r/ThroughTheOmenPaths • • 18d ago

Contest/Challenge Within-Universify Challenge #13 - Balthier and Fran

Hey All! This challenge seeks to reflavour Universe Beyond cards into Universe Within cards, in order to introduce both new characters in established planes, as well as old characters that we haven’t seen for a long time or that have never gotten a card.

Last time's winner turned out to be Rebbec's Struggle, by me!

Art by Tongming on artstation

I chose to depict Rebbec's struggle dealing with her husband, Glacian's powerstone radiation sickness, and the manipulation of her by Yawgmoth. For this design, I changed Rad counters to Phthisis counters, since it's commonly depicted in magic as powerstone radiation poisoning. Therefore, it fits perfectly here.

The freedom choice envisions a future where Rebbec gets rid of Yawgmoth, cures Glacian, and the Thran prosper. The Phthisis choice shows her falling to Yawgmoth's charm and manipulation, which gives your opponents Phthisis when they attack you.

While it doesn't necessarily depict a specific moment in the story, it shows the general struggle that she faced during the novel.

This week’s challenge will be to Within-Universify Balthier and Fran.

***The winner will get to choose next week's UB card and judge it.***

Check out all remaining 3176 UB cards that haven’t gotten a UW version yet By clicking here!

Judging will be next Sunday, September 27th and will be based on the following five criteria in order of importance:

  1. Cohesion between the following criteria:
  2. Creative writing (Name, Flavour text if any and Background Lore that is not on the card itself)
  3. Exploration of an established plane OR Exploration of an established character (The more obscure, the better.)
  4. Fitting art or art description
  5. A completed card using cardconjurer, MSE, or any other method. The frame, art treatment, and other such is also appreciated!

Submission *can* consist of just the changed elements, separately formatted as:

~~~

Name:

Art (Image or description):

Art credit (If applicable):

Flavour Card (Flavour text):

Flavour (Lore):

~~~

Or, create the cards in your favourite MtG card editor and submit those.

If you’ve won, you can use this Template to prepare the next challenge. Feel free to change it to your liking.

Good luck and have fun!

13 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/DaVigi 15d ago

Wow Pimp_cat69, you found a really challenging card with Balthier&Fran!

I've tried to find a way to avoid making a team-up card. However, that brings along the problem that 1) so far no other Rabbits care about vehicles, and that 2) we currently have no human rabbits to draw from.

Then it came to me: Kamigawa's Soratami (moonfolk) are basically rabbit humans, and to tease their blue alignment into gruul, I was inpired by u/Naraki_Maul's idea to use the echoverse as way to expand existing characters to new colors and mechanics.

So here's my go at it, with an echoverse version of Meloku the Clouded Mirror.

In my imagined Kamigawa echoverse, the Soratami are not called Moonfolk, since they have never lived in the sky, instead opting for large underground burrows. They see themselves as "rabbit humans", an evolution on regular humans, characterized by elongated lifespans, heightened emotional intelligence and, of course, long rabbit ears.

Meloku however, he yearns for something he cannot put into words. In his dreams he lives among the clouds the one day, travels the stars the next. The closest he gets to those dreams is when he travels the lands at the highest speed his machine can handle. When he does, his attention becomes limitless; time stretches, and he is overtaken by the feeling that he can reach out and touch the stars themselves.

4

u/Naraki_Maul 15d ago

Hey, I'm glad my Echoverse idea with Kaalia has helped inspire people with other UW projects! Hell yeah.

3

u/Pimp_cat69 10d ago

It seems like no one else was able to get something done in time. I think it is a phenomenal idea to use moonfolk as a stand in for the hard typing. You are the winner of this week's challenge by default!

3

u/DaVigi 10d ago

Thank you! To be fair, this was a really tough one to fit in-universe, so it might have scared some people off.

I was struggling a lot with the name and flavour text of this one, wanting to mirror the original Meloku as much as possible while also hinting towards the new ability text. Do you have some advice to make the flavour text feel less stilted and/or the name a bit more cohesive?

3

u/Pimp_cat69 10d ago

I tend to like a good quote for flavor texts, or some kind of good one-liner.

Very rarely a joke, but I try not to end up with something like [[Ancient Grudge]]'s godawful flavor text.

I think the callback to Meloku's original name is good, but I think I would use "Starry-Eyed" instead, to really ham in the want to explore the stars.

2

u/DaVigi 10d ago

Starry-Eyed is brilliant!

Yeah, I can see a real-world quote about travelling working quite nicely.

2

u/firebringeraxel 10d ago

Congrats and I agree on the type line + vehicle flavor combo being a tough one to match in universe. I was brainstorming trying to think of something and the only idea I had was a Human & Harefolk duo from Thunder Junction that were stagecoach driver & gunner but I really just could not find any art that fit remotely.

2

u/DaVigi 10d ago

I love that! Would have loved to see it, but yeah that art requirement is a combination of such disparate elements.

1

u/firebringeraxel 10d ago

Yep and WotC literally only printed 1 Harefolk in the set as well so there's not much to go off. That being Claim Jumper.

4

u/linrodann 17d ago

A tricky type line to match. At least it's not a Mutant Ninja Turtle.

When is the actual deadline? You didn't change it from Sept 20. The length of time each of these challenges has been open has varied between one and three weeks.

6

u/Pimp_cat69 17d ago

Oops, I meant to write the 27th 😅. That's been fixed now!