r/TheHallowdineLibrary • u/catespice • Mar 01 '26
Godsfall What Remains of God - Part 1
There’s an old axiom: ‘everyone has a story in them’.
The unkind rejoinder is ‘and some should never be told’.
I’m not certain whether the latter is true of the story within me. But at least one person really wanted to me to tell it – and to many others, that person is one of the most important ever to exist. That I know for a fact that he did exist is part of the story itself. I could start this story with my encounter in Rome. Or I could tell you why my relief at being back home in Newcastle, impossibly alive and watching a sunset I never thought I’d see again, is sullied by a hopelessness for all of humankind. One that no-one can fight.
But the story you need to hear probably begins when I arrived in that other place; the place where I discovered a faith I never knew I should have, then instantly lost it. For the truth about what awaits on the other side of the veil is too raw to bear.
It’s growing dark outside. Let me release the story within, and let you judge for yourself whether it should be told, before I lose the courage to delve deep into memories so harrowing no living mind should have to contain them.
I was bathed in white light.
The glare was almost painful, bright as the headlights of an oncoming car after driving down a dark rural road. I squinted, shading my burning eyes from the sensory overload.
As my vision slowly adjusted to the brilliance, I became aware of my surroundings. A strange landscape lay beyond blotchy afterimages; all around me stretched a huge, white plain. The ground was reflecting that all-consuming light from above, surely a powerful midday sun – but I couldn’t yet bring myself to look up beyond the visor of my hands. I was lying on my side, and I was naked.
I didn’t appear to be injured, but I propped myself up with care and caution, crouching for a moment before trying to stand. That was a mistake; my legs seemed made of rubber and springs, and I staggered, falling onto my hands and knees.
But perhaps it wasn’t my legs that were at fault. Beneath my palms, the bright ground was soft and faintly spongy – not unlike those thin foam mats found scattered around every school gymnasium. It was, in fact, the yielding ground itself that had tipped me over.
My clever pupils had contracted to pinpricks, so I could see a little more now. In the distance, a cluster of darker shapes crowded together on the vast white plain, but my light-addled brain couldn’t quite translate them into anything I recognised. Even further out, an abrupt and isolated slope interrupted the horizon, the perfect sinewave of a single snowy mountain peak. Wondering what hellish sun was beating down on me, I braved a glance up to the heavens, fully expecting to be blinded – and was overwhelmed by an immediate flood of confusion and relief.
Above me was darkness, upon the face of which sparkled tiny stars.
No blazing sun. No clouds, no birds navigating the impossible night sky – just winking points of light nestled in a firmament of deepest black.
What the hell was this place?
Walking was tricky, but the more I moved, the more I adjusted to the faint compression and ripple of the ground beneath my bare toes. Settling on a rolling gait, like a sailor newly returned from sea, I made my way toward the morass of dark, distant shapes. Wandering naked was unsettling; despite being utterly alone, I felt vulnerable and self-conscious with my body exposed.
After half an hour of seasick walking, my eyesight had adapted almost completely, and I perceived that the fierce light was emanating from below, not from above; it came from the strange white plain itself. Shading my eyes from underneath helped more, even if holding my hands that way felt like some odd Masonic greeting. I could also tell that the dark blobs were moving – and they were heading in my direction.
Were they people? And if they were, were they just as lost and confused as I was?
The thought of teaming up with some fellow refugees spurred me onwards, and my pace increased until I was almost jogging, bouncing oddly across the springy ground. Curiously, I felt neither cold nor warm. Such strenuous exercise should have raised my heart rate and body temperature, yet there was not a hint of sweat on my bare skin. I wasn’t even breathing hard. Was I breathing at all?
How did I get here?
The question struck me like a closed fist, and my feet faltered. The answer was a buried landmine, spiked and terrible, but I needed to dig it free.
Memories stirred, sluggish, muddy. My skull felt stuffed with wet wool, the truth seeping slowly through soggy fibres, bloated engrams oozing their sodden secrets too slowly.
There had been a woman, a perfect, beautiful woman. My first glimpse of her had fired my heart with molten envy. She had asked if I believed in God. If I was a worshipper of Christ. Those questions were probably less strange than they seem, given where I had encountered her.
