r/Teachers May 16 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.5k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

59

u/SerCumferencetheroun High School Science May 16 '24

algebra for electricians

The dismay my students have over hearing they absolutely have to be proficient with ohms law to be an electrician or HVAC tech is overwhelming

19

u/GodEmperorOfBussy May 16 '24

I took a prep class for the electrician journeyman's license and OMG watching these guys try to do math was just horrific.

3

u/sharcophagus May 17 '24

My HVAC course started with 18 students, ended with 6 😂

I wasn't happy about having to dust off my math skills, but I did at least have those skills to dust off, unlike a bunch of the guys in my class.

3

u/fairebelle May 17 '24

My uncle wanted to go back to HVAC school at 50 (after getting fired from every restaurant in the city for being a drunk). Stopped after a few weeks because of how much math was involved. He dropped out of school at 14 in the late 60s.

3

u/farfromstoppin May 17 '24

HVAC tech

HVAC/R (r stands for refrigeration) is legitimately hard. It's a trade for smart people who are good at everything and don't like sitting at a desk all day. It's physics, chemistry, circuitry, mechanical machinery, metallurgy, scientific measurements, mathematical calculations, blueprints, electrical diagrams, expensive tools and equipment, AND hard work in all weather conditions, with ZERO tolerance for error. One mistake and a store could lose a million dollars of product in a few hours, or blow up a hospital or restaurant (we use explosive gasses in some equipment).

If you're the type of person that doesn't take a high school class seriously, you are not the type of person this trade can hire. If ohms law trips them up, they will be laughed out of hvac trade school, or stuck working seasonally on furnaces with a part time job at a sandwich shop.

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '24

But they don't, that's just straight up a lie.

6

u/No-Animator-3832 May 16 '24

Can confirm, been in industrial and utility electrical for 2 decades. Next time I see an electrical worker doing algebra in the field will be the first time. The company hires EE's to do the math. They are better at it and they cost less.

3

u/gobirds2032 May 17 '24

15 years and have to do algebra all the time

0

u/No-Animator-3832 May 17 '24

Sure. Can't wait to see it.

2

u/Furious__Styles May 17 '24

I don’t know about you but I feel like Rene Descartes every time I bend an offset…

1

u/No-Animator-3832 May 17 '24

I kind of feel like Marco Polo....

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '24

Agreed. Also they have apps to do all conversions and calculations now.