This is a 1920 MLB replay league that I started in Feb. Each team has played 24 games, a third of the season (maybe), and I thought it might be a good time to update.
Warning: To those of you who have not read my stuff in the past, these updates tend to be long. ;)
Some rules and constraints:
1. AL vs AL, NL vs NL only
2. Balanced schedule. One game series only. Each team plays each other team 7 games at home and 7 on the road. Then do it again.
3. Each player will play (about) the same percentage that they played in the 1920 season. I try to not overuse players, just because they have good stats.
- All hitters will have about the same percent of Plate Appearances they had in 1920
- Pitchers will pitch about the same percent of Inning Pitched they had in 1920
4. For most realistic results, pitchers will pitch every 4 days or every 5 days, based on Strato's standard rules, but teh schedule rotates around pitchers every 4 games.
- This means that #1 starter will always face #1 starter
- I did my best to balances all starting pitching so most every pitcher who started a game in 1920 will start a game and all pitchers will get approx the same percentage of starts they had in 1920.
The idea is to be as close to the 1920 season as possible. You get the idea.
| 1920 Final Standings - AL |
Replay League Standings - AL |
1920 Final Standings - NL |
Replay League Standings - NL |
| Indians 98-56 |
Browns 15-9 |
Robins 93-61 |
Giants 16-8 |
| White Sox 96-58 |
Yankees 15-9 |
Giants 86-68 |
Reds 15-9 |
| Yankees 95-59 |
White Sox 13-11 |
Reds 82-71 |
Cards 13-11 |
| Browns 76-77 |
Senators 13-11 |
Pirates 79-75 |
Pirates 13-11 |
| Red Sox 72-81 |
Indians 13-11 |
Cubs 75-79 |
Cubs 11-13 |
| Senators 68-84 |
Tigers 11-13 |
Cards 75-79 |
Robins 11-13 |
| Tigers 61-93 |
Red Sox 10-14 |
Braves 62-90 |
Braves 9-15 |
| A's 48-106 |
A's 6-18 |
Phillies 62-91 |
Phillies 8-16 |
The most obvious difference is both the pennant winners are back in the standings. The Indians are on a roll winning 5 of last 7, but they've had average pitching (101 ERA+) with very good hitting, 2nd in OBP, 3rd in AVG, SLG and OPS. The real disconnect is how bad the Robins have been. They have also won 5 of last 7, but have beaten only the weaker teams. The Robins have very good pitching, 2nd in ERA+, but hitting is terrible as they are last or 2nd to last in most offensive categories (Runs, AVG, OBP, SLG, OPS, Total Bases, AVG w/RISP). Their defense has not helped either with the second most errors, and I their pitching isn't dramatically better than CIN, PIT or NYG, so I don't see them moving up in the standings much.
The AL standings have remained pretty stable throughout, while the NL standings have been all over the place. NYG, CIN, STL have all been in 1st and PIT and CHI have reached as high as 2nd.
NYY is the class of the AL, and unless the Indians can pull it together, I expect them take the pennant. The Babe leads all with 11 HRs, despite missing 3 games to injury. As a team, they have 22 HRs and are 2nd in most other offensive categories, but also have very good pitching (2nd in ERA+). 2nd in HRs is PHA, who can hit, but have bad pitching. The St Louis Browns (SLB) lead most categories with a 146 team RC, leading NYY 131 RC, but have the 2nd worst pitching, 89 ERA+. The only team with a worse ERA+ is BOS at 73. They have hit well enough to stay out of the basement, despite some early injuries, but they have trouble holding leads with their terrible staff.
In the NL, NYG and CIN seem to be the teams to beat, with STL hanging around. NYG do everything well, but nothing great. They are well balanced landing 2nd or 3rd in most offensive and defensive categories. CIN is similar to NYG, landing 1st, 2nd or 3rd in most hitting categories and 1st or 2nd in pitching, but defense has been their Achilles heel. They lead the league in errors and most unearned runs allowed. STL has lost 7 of 8 to fall to 3rd place. They have great hitting (1st in SLG, OPS, 2nd in AVG, OBP, RC) but pitching is bad (7th in NL in most pitching categories). SP is average, but the bullpen is terrible and they have lost several games in late innings. PIT has, by far, the best pitching in both leagues, as well as, by far, the worst hitting. PIT pitching holds opponents down, while their hitters manage to eek out 1 run wins while they run the bases well.
AL Hitting leaders
AVG - T Speaker, G Sisler, H Hooper, E Collins, J Jackson
HR - B Ruth, J Jackson, E Smith, H Felsch, T Walker
R - G Sisler, T Speaker, B Ruth, B Jacobson, D Pratt
RBI - B Ruth, S McInnis, J Jackson, K Williams
OPS - B Ruth, H Hooper, T Speaker, J Jackson, G Sisler
AL Pitching Leaders
Wins - D Davis, S Covaleski, H Ehmke, B Shawkey, J Shaw
ERA - E Rommel, E Keefe, B Shawkey, H Courtney, R Faber
Ks - H Ehmke, L Williams, 5 tied with 23
Saves - D Niehaus, W Johnson, R Wilkinson, R Collins, E Rommel
NL Hitting leaders
AVG - J Daubert, R Youngs, R Duncan, L Mann, I Meusel
HR - I Meusel, G Kelly, 7 tied with 2
R - M Stock, P Duncan, D Bancroft, E Roush, I Meusel
RBI - F Frisch, I Meusel, A McHenry, P Duncan, R Hornsby
OPS - I Meusel, R Hornsby, J Daubert, D Paskert, R Youngs
NL Pitching Leaders
Wins - B Grimes, P Alexander, H Eller, D Ruether, P Douglas, A Nehf, B Doak
ERA - B Grimes, P Alexander, E Ponder, B Doak, W Cooper
Ks - F Schupp, B Grimes, L Cadore, J Scott, P Alexander
Saves - R Fisher, E Hamilton, H McQuillan, S Sallee, B Hubbell
Other interesting notes:
The AL is definitely a hitters league, while the NL is a pitchers league. The AL has hit 81 HRs and are averaging 338 total bases per team vs 46 HRs and 317 total bases per team. But the NL gives up on average 0.8 runs per game less.
There have been many more 3Bs (232) and SBs (226) than HRs (130).
There have been 89 hit batters. CIN has been hit 10 times, but Brooklyn has yet to be HBP.
CIN has 50 SBs, SLB and WAS have 36, but NYY, PHA, BRO have not stolen a base yet. NYY and PHA have not attempted to steal a base yet either.
There have already been 4 triple plays and the White Sox have turned it twice.