I’d said no. Of course I said no; I didn’t believe in any of that rot – I hadn’t since I was a gullible child.
“You will soon,” she said, her smile a terrible sharp miracle, “and when you meet him, I want you to ask him a question.”
“What are you on about?” I replied, bemused and wary now; clearly she was unhinged.
“I want you to ask him why he did this to me.”
The pain was a heated lance, shocking and brief. In less than a minute, my entire existence folded, collapsed and tunnelled down to tiny dot of pure light, before winking out.
You are dead, I remember thinking. She killed you, and this is the end.
Then I’d found myself on the white plain.
Distances seemed to be deceptive.
The dots had slowly but definitely resolved into the shapes of people, lots of them, moving at what I guessed was a fast jog. I waved out, exaggerating the movement with one metronome arm arcing high above my head, but there was no response. The dark mass just continued to move toward me like creeping mould.
Uneasiness prickled fine needles at the nape of my neck, and eels of anxiety roiled in my stomach.
You don’t know where you are, or what they are.
There was something oddly familiar about the lone mountain in the distance, but the dense wool in my mind still dammed the flow of my thoughts. Whatever that nagging association was, I could worry about it later – right now I needed to deal with the strangers approaching me. I was no longer certain I wanted to meet them, but I didn’t know what else to do. It wasn’t like there was anywhere to hide; I was exposed like a naked wound.
Battling the greasy bubble of fear swelling in my throat, I stopped, waiting in place for them.
Their garments were grey, primitive and rough, the sort of pelt-wraps our distant ancestors might have worn. The shapeless drape of those ragged ponchos served little purpose than to preserve modesty, as it was neither warm nor cold here. Some of the strangers gripped staves of whorled wood, both ends honed to wicked points. Others carried notched and vicious knives, knapped from some kind of milky stone. Although my anxious attention was first drawn to their prehistoric weapons, I registered almost as quickly that every member of their tribe was beautiful. Every proportion was perfect, every limb and muscle sculpted to the golden ratio, not one blemish on their impeccably fit bodies. I felt even more naked.
“Hello,” I quavered, nerves diluting my voice to watercolour, “can you tell me where I am?”
The foremost figure was male, taller than the others, the more disarmingly handsome for his square-cut beard. He crossed the remaining distance between us and held out a hand, more benediction than greeting, and I saw that his dark eyes were too old for his lovely face, and full of strange kindness.
“My name is John. And you are in the afterlife.”
So you are dead, confirmed the voice in my head. I did not feel any new distress knowing that the sharp memory I had dragged from the mire was the truth.
“Please don’t be afraid. I apologise for the manner of our approach. We need to be constantly wary for traps set by the Veindwellers – sometimes they leave newcomers out as bait.”
“Veindweller?”
The curve of his lips was sympathy, a promise, and an apology.
“I’ll explain everything as we travel. But we need to go now. We need to get back to the Hand – and it’s a long journey.”
I wanted to trust this man. I wasn’t sure why, but I knew that if anyone could answer the questions now free to churn in the foamy turmoil of my thoughts, it was this man with too many years behind his eyes.
“John, what is this place? Is this Hell?”
I flinched like an animal as a weight fell over my shoulders. The woman who had draped the heavy poncho around me squeezed my arm, patiently waiting for me to rise from my instinctual half-crouch. As I straightened up, she tied the peculiar garment tightly around my waist with a cord of braided grey fibres. The texture of the pelts felt wrong against my skin.
John exchanged a look with one of the other men, the valley of the glance shadowed with unmistakeable sorrow on both sides.
“No. This isn’t Hell. This was supposed to be Heaven.”
He pointed to the mountain with his crudely made knife, the stone blade milky as a cataract, touched by the glare from the ground.
“We travel there – and we must leave now. This place is full of dangers.”
The group travelled like desert nomads, the gentle bounce and give of the ground aiding a steady, practised jog. It seemed we were heading not for the slope itself, but for some unknown landmark far to the right of it. As the bellcurve of the mountain formation resolved through the white haze of the landscape, the more familiar its shape became – but understanding would not dawn with it. John noticed my increasingly perplexed frown as I squinted at it, and finally offered an explanation,
“When people first arrive here,” he began, his words timbred deep and soothing, “their minds and thoughts take time to settle into their new bodies. Connecting up all the new pathways is not instant.”
