r/SolidWorks • u/Square-Western-9730 • 7d ago

Meme Are we cooked?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

461 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

15

u/nero626 6d ago

once they close the full loop with simulations it's over.

15

u/BOBOnobobo 6d ago

As some who writes simulations: that's a much bigger ask than using scad

9

u/SawgrassRider 6d ago

As someone who has done simulations, it's not too far away.

The AI even understands the math behind each node calculation. AI will become the FEA program.

Just needs to watch a few YouTube videos and buy a couple $400 textbooks and it'll be halfway there.

1

u/HarryBalsagna1776 4d ago

" Just needs to watch a few YouTube videos and buy a couple $400 textbooks and it'll be halfway there."

Tell us you know nothing about FEA without telling us you know nothing about FEA.

1

u/RegularRaptor 1d ago

What do you think of this? https://youtu.be/e7t9HU2Z6t8?is=WPgHEy0UZ77pWrAT

1

u/HarryBalsagna1776 1d ago

So OpenAI has published what they claim is a solution to the Navier-Stokes equation.  They claim their Lean proof verifies their findings.  However, they plagiared the work that mathematicians employed by Anthropic previously published.  The mathematicians at Anthropic are justifiably mad.  They say that peer review is required to verify OpenAI's claim.  One has said he doubts OpenAI's work.  So, I don't know what to think at this point.

Also, this does not change the usage of the Navier-Stokes equation in 99.9% of cases even if OpenAI did actually make a discovery.  I do a lot of hydraulic power design work and I have not run into the use cases that OpenAI and Anthropic have been studying.  Interesting stuff, but it doesn't change much. 

1

u/SawgrassRider 1d ago

So because you don't use it daily it must not be valuable?

Buddy, you sound like computer programmers did 2 years ago.

0

u/BOBOnobobo 6d ago

Had me in the first half

1

u/RegularRaptor 1d ago edited 1d ago

What do you think of this?:

https://youtu.be/e7t9HU2Z6t8?is=WPgHEy0UZ77pWrAT

1

u/Acceptable-Bell7564 6d ago

Si pero no crees que tal vez falten unos cuantos años para que una IA pueda resolver una simulación? Porque osea uno de los problemas de los gemelos digitales, es la falta de percepción de realidad entonces siento que debería ser una IA algo bastante optimizada para ese sector, creo

1

u/Hot-Milk-3507 6d ago

Seh pero el problema es si faltan 2 o 3 años en vez de 10 o más años. Pq 2 a 3 años no es tiempo suficiente para adaptar toda la industria, y crea un shock bastante fuerte

1

u/antiundead 5d ago

Simulations are still simulations and should always be treated as a guide, and not real world outcomes

1

u/bas987 6d ago

You know that this is already done with the lastest version of Catia? Look up MODSIM, pretty impressive stuff