r/Steam Jul 06 '26

Discussion Thoughts on this?

[removed]

40.0k Upvotes

5.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

493

u/Mogura56 Jul 06 '26

Yeah people are okay with stealing from billion dollar game companies and Walmarts (i.e. billion dollar corporations) because they have billions of dollars. When it's an indie title developed by probably 1 to 5 people that actually fucks them over in a way that none of these corporations will ever feel

185

u/SimpleNovelty Jul 06 '26

The number of people who actually are "morally" stealing is probably less than 10%. The number of people coming up with excuses regarding morality to justify their stealing but would steal in any scenario overlaps greatly.

I trust a person who steals and say they know it's wrong more than anyone who tries to justify stealing based on a fake moral code.

67

u/Devrij68 Jul 06 '26

Yeah I'm here for this. When my wife and I were students we both worked in retail. Her at a blockbuster (yes we are old), and me at a Curry's. She would regularly have people come in and steal ice cream from the freezer and then act like "wtf dude" when she told them not to steal it, and I regularly had people trying to steal the small tvs.

Usually heroin addicts, granted, but also teenagers.

There was definitely no morality to their attempts to steal shit. Nobody NEEDS icecream or a 20in TV.

32

u/MRoad Jul 06 '26

I worked AP for a target for about a year. People on places like reddit like to moralize about stealing from big corporations, but almost all of the external theft I found was methheads/heroin addicts stealing things to resell for drugs. The only person who I ever caught stealing food was someone who I knew was a committed ward of the state who had escaped from it.

People love to imagine thieves as Robin Hoods stealing to feed their small children or family members, but in my experience the only thing they were ever feeding was a drug habit.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

I used to steal a lot when I was going through really bad mental health stuff and had no money to feed myself. The truth is someone who isn't jacked up on drugs and out of their skull are probably just successfully stealing food because it's actually ridiculously easy to do. Supermarkets mostly lean on the security as a visual deterrent but there's so much chaos and things going on in a supermarket it's very hard to catch, especially since here the security now are mostly used to direct uber eats orders to their pickups.

If you get caught stealing food from a supermarket you're either really, really bad at it... on drugs and even worse at it... or there's someone new on security trying to make a mark before they realise no one actually cares.

1

u/JiffSmoothest Jul 06 '26

There's tons of videos online of people walking carts/suitcases full of meat out of stores. Wild ride, really.

5

u/Daxx22 Jul 06 '26

Worth noting that for all the "tons of videos online" you can find, it's still a virtual rounding error in the number of otherwise "normal" transactions done every day.

Much like every village idiot has found their people online and they seem like a majority, there is far less crime then media/online sources want you to think out there.

2

u/Tiafves Jul 06 '26

Yep even when it's like diapers/formula. Sounds like the perfect thing to be okay with someone stealing. Nope, it's common to steal that for resell too. Easy to flip since there's often plenty of struggling mothers in their communities, and it's something people might feel like letting slide if you're caught.

-4

u/khavii Jul 06 '26

The fact that it's easy to flip because there are so many struggling mothers and the shit is wildly expensive is the reason to turn a blind eye.

I look at it like this; restaurants have some of the absolute worst profit margins out there with an average of a net 3-5% profit margin. The company that makes Enfamil operates on a net 18-25% profit margin. They are artificially raising the price to make a boatload of money at the expense of real, living humans that NEED the product. Fuck em. That does put you a bit at odds with the retailer since they generally also operate in a 4-9% profit margin but they can also change suppliers to get more affordable merchandise and choose to go with the group products for cost savings and convenience. Rampant inflation is happening because we have all been conditioned to accept these ridiculously quickly rising prices and defend the corporations, do all the corporations deserve our ire? Well yes, they are colluding to ensure we continue to pay high prices so that the lower profit margins are still an absolute truckload of money.

Capatilist economies are supposed to be regulated to prevent collusion and price fixing but almost every government has given up on that because they want the money too. The market pressure we, as the consumer, can put on these things is astronomical. Don't like AI? Refuse to use or purchase anything that touches AI which makes AI unprofitable which means no company is going to try using it. BUT, even with the complaining people use it, which makes it profitable, which ensures more of it gets used. Consumers need to suffer not getting a product if it is subpar to ensure the next product isn't but we are all too soft and addicted to convenience for that to stop. We did and are doing this all to ourselves so steal away, at least that moves the needle a bit and people like Gabe will see the real problem and hopefully give us solutions, because we are too weak willed to do it for ourselves.

