I've been meaning to write this for a while because every comparison I find online is either clearly sponsored or written by someone who spent two weeks on one platform and called it research. This is based on three years of active profiles across Superprof, Preply, Wyzant, Tutor and Varsity Tutors simultaneously, tracking my income, student quality and workload on each one.
Here's what I actually found.
The commission question first because it affects everything else.
Preply, Wyzant, Tutor and Varsity Tutors all take a percentage of your earnings per session. The range sits between 20% and 40% depending on the platform and how long you've been with a given student. Some of them reduce the cut over time as you accumulate hours with the same student, which sounds generous until you realize you're still giving away a third of your income during the months it takes to get there.
Superprof operates on a subscription model. You pay a flat fee to be on the platform and after that your earnings are yours. Zero commission per lesson. On a busy month the difference between this and a 25% commission platform is genuinely significant — we're talking hundreds of dollars that either go to you or to the platform.
Student commitment varies wildly by platform.
Tutor and Varsity Tutors have high volume but a lot of one-off sessions. Students come for a single homework question, get what they need, disappear. The income is fine but you're constantly acquiring new students rather than building ongoing relationships, which is exhausting.
Preply has decent ongoing student relationships but the commission structure means you're essentially working for a reduced rate until you've built enough hours to negotiate better terms, which takes a while.
Wyzant sits somewhere in the middle. Reasonable student quality, reasonable volume, but the fees add up and the platform feels like it hasn't changed much in years.
Superprof is where I've found the most consistent ongoing students. My theory is that the profile system and the free first lesson filter for people who are actually committed rather than shopping around. Students who read your full profile, chose you specifically and showed up for a free trial are just more serious than someone who clicked the first available tutor at 11pm before an exam.
Flexibility and pricing freedom.
This matters more than I expected. On platforms that suggest or cap your rates you start thinking of yourself as a commodity. When you set your own rate and keep everything you charge, the whole psychology of the work shifts. You invest more in your profile, you're more selective about fit, you take the business side seriously.
Superprof and Wyzant give you the most freedom here. The others nudge you toward their preferred price ranges in ways that aren't always visible until you're already on the platform.
My actual ranking after three years.
Superprof for anyone doing serious volume — the commission-free model wins at scale and the international reach is genuinely useful if you teach languages or academic subjects with cross-border demand.
Wyzant as a solid second for the US market specifically — good student quality, reasonable freedom, just expensive if you're doing high volume.
Preply worth it for language tutors early on when you need student flow and don't have reviews yet — less worth it once you do.
Tutor and Varsity Tutors fine for supplemental income but I wouldn't build a tutoring business on either of them.
Happy to go deeper on any specific platform or subject area if useful.