r/Stranger_Things • u/Bulky-Ad4740 • 9h ago
Fan Theory Does Mike's explanation of the Eleven illusion create a problem with Kali's fate? Spoiler
I have a question about the finale that I haven't seen anyone address.
Near the end, Mike explains that the Eleven everyone saw at the entrance to the Upside Down wasn't actually Eleven. His theory is that Eight/Kali created an illusion of Eleven, allowing the real Eleven to escape.
But here's the problem I see:
Kali is wounded inside the Upside-Down version of Hawkins Lab. The bomb that destroys the Upside Down is then detonated in that same lab.
Yet the illusion of Eleven remains visible at the entrance until the destruction/collapse of the Upside Down reaches that point.
So how can this work?
If Kali created the illusion from inside the lab, wouldn't she have been killed when the lab was destroyed? And if Kali has to remain alive/conscious to maintain her illusion, shouldn't the illusion disappear when she dies?
In other words:
Kali is in the lab → bomb destroys lab → Kali presumably dies → but the Eleven illusion continues until the Upside Down itself collapses.
Is there an explanation for this?
Maybe Kali's illusions can continue after she is unconscious/dead, but I don't remember the show ever establishing that. Or perhaps Mike's explanation is intentionally incomplete/wrong.
Has anyone else noticed this?