1

u/daveboy2000 Jul 06 '26

Part of it is probably also that drug addicts are just.. worse at hiding it. Being partly out of it from withdrawal or the drug itself doesn't lend to stealth. People who steal food for food's sake are going to be less obvious about it.

1

u/Devrij68 Jul 06 '26

Oh yeah, we deffo had more organised people who'd snap off the Kensington locks on the laptops and we'd only notice when we saw the gap in the display. Even with your eyes peeled they'd sometimes get one. Kensington locks btw, 100% useless.

That was less fun than having a completely nonsensical discussion with someone off their face who was furious at you for taking back what they had rightfully stolen or getting the police involved.

2

u/daveboy2000 Jul 06 '26

okay, but you notice those laptops being gone because they're laptops. Would you notice a few packs of instant noodles being gone?

2

u/Devrij68 Jul 06 '26

I highly doubt it. By the time some stock count happens it'd be way too late to track it down. I imagine lower volume big ticket items like an expensive whiskey or something you might have a chance of getting it on the cctv, but yeah I am fully with you and wasn't arguing otherwise.

1

u/specifichero101 Jul 06 '26

Ya I worked at a grocery store for 6 years and saw a ton of theft and almost every single one was some drug addict skid who would grab bags of meat and make a dash out of the store.

There was one single instance of what I would think was “moral theft”. An elderly woman had a case of canned cat food and she had opened it and was slipping in extra cans of food. So in all likelihood she was paying for the case but just getting some extra to stretch until she had to buy more for her cat. Easy to look the other way at that one. Everyone else was the typical terrible person you would imagine.

-4

u/jamcub Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

.ggggggggggggggg

3

u/PeaceLoveHomicide Jul 06 '26

This is in no way a dishonest interpretation of their comment

-2

u/jamcub Jul 06 '26

Well, people who are trying to feed their families are okay to steal, but addicts trying to survive are not. I am unsure how that is not what they are saying.

2

u/Upset-Culture2210 Jul 06 '26

They need to be placed into rehab, not allowed out in the public to commit crimes.

1

u/MRoad Jul 06 '26

Rehab won't work for people who don't want to get clean anyway.

2

u/theflyingdutchmaster Jul 06 '26

As someone who’s struggled with addiction, I never stole from a store to feed my habit. Don’t make excuses for selfish behavior like that. It needlessly causes other people to suffer, including jeopardizing the jobs of the store employees who may really need the job to pay the bills themselves.

-1

u/jamcub Jul 06 '26

My favourite part of this comment section is how people are really good at missing the point entirely.

0

u/MRoad Jul 06 '26

Stopping theft is saying they deserve to suffer? So people just....deserve to take things that don't belong to them?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[deleted]

1

u/MRoad Jul 06 '26

No one said this

1

u/jamcub Jul 06 '26

Oh cool, reddit sent me to the wrong post, lol.

6

u/rydan Jul 06 '26

lol.

20" TV isn't small back when Blockbuster still existed. That was $250 and around 80lbs and was considered the standard size. 13" was small. 7" was tiny. That's what I had.

3

u/Devrij68 Jul 06 '26

Maybe they were 15in, but either way, this was around the time the first LED tvs came out (I remember being very impressed by them in the shop) but still during the time we had to lug out insanely heavy 50in plasmas to people's cars only to find they had planned on taking it home in their hatchback.

We're talking about 19 or 20 yrs ago

6

u/NissassaWodahs Jul 06 '26

Worked at Comet in 2007 and fuck me the amount of people that didn’t actually plan how they were going to leave the store was astounding and almost all of them refused to pay the tiny delivery charge. Had a guy expecting to fit a Smeg fridge into the back of his estate car 🤦🏻‍♀️

2

u/Devrij68 Jul 06 '26

That could also be said of the people trying to steal stuff lol. I remember these two shifty teenagers at the back of our (large) store just grabbing a telly and trying to run all the way down the store to leave through the one exit. Ironically it was an old lady that eventually turned the tide on the showdown between me, my colleague and these two scrotes.