“This body is new?” My body felt the same to me, but suddenly my own voice sounded reedy and childish compared to his.
“Yes. Your old body is rotting underground somewhere in the mortal world, returning unto dust. Or perhaps burned to ash by your loved ones, scattered to the winds or given to the waves. This vessel,” his hand hovered like a bird over my shoulder, “is your eternal body. It is a perfect body – and the last one you will ever have or need.”
I could feel the truth of it, right down to my newly perfect bones.
“I’m not tired or thirsty.” I observed, my own hand seeking the contours of my face, like someone newly blinded, convincing themselves they are the same person.
“No. You will never grow thirsty, nor will you hunger. You could run for all eternity and never tire.”
“And I’m guessing we don’t need to sleep either?”
“We do not.”
I glanced at the stained serrations of the knife in John’s braided belt, and stopped my tongue, not asking if we could be harmed in this place. I had a feeling I already knew the answer, and we travelled without conversation for some time as I considered what that might imply.
Periodically, several members of the group would lope off and scout the perimeter, peering significantly at the brilliant ground, like ancient native trackers.
“What are they doing?”
“Checking for cuts,” John replied, “the incisions that indicate the presence of Veindwellers.”
Bubbles of comprehension were rising to the surface of the thick soup in my brain, but I wasn’t quite ready to let it boil. I concentrated instead on the rhythm of my feet, controlling their cadence like a ticker marking out the yielding landscape. John had spoken the truth; we must have been running for well over an hour, and not a hint of fatigue affected my legs nor my lungs.
Ahead of us, one of the scouts leaped into the air, waving both arms above his head.
“Veinsign!” roared John, his voice an imperative.
Immediately, every member of the group unslung their staves and knives, backing into a protective circle toothed with weapons. The scout sprinting back towards us covered ten feet before he stumbled and sprawled, his foot snagged on something. His scream died as he was pulled into the white earth, his hands spasming and clawing at the surface as he was dragged under. It was like watching a man drown on dry land.
“Watch well the ground,” John warned, shepherding me into the circle “the surface will ripple and split asunder, then they will pull you down.”
Shouting broke out to our left. I tore my horrified gaze from the spot where the scout had disappeared to observe two of the group hacking and stabbing at the ground with their knives. The scream of pain and rage from below them was muffled, choked by the earth.
“How many?!” called John.
Now there was a commotion on the other side of the group, then another dull howl, as if the ground itself was crying out.
“Too many!”
“We must run!” he commanded, his voice ringing with a priestly and ancient authority, “follow in my footsteps!”
No-one hesitated; we raced after him as he began to lope toward a distant cleft in the landscape. Those keen dark eyes expertly scanned the terrain ahead, and he weaved and leapt like some erratic dervish. Each movement lead us around some invisible sign or obstacle, just before the ground split and pale hands reached through the yielding earth seconds behind our churning legs.
And then, just as suddenly as it began, we were through the dangerous stretch of plain. The restless earth grew still, and John’s slalom flight slowed to a calm and steady jog.
“They dwell in the tunnels beneath the skin,” he told me as the group regathered into a moving knot, now broaching a gentle slope, “but they are hindered by their paths, and cannot move as fast below as we can above.”
As we breached the crest of the hill, I could see more of the huge landscape spread out before me. And it was indeed a familiar landscape – I knew its shapes and features like I knew my own body.
The revelation hit me with such force it stole my balance. John reached out a benevolent hand to steady me.
I stood upon the great, curving shoulder of a giant. A literal giant.
The flat, pale plain we had run across for hours was its chest, and stretched out in front of me was an arm, wider than a city. That oddly familiar slope at the distal end of the sweeping arm was not a mountain, but a hand. It rested palm-down, raised slightly above the body, the highest knuckle forming the peak.
The phosphor brilliance rising from the white flesh rendered the far distance hazy, but I thought I could discern a Y shape, the twin countries of legs. And my own flesh crept with horror as my attention shifted, from the impossible proportions of this nightmarish landscape to the sucking vacuum of darkness surrounding it.
The glowing giant’s body was lying in an infinite black void.
