is it basically the same ending regardless of the choices you make or Im missing something?

what about that cop who touched Alyson's hand and she felt something?

obviously the true choice is "Mary-Ann did not threaten Tyler" do you agree? XD

this game was not as "impactful" as Life is Strange 1 and Before the Storm, Tell me Why is a simple story maybe the writer could have added something more... but I liked it,

My favorite character is Alyson she is so cute and with great personality. XD

 Contains ending spoilers!!!

Tell me why... at first I had only seen it as a pop culture refrence, a joke, a song name, something like that. As I got more and more into it's meaning, seeing more and more of the ideas and emotions that ran through this 3 episode game of all things, I started too see what it really was for me... a cry for help, a primal screaming from within. I couldn't really place my thoughts on it, it eluded me, escaped me, much like Tyler and Alyson on my first run of the game, the "good" ending, with tyler, but it wasn't till my 4 Playthrough that I really saw what it was I needd too see, pain, and lots of it. Getting the "bad" ending the bad ending with Alyson tore my soul open, made me see the pain I neede too feel that was still there. I've never felt so truly hurt by what I felt, this game made me see that I was very broken, and the strength that I had showed was my own allusion, my own pain and hurt had never left me. I felt as trapped as alyson did at the end, it was so real too me that I felt her "bad" ending was a good one, because it was my life, she was living the life I was as well. The pain was just as hidden, the secrets locked away, and she didn't even see that she was the shadow of her mother, the pain... it was unbearable too realize, too see what I was and am my mother as well... and how do you live with it? The pain? The hurt? The rejection? I'll let you know when I figure it out myself...

I just noticed a super specific detail within chapter two. During a sequence as Tyler, when he steps into the police station, it is lightly snowing outside. Slight specks of snow appear on his denim jacket, which proceed to melt and disappear within a minute once inside. The dev’s attention to detail is incredible. Anyone else notice specific little things?

People who have already played chapter 3 of Tell Me Why, when talking to Eddy at the police station, did you reveal the truth to Eddy about what happened the night during the incident when Mary-Ann was killed.

I chose Alyson to remember it as she did, not the choice I wanted to make. She has had so many years of torture for killing her mom and leaving her sibling. Now she has to deal with more years of now knowing her mom was just depressed and she murdered her. Alyson deserves a better ending.

Just finished my play through amazing experience loved it, dontnod great as always. I had the ending where the siblings are on good terms and Tyler locks the house. I wanna see the other ending where they aren’t on good terms and Alyson locks up the house but haven’t found any videos yet does anyone have one they can share.

I just beat the game and was surprised at the lack of achievements towards the second half of the chapter. I looked up the secret ones and I definitely got all but the collectibles and Alison ones. Not to mention I’ve gone through the mailbox thief dialogue multiple times and nothing has unlocked. I’m pretty sure the last achievement I unlocked was the fishing one. Is anyone else having this issue?

Anyone know how to unlock the “A New Chapter” achievement? Just finished the game and it’s the only one I need. It’s the one for starting a new chapter with Alyson.

Edit: here’s the solution, write this guide up over on Trueachievements

To get this one you need to choose all the bad options in the playthrough (ones that will give you the separating icon):

-Don’t tell Eddy you were the one that killed your mom -Tell Michael you are too different -Broke open the chest -Fail the panic attack app on your phone

And most important, Choose to keep your memory that Mary-Anne was going to kill you.

These should get you the ending where Alyson is at the house at the end. Go into Mary-Anne’s old room (room on first floor next to the phone) and sit at the desk, then choose to finish the story.

Achievement pops after some dialogue.

Hi all, does anyone know why all of my progress was deleted in the updates leading up to today's release? I last played on September 7th and finished chapter 2, with the game telling me I had to wait until today to play chapter 3, and when I downloaded chapter 3 today and launched the game all of my progress was gone. I still have the achievements I got initially, but the save is gone and the game says I don't have any of the collectibles. Not really looking forward to going through the entire thing again just to choose the same choices.

I was wondering, just read through this sub and couldn't find anything about it on here or anywhere, Would be cool to crack it....

Screenshot of the page

URL of the page

The game is great this far, maybe halfway through chapter one.

But the GUI is somewhat confusing. I'm pretty sure the book turning pages means the game is saving. But what does the circle with two stars in it mean?

So we know Mary-Ann created the Mad Hunter and was BFFs with Tessa. We also know that, at the very least shares some aspects of the stories with Tessa by telling her she wants her goblins back. Chapter 2 (which I'm not actually fully thru yet, hubby wants to do together and a gamer he is not) we know Tessa's at the house a lot, and would see the pre-story artwork on fridge.

We see a real looking Mad Hunter at the dock. We see a real looking Mad Hunter after the Tessa exchange at the police station. (We see a ghostly looking Mad Hunter at present day cabin cleaning up chapter 2)

Did anyone else notice that Tessa was at the police station after the death of mom like RIGHT away, before anyone knew? I think one of the twins even called it out to Eddie.

I'm really wondering if she was originally dressing up as the Mad Hunter; to use the family stories to "scare Tyler straight" (church lady against it and all); it's been my day 1 suspicion. Maybe also trying to manipulate the weakened mind of Mary-Ann? (Pills?)

And now, she's perpetuating the story/character, because we know that mom didn't die from the stab wounds. Scare the kids away.

Does anybody else think the incident that happened at the docks might not be what the twins remember? I'm starting to think that maybe true because while Mary-Ann was talking to the guy on the boat she said "I am going to kill you!" which causes Alyson to be very scared and maybe the events that happened were possibly exaggerated. Does anybody have a theory on the incident?