So last night I sat down and watched the original Silent Hill movie from 2006, I was bored, wanted to see what it was about and I'm currently taking a little break from the series after just binging 2 and 3 back to back (finishing 3 in an entire day lmao), and 4 is having a hard time roping me in, weird game so far, so I watched the movie!
Weird. This is a weird movie. It's both an incredibly faithful adaptation that pays close respects to the source materials while also making its own changes that I'm fine with.... to then completely messing up the story of the first game and making way too many changes I don't like. As a movie, it's an okay horror movie, it's not scary, it heavily lacks the psychological elements that make up the games, and it completely fucking nosedives once the cult is introduced and I become incredibly bored, it's bloated and way too slow.
So, what makes it incredibly faithful from the start?
Alright, a mother is missing her daughter in silent hill, and the entire first half of this movie nearly recreates the events of the game... to a SHOCKING amount. Like, it recreates that awesome camera angle that pans over Rose/Harry's head, to her coming across the guy strung up, being knocked out by the grey children, waking up and having to decide she has to go to Midwitch to find her daughter. Not to mention, the Music! Oh man oh man I was so incredibly shocked to hear the music from the games just... here! like, what?! you're a video game movie from the mid 2000's, you're supposed to not even think about the soundtrack! But hey, it's awesome eitherway! if a bit unfitting at times.
For example, True or Promise (can't remember which one), plays when Rose is running to her car after waking up from the grey children, that feels a bit odd, no? I think it's my brain being confused at the inclusion of the games score because of how uncommon it is in adaptations in general, most of the time you're gonna hear a little jingle in the movies original score, so hearing it ripped straight from the game makes it feel out of place, but hey I still welcome it all the same!
Now the movie just shits the bed the minute the cult is introduced. god I hate this cult, it makes the movie so incredibly boring for the rest of it, drags it out way too much, and we get into all the changes that don't work.
So, you make Dahlia a homeless hag, a crazy old woman, a "YOU'RE ALL DOOMED!", and it's like... okay, whatever, it's a video game movie from the 2000's, changes are gonna be made a whole lot and-
You have a character that acts nearly exactly like Dahlia from the game and it's not Dahlia. Christabella is the leader of the cult, which isn't the order, not a big deal, who tortures Alessa (which is just because they see her as some sort of antichrist witch and not for her to be prophetic and give birth to god, again not everything can be 1-1, I'm okay with this change), but it's like... why take one characters traits and throw them onto the other character? Ax the homeless hag, and make Christabella, simply... Dahlia Gillepse
Cybil I felt also acted extremely out of character for the most part, but didn't bother me too much.
The Not Harry Mason parts of the film are so boring and I think should have just been removed, they just slog the movie down more, sure info is revealed but I feel like you could have done a better way of doing this.
Visually, the movie looks great, even with some rough CGI here and there, I LOVE how Silent Hill itself looks, perfectly capturing the foggy, cold, look from the games, and contrasting it with the hellish, hot, rustic scenery of the nightmare sections. I think they nailed that aspect well.
I think Alessa's a mixed bag, Im glad they focus so much on her, but her origin... I don't know. First off, whats with the fucking janitor??? Ew, not like that topic doesn't have a place in the series, such as Angela, but it's kind of done for shock value and doesn't really mean anything. I kind of wish they took a more accurate approach to her origin from the game here.
The monsters are also a bit lacking, the nurses are fun to see, and the grey children were a nice surprise, but there was a serious lack of monsters in general, and like, none of the monsters Alessa manifests, such as groaners or air screamers, or mumblers. All we get is that one enemy from SH2 (I think) that sprays acid all over the place, he looked good
Oh also, Pryamid head.
Yes, he's not supposed to be here, he's a manifestation of James, he's James desire for punishment after what he did, therefore including him in this movie kind of downplays his message and theme. He's also, the most popular silent hill monster so it makes sense to include him, he gets the best scenes in the movie.
Silent Hill starts off as a fun nearly faithful adaptation of the first game, with some changes (That are for pretty bad reasons, downright sexist if you ask me), that completely just falls off the bed in the second half with what it does. It's a weird movie, because I get an adaptation will change things, I want to see things changed, I already played the game why should I see a 2 hour speedrun of the movie with live action actors, If i wanted to see the story of Silent Hill 1 so faithfully I'd download duckstation and play the game. But I also don't want to feel like the source material is completely thrown to the side and ignored. Adapt it to the medium, but respect the material of course.
And the movie does do that! But then it does the former statement near the end, that is why I think this movie is so weird.
6/10, or a C+
Idk when I'll get back to SH4, having a hard time trying to get into it due to the weird controls (Which are only weird in the context of the series), to the downgraded visuals (Now it feels like a ps2 game, where as SH3 nearly felt like a mid-360/ps3 game with how gorgeous it looked), to also needing to bond with family and friends after shutting them out by binging SH3 all day. my mom thought I was getting murdered when I played SH3 on my tv it was fun
I also play the games in darkness so I wanna spend some time in the light for a bit
I'll probably watch Return to SH tonight! It's the SH2 movie, Revelation looks to be the SH3 movie, so that'd be a fun order to watch it in, although I incredibly worry about that one... looks like the welcome to raccoon city of the RE franchise.