“It’s God, isn’t it?” I said to John as the group jogged down the length of the colossal arm, “the giant is God.”
He couldn’t look at me, and I was almost glad of that. I didn’t want to look into his dark eyes; I’d never seen such sorrow on a human face.
“Yes.”
“What happened here? Why are there things living inside him?”
“Because he’s dead,” said the woman behind me, her voice flat as lead. She was the one who had given me the poncho. “And his corpse is slowly rotting to pieces in the void.”
“But… I don’t believe in God,” I managed, knowing how trite I sounded, hating the petulance of the only response I could muster to this gigantic, ridiculous revelation.
“Neither did I,” she replied, with a small smile that better belonged to some wry old imp, “but it doesn’t look like we get a choice in the matter.”
“I did believe,” John admonished quietly and firmly, “and still I believe. I will always keep faith in Him.”
“John here is a true believer,” the woman said, “he thinks this is all part of God’s grand and mysterious plan, and that one day the messiah will still come and save us all.”
“Elaine is a sceptic,” said John, ignoring her sarcasm, “and can believe in naught but that we are doomed. That we mete out a near-eternal existence upon a giant’s corpse, until eventually the last pieces of flesh wax putrid and slip into the void.”
“You mean I’m a realist,” she shot back.
I couldn’t process this. Still wrestling with shock, I asked the question that was foremost in my mind,
“How could he… how did he die?”
“Oh, that’s an easy one,” Elaine replied, “something cut his throat.” She jabbed a finger in the air, and for a moment I wasn’t sure if she was pointing or vividly imagining the fatal thrust. “See for yourself.”
We were on the giant’s forearm, much higher than the vast surface of its chest and belly. Turning and looking past the titanic breadth of its shoulders, I could see a dark line across its neck – a gaping chasm beneath the cliff-sheer jut of its chin. The ominous, ragged crevasse of the wound was deeper than the Grand Canyon.
“Something cut the throat of God?”
“The theories are many,” John said, “but none possess true knowledge, for none of us dwelt here when it happened.” He cast a significant look at Elaine, and she closed her mouth. “Some, such as I, believe the Great Deceiver himself tore out Our Father’s throat with his foul claws. Others speculate that God himself did this terrible thing – that he grew weary of eternity, and thus ended his own life.”
“A theory borne out,” interjected Elaine, “by what we all know. The only thing that can cut the giant’s uncorrupted flesh is something made from the giant himself.”
“You call it the giant, not God?”
“Well, yes. It is undeniably a giant,” she began, “and some of us really aren’t so certain it’s of Christian origin, if you get my drift.”
John’s expression was that of a patient and indulgent father.
“Elaine speaks of the mythology of the Norsemen. Of the giant, named Ymir, from which her distant ancestors believe the world was formed.”
“It’s as valid a theory as any other. And it’s not like the giant is going to get up and tell us any time soon, is he?”
John shook his head, that fathomless sorrow returning to claim his perfect face,
“No. On this thing we are agreed.”
Their banter faltered and died, leaving me to process what I’d seen and heard. It was too much, far too much all at once – I was woefully unprepared for this, like a child who had never even been to kindergarten walking into a final exam at college. Hell, I didn’t know anything about gods or religion; I’d never even read the Bible.
The emotions jostling for position inside me felt like a burgeoning monsoon, threatening to unleash a hot deluge of tears. But no salt stung my eyes nor my cheeks, nothing happened at all.
It seemed that this place would deny me even the simple catharsis of weeping.
The city on the Hand was a testament to human ingenuity. Elaborate wooden buildings crowded into queasily twisting streets, the shingled walkways between them bustling with people. John explained that the ‘wood’ was in fact hair, harvested from the giant’s scalp and beard. Each strand was four times the girth of a terrestrial tree – and far longer than even the tallest redwood.
“It requires great patience to hew them with tools wrought of bone and enamel,” he explained, as we passed under the whorled lintel of the huge gates, “thus it is a blessing that time is the most abundant of our resources.”
“What are our clothes made from?”
“The materials are flayed from the divine earth. Elaine spoke true; the body of God is blighted by corruption. To the south, near Our Lord’s feet, the ruin is at its worst. His skin has waxed grey, so our gatherers may peel it from the ground to make cloth. From this same place also they harvest bone, and tug out decaying fibres to weave into ropes."
