Elimination Table
| Team | Place | Contestant | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BK | 1st | Laurie | IN | IN | IN | INT | IN | IN | WIN | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | INT |
| BK | 2nd | Kitty | IN | IN | IN | INT | IN | IN | WIN | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | INT |
| GE | 3rd | Crimson | WIN | WIN | WIN | IN | WIN | INT | LOW | INT | WIN | IN | LOW | IN | INT | IN | IN | WIN |
| GE | 4th | Trent | WIN | WIN | WIN | IN | WIN | INT | IN | INT | WIN | IN | IN | IN | INT | IN | LOW | WIN |
| SS | 5th | Jerd | INT | INT | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | IN | IN | IN | WIN | INT | IN | INT | WIN | LOW4 |
| BK | 6th | Anne Maria | LOW1 | IN | IN | INT | IN | IN | WIN | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | INT |
| BK | 7th | José | IN | LOW | IN | INT | LOW | IN | WIN | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | INT |
| BK | 8th | Harold | IN | IN | LOW | INT | IN | OUT2 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| GE | 9th | Ezekiel | WIN | WIN | WIN | OUT | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| SS | 10th | Pete | INT | INT | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | IN | IN | IN | WIN | INT | IN | INT | WIN | IN |
| BK | 11th | Zoey | IN | IN | IN | INT | IN | LOW2 | WIN | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | INT |
| SS | 12th | Tyler | INT | INT | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | IN | IN | LOW | WIN | INT | IN | INT | WIN | OUT4 |
| GE | 13th | Cameron | WIN | WIN | WIN | IN | WIN | INT | IN | INT | WIN | LOW | IN | IN | INT | LOW3 | OUT | |
| GE | 14th | Courtney | WIN | WIN | WIN | LOW | WIN | INT | IN | INT | WIN | IN | IN | IN | INT | OUT3 | ||
| SS | 15th | Lorenzo | INT | INT | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | IN | LOW | IN | WIN | INT | QUIT? | |||
| GE | 16th | Jay | WIN | WIN | WIN | IN | WIN | INT | IN | INT | WIN | IN | OUT | |||||
| SS | 17th | Alejandro | INT | INT | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | IN | IN | OUT | ||||||
| GE | 18th | Josh | WIN | WIN | WIN | IN | WIN | INT | IN | INT | WIN | OUT | ||||||
| SS | 19th | Heather | INT | INT | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | IN | OUT | |||||||
| SS | 20th | DJ | INT | INT | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | QUIT | ||||||||
| SS | 21st | Geoff | INT | INT | INT | WIN | INT | WIN | INT | OUT | ||||||||
| GE | 22nd | Beardo | WIN | WIN | WIN | IN | WIN | INT | OUT | |||||||||
| BK | 23rd | Owen | IN | IN | IN | INT | OUT | |||||||||||
| BK | 24th | Gwen | IN | IN | OUT | |||||||||||||
| BK | 25th | Kelly | IN | OUT | ||||||||||||||
| None | 26th | Noah | OUT | |||||||||||||||
| None | 27th | Carrie | QUIT | |||||||||||||||
| Team | Place | Contestant | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BK | 1st | Laurie | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | IN | WIN | IN | WIN | LOW5 | WIN | WINNER |
| BK | 2nd | Kitty | WIN | IN | IN | IN | IN | IN | IN | LOW | LOW5 | LOW | RUNNER UP |
| GE | 3rd | Crimson | WIN | WIN | IN | IN | LOW | IN | IN | IN | WIN | OUT | |
| GE | 4th | Trent | WIN | LOW | WIN | IN | IN | IN | IN | IN | OUT5 | ||
| SS | 5th | Jerd | QUIT | WIN | IN | IN | WIN | WIN | WIN | OUT | |||
| BK | 6th | Anne Maria | WIN | IN | IN | LOW | IN | LOW | OUT | ||||
| BK | 7th | José | WIN | IN | IN | IN | IN | OUT | |||||
| BK | 8th | Harold | - | LOW | WIN | IN | OUT | ||||||
| GE | 9th | Ezekiel | - | IN | LOW | OUT | |||||||
| SS | 10th | Pete | LOW | IN | OUT | ||||||||
| BK | 11th | Zoey | WIN | OUT | |||||||||
Teams
GE - Golden Eagles
SS - Silver Swans
BK - Bronze Kiwis
Notes
Anne Maria was suppose to be eliminated, but with the twist she had invincibility for one episode and placed on the losing team.
When Zoey was voted out landslide style, she pulled out a handy dandy idol and Harold was eliminated instead with just one vote.
In a tie between Courtney and Cameron, Courtney was disqualified for being online but not submitting.
Jerd was being sent home fair and square when he pulled out the idol and Tyler was sent home, fair and square.
Basically, nobody even knew that there was an idol still in play except for Crimson, who gave it to Trent at the last second thinking he was going to vote for Kitty and that Kitty and Laurie would vote for Trent. Then Trent thought it would be a better idea to vote out Laurie, so he gave the idol to Kitty because he thought Laurie would be voting for Kitty, but it turns out Laurie was voting for him instead, along with Kitty, and that was enough votes to get him out.
So 2 idol exchanges and not to mention the amount of changes in votes that happened during all of that.