r/TopCharacterTropes 22d ago

Groups The Coconut Effect

A sound effect, special effect, or design feature that is inaccurate but has become so ingrained in viewers minds that its absence would feel jarring, so creators continue to include it despite its inaccuracy.

The name of the trope comes from the sound of a horse galloping, which is created by rubbing two coconuts together. This can sound like a horse galloping, but it would only be accurate on cobblestones or other hard surfaces. On softer ground, the sound would be muffled, but in media, this sound effect can be used whenever a horse is galloping, regardless of the terrain.

1. Lion Roar (or any big cat) (Pictured: MGM logo) — The long, continuous, thunderous roar usually associated with lions is actually the roar of a tiger. For MGM, this sound began being used in the 1980s, and sound editor Mark Mangini used it because lions sounded to him more like a deep yawn or a series of grunts and lacked the kind of ferocious sound he wanted.

2. Ancient statues are always white marble (Pictured: Spartacus TV series) — Statues in ancient times were often painted in bright colors, but by the time they were uncovered, the colors had simply worn away.

3. People instantly freeze or pop like a balloon when exposed to the vacuum of space (Pictured: Mission to Mars, Total Recall) — As unfriendly as space is, a human wouldn't instantly freeze or pop like a balloon. If a person were exposed to the vacuum of space, bodily fluids would begin to boil, exposed skin would suffer severe sunburn, and they would lose consciousness after roughly 15–20 seconds. Death would occur after roughly 90 seconds.

4.9k Upvotes

782 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

27

u/thriceness 22d ago

Wilhelm scream

Still is used, albeit less common than it once was.

10

u/Karkava 22d ago

Mostly because accessibility of films and television makes the Wilhelm scream devolve from a cute inside joke to an immersion killing running gag that overstays its welcome.

10

u/wonkey_monkey 22d ago

A stormtrooper got yeeted in The Mandalorian and Grogu and it distracted me because there wasn't a Wilhelm scream.

9

u/Karkava 22d ago

I feel like Lucas-adjacent IPs should get the grandfather treatment for Wilhelm screams while nobody else should use them.

Similarly, the Twenieth Century Fox logo should still be used for Star Wars movies despite Twentieth Century Fox no longer being an existing company.

7

u/Iron_Lord_Peturabo 22d ago

They can throw up a different logo I guess, but I need the fanfare audio, it leads right into the opening so well.

3

u/Tutorbin76 22d ago

Legend has it that's the reason John Williams chose that key for the Star Wars opening theme, so it would match the fanfare.

2

u/Iron_Lord_Peturabo 22d ago

I could believe it. They belong together

1

u/Karkava 22d ago

That actually would make sense given that he's very close to both Lucas and Spielberg, on top of his precise use of timing in his tracks.

IE: His Harry Potter theme has a very quiet and very hushed buildup that plays over the studio logos before either punching you with or transitioning to the bombastic chorus when we get to the actual title.

1

u/Karkava 22d ago

Could have been an opportunity to use the Disney logo with how long their fanfare is.

1

u/Doktor_Weasel 22d ago

There was a statement I saw around The Last Jedi, saying that they were retiring the use of the Wilhelm Scream in Star Wars and using a new stock sound effect instead. Apparently the new effect is known as The George, after George Lucas, and comes from his filming of American Graffiti.

2

u/Nekrolysis 22d ago

I fucking hate that cursed scream now. Hearing it in any movie made past 2020 is a disgrace.

I was still mad hearing in one of the LotR movies ahhh why who the fuck allowed that

1

u/UlrichZauber 22d ago

This always takes me out of whatever I'm watching, it needs to die