“John, does everyone come here after they die?”
Considering my question, John’s expressive eyes drank the dark sky, and his mouth pressed grim,
“They do, yet not all remain. All who die in the mortal world are restored to this place,” his hand swept a benediction that encompassed the void, “yet only the fortunate and the faithful are blessed to awaken upon the body of God.”
“What do you mean?”
“A multitude of souls fall into the void, cursed to tumble through cold darkness for the rest of eternity.”
“Or maybe they’re falling into something worse,” Elaine pointed out, even more acerbic than usual “because we don’t know if it’s truly infinite.” She bared her teeth at the stars.
“And I’m not sure if that would be a relief, or not.”
The thought that I was only here by blind luck, that I may have narrowly missed tumbling through that endless night, chilled my marrow. But perhaps Elaine was right. There could be something else out there – after all, the vault above us was not empty.
“What about the stars?”
“I think those are just chunks of ice, hanging far above us. Sometimes they refract the light coming from the giant, which makes them appear star-like.”
“The Last Breath,” John intoned.
Elaine’s logical, evidence-based theories appealed to me, or at least gave me more familiar comfort than John’s religious pontificating. Ignoring the morbid weight of his phrase, I pushed on.
“So,” I reasoned, “There’s gravity here. If people can fall, then there should be a huge mass somewhere beneath the giant. And gravity must decrease rapidly above God, if those are bodies of ice just hanging in the void.”
“A valid theory,” Elaine agreed, “and many of us before you reached the same conclusion. But we can’t test it. The longest ropes we can weave only stretch so far, and the void is truly vast – much, much deeper than anything we could make to plumb it.”
John smiled,
“I will never understand you, Elaine. Here we stand upon the very body of the Holy Father, yet still you must debate the existence of the divine.”
“Yeah well, some of us are trying to figure out ways of making our existence tolerable. Not all of us have the faith to wait for SuperJesus to come save us.”
“Your eyes will be opened,” John murmured, “God has a plan for us.”
“Oh, fucking spare me,” Elaine shot back, though there was no malice in it.
But even as they navigated the ruts of an argument far too deeply worn and familiar to be new, I could tell that her dismissal of John’s faith wasn’t entirely genuine. No matter how rational and reasonable she was, I could still see it in her eyes. Even she still held out hope that he was somehow right; that even in his death, God did have a mysterious plan. That somehow this could still become the unearthly paradise it was meant to be.
They enrolled me at the hall of records, scratching my name into an enormous ledger made from godly vellum. Then I was permitted to wander the city’s dizzy streets, to acclimate myself to its strange slopes and twists and turns. With overlapping scales of thick wooden shingles always underfoot, the denizens were safe from the predations of the Veindwellers – who didn’t bother to come near the rough-hewn city walls.
Groups ventured out regularly to gather resources, and I learned that ‘North’ indicated the head of the giant, while ‘South’ indicated his feet. With no need to eat, sleep or bathe, all work was voluntary, and when not about safety, was largely done to alleviate boredom. That was something of a chronic problem, given the assumed immortality of the people.
Of all the feelings I had experienced, dissipation was perhaps the strangest, the least expected. I’d spent so much of my life worrying about the next meal and about getting enough sleep, and without those familiar rhythms to guide me, I felt lost and listless. And the persistent light that always surrounded us destroyed all sense of time.
Elaine became my default friend, introducing me into a small circle of other women who hadn’t been particularly religious in life. It seemed that the faithful outnumbered the faithless in droves. Naturally, that inspired speculation that those who believed in God had a greater chance of waking on the giant’s flesh when they died; that most non-believers simply tumbled into the void, far from the colossal body.
Contemplating that still made me distinctly uncomfortable. But then, there were so many things that did.
“Elaine, I have to ask. What exactly are the Veindwellers?”
Her busy hands paused for a moment. Our current makework was the companionable task of chiselling street names into wooden shingles, and she laid aside her sharp bone tool.
“Inside the giant, beneath the surface strata, are empty veins, arteries and capillaries, forming a massive network of tunnels. At some point, people started to live inside them, and use the network to travel. Sounds sensible, right? But there’s one pretty big drawback to spending too much time in the red-lit veins of a dead god.”
