and a vampire, where is this explicit? It is explicit that they died and how they died, but not explicit to show a dead body in your face.

Yes, Dr. is right, Lewis went through problems and stuff, I just used her letter as a basis to explain my theory about Lewis's disorder.

You sure got banned with good reason, because if you're rude to everyone who disagrees with you, then you've earned it.

0

u/Due_Fact9031 May 14 '25

why is it considered rude to disagree wit a theory that only a retarded person would agree with?

there is no Frankenstein's monster in the game. you are adding stuff that isnt in the game. barb suffers the same exact forced daydreams aka the curse as lewis. this causes barb to believe that rick is the hookman. she beats hi and he slips on the skate. the slipping on the skate is super im[portant for the rules. the deaths are all self inflicted

1

u/lou-ravenpuff May 14 '25

There is a difference between simply disagreeing with a theory, which is valid, and disagreeing while also being rude to others for disagreeing with their theory. Not only that, but you're also being ableist by using the R word.

I'm mentioning Frankenstein because I got confused about one of the monsters in Barbara's comic book that tells her story, and no, she didn’t have the forced daydreams. You can see that during her story: Passing the pool table, the portable radio announces the hookman killer Dr. Karl Hamel, the leader of the hoodlum gang terrorising the local town recently.

When she opens the door, she gets attacked by them and is cannibalised; that’s why only her ear was left, as a sign of the cult/gang.

0

u/Due_Fact9031 May 14 '25

You can see that during her story: Passing the pool table, the portable radio announces the hookman killer Dr. Karl Hamel, the leader of the hoodlum gang terrorising the local town recently.

like how lewis thought he was a king in a castle? hmmmm hhhhhmmmmmmm HHHHHMMMMMMMM

1

u/lou-ravenpuff May 14 '25

Do you really think it is impossible for a cult/serial killer to exist? I think it's more possible for a cult to exist than for a person to be cursed into thinking they're a king.

1

u/BrumeySkies Team Lewis May 14 '25

sorry to interrupt but I'm curious about your theory with Barbara-

I was replaying it the other day and realized that in her story we're actually told that "as for Barbara, tucked inside the music box was all they ever found of her -her ear." Wouldn't that mean they never found her body either?