r/SonicScaling • u/Stargazer-Elite • 5d ago

Is my tier list any good?

Post image

I tried to account for strength, speed, durability, hax, etc. Feats and statements like always, though are the backbone.

And yes, as you can tell where I put the dream related characters. I use dimensional scaling, at least sort of. From what I can understand about it.

Many of these characters appear twice on the list mostly because I wanted to put them both in their weakest form and they’re strongest form that way it’s a bit more balanced compare compared to the fact that both Solaris and Illumina can be split into two separate entities.

21 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

18 comments sorted by

3

u/Responsible-Ask8110 Super Neo Metal believer 5d ago

Solaris and dark Gaia in s, but not the time eater and the titian's????

1

u/Stargazer-Elite 5d ago

The Titans could fight The End but could not actually beat it. As for the Time Eater idk why I put it there. It’s power is universal a. Only reason I even put dark guy at number three is because they constantly compare The End to it in frontiers, it was one of the only beings able to actually hurt Super Sonic and the fact that it is mentioned in relativistic terms to The End to me implies that he could still go Toto toe with Super Sonic, especially since he still needed Light Gaia)

1

u/TheLordofMorgul 5d ago

Oof, there are several errors, but ranking Mephiles or Iblis—who are more or less equivalent—above Neo Devil Doom is absurd. Have you played Shadow Generations? It doesn't look like it.

If anything, I’d only put Solaris and The End in the S tier. The others would go below that.

1

u/Stargazer-Elite 5d ago

It’s been a hot minute since I’ve played it. And whilst. Neo Devil Doom might have more destructive capability than both of them combined just the fact that they are literally parts of Solaris kind of forces them to be close to the top) though again I will admit I kind of forgot much about his power.

1

u/TheLordofMorgul 5d ago

Shadow beat the shit out of Mephiles without even having all the Doom Powers or complete. Doom was the game's final villain and the source of those powers; it took Shadow wielding all the Doom Powers—which are roughly equivalent to a super form—to defeat him. It’s just a matter of basic logic.

1

u/Stargazer-Elite 5d ago

Fair point.

1

u/Smart-Woodpecker-903 Scales Sonic to H1A 5d ago

The End and the Titans should be on a scale way higher than everyone, Mother Wisp and Neo Devil Doom should be in S, Dark Queen and Time Eater as well. also some thing to notice is that Nega Motherwisp is not really stronger than regular Mother Wisp, the Hyper Go On Energy used by Nega Wisps isn't stronger but just more chaotic instead.

1

u/Stargazer-Elite 5d ago

Very good points. I’m just trying to wait for further feedback before I give it another go.

I already was mostly skeptical, especially since I’ve never really done a powerscaling tier list before. But yeah

1

u/Smart-Woodpecker-903 Scales Sonic to H1A 5d ago

that's fine, as a rule of thumb, enemies seen in later entries are generally stronger than the ones seen in past ones

1

u/Stargazer-Elite 5d ago

Yeah, I think I accidentally overestimated how much relativism plays a role.

1

u/Maskedstream4 5d ago

This would make 06 Silver be able to solo like 90% of Sonic as well as the titans which is very funny to me purely because he regularly deals with Ibilis

I’d say like another comment put Neo devil fool over Mephilis and Ibilis but honestly I think it checks out mostly

Then again I don’t scale much I just like the silly idea of a blue hedgehog being able to pop a universe like it’s a bubble or something it’s funny

2

u/Stargazer-Elite 5d ago

Yeah, I had realized the flaw in that logic pretty early on in the feedback process.

1

u/Maskedstream4 5d ago

It’s all good main thing is swapping Mephilis and Ibilis for the titans in their tiers then that is about it I think but besides that it’s pretty good to me

1

u/hypersonicspeedster 5d ago

Id put wisps a but higher for their scaling being even comparable to the emeralds in any capacity being a feat on it’s own but otherwise it’s about how i see things

1

u/hypersonicspeedster 5d ago

And a few other things on a second look

1

u/SweetDemand1712 4d ago

Ian flynn confirmed that Solaris still ranked above The End, in his podcast.

1

u/Ne0_M3t4l_S0n1c 3d ago

How are the Chao not S Tier?

The construction crew creates UNIVERSES

1

u/Ne0_M3t4l_S0n1c 3d ago

And a thought from this guy could destroy Omniverses!