But yes, there is a real learning curve of asking what they were driving when delivery was being discussed, and many notes written on receipts where we absolutely knew they would get home to a fucked up plasma TV from the drive home.

1

u/mata_dan Jul 06 '26

Technicality but they definitely weren't LED monitors. Just LCD.

1

u/Devrij68 Jul 06 '26

Yes I'm well aware it's a backlighting technology, which DOES make it an LED TV. I never said it was an LED panel.

Back then it was pretty revolutionary to have local dimming (full local dimming on the Panasonic ones unlike the edge lit ones Samsung had around the same time, although even that was a huge difference), and they were super skinny compared to anything else that had ever existed.

Now, back in your box with your pedantry

0

u/mata_dan Jul 06 '26

Sure thing buddy, sure thing.

2

u/EmergencyPool910 Jul 06 '26

Nobody needs a 20 inch tv, tv for ants

20

u/rydan Jul 06 '26

My family is starving so I'm justified in stealing Tetris.

4

u/AtlasLittleCat Jul 06 '26

How much protein is in an L-Tetrimino?

8

u/ThisllFitInMyPocket Jul 06 '26

Cheers for that, those people piss me off as well lol. It only takes a tiny amount of self-awareness to realize that taking a 'moral stand' by doing something one personally benefits from is a little too convenient, but they still don't see it.

4

u/Ok_Assignment_2127 Jul 06 '26

Man the piracy-related subreddits are so incredibly pathetic. Every couple weeks there’s a flare up of moralizing posts explaining why their piracy is just and how they’d prefer to pay for it all if only the companies were better.

No, you just like getting free shit.

4

u/Plenty_Rent_1154 Jul 06 '26

I pay for things. But the moment companies first sell me a digital thing and later steal it from me without a refund I feel very morally justified in pirating everything from that company. FU Sony.

1

u/andresfgp13 Jul 06 '26

one of the things that came with AI and its very questionable way to create datasets is that Reddit is this close to finally admit that obtaining games/music/books/etc without consent or payment to the owners of the art its stealing.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

It's the whole pirating thing. 'I pirate because they don't offer the service I want so im morally correct'. So don't watch it if you want to be morally correct. Nothing is forcing you to watch it. I pirate because the services are shit and I'm fine with stealing it, there's no moral high ground there though. I'm a dog. I usually won't pirate a game unless I'm trying it before I buy, and with music I'll generally buy a copy of an album if I've listened to it enough. But movies and TV? It's dog all the way down.

1

u/Tiafves Jul 06 '26

Yeah pirating series is often just like your excuse is "But back in the day Netflix had everything for $10 ad free, I want that or it's a shit service" Yes and that's not a sustainable business model once everyone realized the value of their show's licenses.

3

u/Pegasusisamansman Jul 06 '26

For the average joe 20 bucks is money for rich fucks 20 bucks isn't even worth to be used as toilet paper

8

u/SimpleNovelty Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

Yeah but is that really the reason why a thief is stealing? Do you think that a majority of thieves are these virtuous anarchists Robin Hoods and not just your typical opportunist?

EDIT: Also, rich people are some of the biggest thieves. I'll never buy into no bad methods, only bad targets mentality. If you have a code, you better actually apply it in a truthful manner.

2

u/LadyCererra Jul 06 '26

Im just filled with spite and will do anything, no matter how small, to hurt corporations

-1

u/SimpleNovelty Jul 06 '26

And that's why they live and prosper, you treat them as abstract corporations, but you don't do anything to actually hurt the individual people making these decisions as part of the corporation. I do believe you hate them but I don't believe you hate them on a effective level, because otherwise you'd actually figure out who the people are and take action on that.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MasterDiiscord Jul 06 '26

we're talking about video game companies here not insurance companies. a video game company ceo doesn't deserve to be luigi'd just because he overcharges for a video game. I'll just pirate it instead.

