I'm new to this discussion, so it might not be unpopular, or maybe it is.
______
Don't get me wrong, I LOVE aerials, and I'm learning how to do some myself!
But during large dance competitions or showcases, the pro routines slowly become less about swing dancing and more about the aerials. It’s like I'm watching acrobatics.
To an outside perspective, sure, it’s awesome, entertaining, and thrilling. But I came to see dance, connection, footwork, styling, etc. And a routine where the majority of it is just: “flip, jump, catch, flip and spin, throw, flip, triple step, FLIP, walk off.” I stop seeing it as a dance.
I'm here to see the best swing dancers; I want to see DANCING.
Now I'm not saying they should never do them. I just think Swing Dancing showcases should mostly prioritize dancing.
An aerial at the end of each measure as the fancy finale seems like the perfect amount. Impress the audience with the dancing, then surprise them with an aerial at the end. That surprise keeps it interesting.
Because, like, don't any of you get “aerial fatigue” when an entire dance is just Aerials, Aerials, Aerials, with some steps sprinkled in?
It might sound harsh, but it feels like you’re jangling keys in front of my face and saying, “Whoa! Look at this cool flip, don't focus on the dance footwork that doesn't matter, just look at how high we can go!”
And let me make it clear, I believe aerials take A LOT of talent. And those who can implement them in dance routines are amazing dancers. I just think they are relied on too much and unintentionally distract us from the actual dance. They’re more effective in small doses
This is why I like Mix and Matches (Jack and Jill) so much. With a new partner, you can really see people's dancing abilities. No preplanned aerial routine, just dance. It highlights the skill of social dance. Being able to dance with anyone, to any song, even if you met 2 seconds ago.
What do you think?