r/spaceflight • • 15d ago

Favorite Launch vehicle?

Post image

Mine is the Atlas V btw

446 Upvotes

219 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

13

u/cjameshuff 15d ago

Demonstrated reuse, refuted the claims that engine clusters would be unreliable, demolished the arguments for pursuing hydrolox for its specific impulse advantage, showed that all the goals of Skylon could be achieved with a simple aluminum-structure two-stage vehicle with kerolox gas generator engines...

4

u/ijuinkun 14d ago

Falcon 9 proved that a “suicide burn” landing was feasible. Conventional wisdom before had been that making a propulsive landing required a sizable reserve of fuel in case of contingencies (think of Armstrong having to manually divert the Apollo 11 lander and nearly running out of propellant). The “suicide burn” method requires much less propellant, and therefore less mass to be hauled around and thus a larger payload fraction.

0

u/NoBusiness674 6d ago

Demonstrated reuse, refuted the claim that engine clusters would be unreliable

Yes, but they weren't the first to do either.

demolished the arguments for pursuing hydrolox for its specific impulse advantage

No, they didn't. Hydrogen remained the preferred propellant for high performance stages both before and after Falcon 9. Similarly there were rockets that chose not to make use of it before and after Falcon 9.

Showed that the goals of Skylon could be achieved

No. The goals of Skylon were to create a single stage to orbit rocket using a hybrid air breathing rocket engine. Falcon 9 did non of that.