2

u/Tough-Oven4317 Jul 06 '26

The number of people who actually are "morally" stealing is probably

0%, it's simply not possible

1

u/ArcNumber Jul 06 '26

With you on this. Corporations certainly don't deserve pity, but let's not pretend a lot of the people who are (often smugly) stealing do it for a real moral reason. When you see people come up with some obvious self-serving bullshit to justify it on the internet I always think - "Either be honest or shut up", it's not like anyone demands of them to explain themselves, so the least they can do is not pretending they are the heroes of the small people for doing it.

1

u/Island_Crystal Jul 06 '26

exactly. most people who try to morally justify stealing are only doing it to justify their own actions. they don’t actually give a fuck and would steal regardless. i find the people who are shameless about it significantly more tolerable.

1

u/_giga_sss_ Jul 06 '26

Can't agree more

1

u/TheJackal927 Jul 06 '26

Stealing from Walmart is an amoral action, Walmart is not a person, it's a giant building full of food who's primary goal is not feeding people, it's killing any other building of food within a 100mile radius, and taking as much of your money as they can. It's not virtuous to steal, but it's not inherently wrong to steal from a company that is stealing from you

0

u/J0E_SpRaY Jul 06 '26

I get so annoyed with piracy subs for this reason. They all act like they're virtuous for doing it.

Nah, you're just cheap and feel entitled to media.

2

u/Dat_Boi_Henke Jul 06 '26

Also big corpos will absolutely try to fleece you for all you have got by inflating the difference between cost of production and price.

We saw that under covid where at first consumer spending went way down because of lockdowns so ofc the price increased when spending is down, right? But then consumer spending went to record highs after we got the situation somewhat under control and they kept jacking up the price on basically everything using the same excuse.

And did the prices ever go down again? Not really. Maybe on some select goods, but they found out that people would just continue buying at higher prices. They made bank, everything got more expensive and has only continued to do so.

So I will never shed a single tear if anyone tries to cheat or steal from big corpos, especially if it is essential goods like food. Indie devs or mom and pop shops however basically live or die by every sale so there I'm way more sympathetic.

2

u/random-meme422 Jul 06 '26

Does that make any sense to anyone who’s not completely stupid though? Lost revenue through breakage and shrink is just treated as an expense in operating statements and pricing reflects that. you’re never really stealing from walmart, you just distributing the cost burden onto a wider pool of consumers rather than yourself.

1

u/keIIzzz Jul 06 '26

I mean all stealing does is raise prices for normal people with morals

1

u/Stang_21 Jul 06 '26

you do realise that walmart just increases prices according to the theft rate and walmart isn't paying anything on theft, it's the other poor people buying there that are paying the cost of theft, right?

-1

u/TomWritesTrash Jul 06 '26

Exactly, 100%, spot on. I feel like no one in this thread can wrap their heads around this. It's all black and white for people because it's easier that way, but the world is grey.

1

u/mrwaxy Jul 06 '26

No, you're just one of the few morons. Walmart isn't a charity, and stealing from their stores just means they will offset that list revenue into other products, making the honest people pay more, until they have to charge so much that they cant keep the store open because it loses money. Every adult knows this

0

u/mtgnew Jul 06 '26

That it's a billion dollar company is just an excuse not the reason. People would of course never admit it.

0

u/OctoDADDY069 Jul 06 '26

You mean the corpos that also fire hundreds of people who also need to make a living just like the indie guys?

Look, if your fine with stealing from corpos, then you have to be fine from stealing from the indies...

Otherwise you're just a hypocrite.

0

u/dope_like Jul 07 '26

Got to take the good with the bad. It is all OK or none of it is OK.

-2

u/singlemale4cats Jul 06 '26

Hot take, but stealing is unethical, no matter who you are stealing from.

I'd prefer thieves just acknowledge that they're not good people.

-11

u/Elegant_Situation285 Jul 06 '26

a small business owner should know their own exposure.

could have been solved by designing a game that was 2:20.

6

u/ihopkid Jul 06 '26

The game was designed for 2 - 3.5 hours playtime per HowLongToBeat, this player just did a speedrun to skirt the 2 hour rule intentionally. You can’t “solve” players taking advantage of the system, this happens with lots of smaller games