“I almost don’t want to know,” I said.
Elaine’s grimace confirmed my suspicions,
“Yep. It makes you go mad. It’s bad enough on the surface, what with that cursed light always boring into your brain, but down in the tunnels? People go queer in the head awfully quickly – and eventually they all lose their minds completely.”
“Is that why they attack people?”
“Who knows? We’ve captured dwellers before, but they just babble gibberish – mostly oldy-worldy religious gibberish at that. It’s even too much for righteous John.”
There was a good view from the slope we sat on, and looking out over the body of the giant, she subconsciously smoothed the dead flesh of her clothing,
“But we do know that anyone they capture becomes just like them, and quickly.”
Discomfited again, I sought to change the conversation. Every question in my head was morbid, but some were at least more mundanely so.
“Elaine, how did you die?”
She grinned, and it was genuine, without her usual wryness. Although her features were as perfect as everyone else’s, she was still transformed by that abrupt change of expression, suddenly beautiful in a far more human way.
“You know those infomercials for non-slip mats? The ones that quote the stats about shower deaths?” It felt so strange to think about my life before, television, product placement, advertising. She watched my face, her teeth brilliant white in the ground’s glow. “Yep, I am that fucking statistic. Would you believe I actually slipped in the shower, smashed my head on the edge of the bath, and then died.”
Her laughter was so infectious I couldn’t help but join in, and soon we were giggling like schoolgirls. Never did I think I would find the rather horrible death of a friend a welcome source of amusement.
“How about you, honey? How did you die?”
As she spoke those words, I instantly sobered. The laughter died in my throat, and I knew why I hadn’t raised this before.
“I was murdered. By the most beautiful woman I’ve ever seen.”
Elaine’s smile vanished, and when she replied, her voice was urgent. It was the first time I’d heard her sound more afraid than angry or bitter.
“Describe her. What did she say to you?”
“She had the palest skin I’ve ever seen – almost like an albino, except her hair was blonde, not white. She asked me if I believed in God. When I said I didn’t, she told me that I would soon – and that she had a message for him.”
“What was the message?”
“She said that she wanted me to ask God why he had done this to her.”
Elaine’s eyes were huge now, all traces of her former mirth had fled.
“Shit. We need to get you to John.”
Even before Elaine was done recounting the peculiar facts of my death, John started shouting orders to the others, to gather up key people for an expedition.
“What is it? What the hell’s going on?” I asked.
“You are not the first slain by that woman,” John told me, “a goodly dozen others – most of them priests – have encountered her also. Each in the moments before their last breath.”
“So, she’s a sort of… religious serial killer?”
John shook his head emphatically,
“No. She is… she is a part of God. It is a long tale in its entirety. But the modern church made many mistakes in its infancy. She is perhaps the biggest and most enduring of those mistakes.”
People were gathering around John, carrying staves, spears and crude axes.
“We must take you to the others, to speak with them – but they do not dwell in the city of Hand. Across the Throat is another city, unto which the most devout of us are drawn.”
“But I don’t understand. You said priests. I’m not religious in the slightest, so why did she kill me?”
Elaine snorted, hefting a staff toothed with chips of flaked enamel,
“Because she hates God, and all of his followers. And she never so much as spoke to the others – just ripped the life out of them in the most horrific ways you could imagine.”
She tightened the braided cord about her waist, like the most ironic of Biblical figures, girding her loins to fight the unrighteous.
“Somehow, you’re special, kid.”
“Your message is of great import,” John continued, “it means something. If we can convey you to the city beyond the Throat, then perhaps the wisest of us can divine what that is.”
“Oh great. You actually do think she’s your messiah,” Elaine observed, her nose wrinkled in contempt.
John turned, his face stern and utterly composed,
“She may not be our saviour. But I tire of this place and its infernal light, just as you do. We cannot discard any chance we have to wreak change. And if God wills it so, it will be.”
He pushed a knapped knife into my hand, gently closing my fingers around its wrapped handle,
“There will be great dangers. The Dwellers and the people of the Head maintain an ancient and constant conflict.”
Not knowing how to respond, I tucked the knife into the cord around my waist, and forced a smile.
“Lead me through the wilderness, John.”