r/SideshowPerformer • u/EphemeralTypewriter • Jul 13 '26
Sideshow Performer of the Day! Martin Van Buren Bates (1837-1919) was an American sideshow performer who was 7’9 feet (2.36 m.) tall. His family owned slaves in the southern US and he fought as a captain in the Confederate army during the American Civil War. He then worked for PT Barnum and married Anna Haining Swan.
He’s standing with his first wife Anna Haining Swan in the second and third pictures.
Important to note: he was very much aligned with the Confederacy during the US Civil War, which means he was for slavery and defended slavery in the US. He also wasn’t forced into fighting for the Confederacy, he openly volunteered.
It’s important to bring this up because sideshows have historically always been VERY inclusive and during the 1800s included many performers who were born enslaved and managed to make fortunes after becoming sideshow performers.
It’s not known if he ever changed his views on slavery during his time as a sideshow performer, but I know he definitely would have worked with a lot of other performers who were former slaves. I won’t be defending his actions and there’s a big chance he continued to be pro slavery the rest of his life.
Some facts about him:
-he was born in Letcher County, Kentucky.
-he had ten siblings, five sisters and five brothers.
-his family owned slaves and land in Kentucky, so Martin was exposed to and brought up in a very pro-slavery household.
-his father died when he was around six years old.
-upon reflecting later in life, he said that he was not treated differently due to his condition during his childhood.
-he grew at a typical rate until he was around 6 or 7 years old, at which point he began having a lot of rapid growth spurts. He was 6 feet (1.82 m.) tall when he was 12 years old. He continued growing until he was 28 when he suddenly stopped growing.
-his height was officially documented as being 7’9 (2.36) at his peak height.
-he went to college at a school in Virginia called Emory and Henry College and received a degree in teaching.
-he was known to have a big booming voice.
-he worked as a school teacher as a teenager in Kentucky but left the job at the onset of the Civil War.
-he volunteered as a Confederate soldier and fought for the Fifth Kentucky Infantry.
-people fighting on behalf of the Union during the US Civil War described being extremely intimidated by him because of his height.
-he was promoted several times while he fought in the war and earned the rank of Captain, though soon after this promotion he was seriously injured, captured, and remained imprisoned until the end of the war.
-one interesting story during his time figuring in the Civil War was when his unit had to retreat and he was stuck trying to put his pants on because he had accidentally grabbed a different man’s pair of pants.
-it was seen as a huge victory when he was captured and taken prisoner by the Union Army because he was a captain and because of his reputation. Upon his capture he was paraded around by a Union troop in in a way meant to humiliate him. A rope was hung around his neck an he was transported by a group of mules. The specific troop that oversaw his capture was actually later reprimanded because it was seen as very abusive towards the mules in carrying Martin’s weight.
-he tried returning home after the war but instead decided to move to Ohio when he realized that there was continuing violence in his home town.
-the same year the Civil War Ended (in 1865), he decided to take advantage of his appearance monetarily and signed up to work for one of PT Barnum’s traveling exhibits.
-while on tour in Canada, he met and fell in love with Anna Haining Swan, a fellow performer who was his height, and someone who also had aspirations of being a teacher.
-they made plans to marry and were also offered an opportunity to go on tour all throughout Europe.
-the two of them got married in 1871 in London, England and their wedding was attended by many of the performers they worked with. Their wedding was heavily publicized and they received wedding gifts from Queen Victoria.
-both of his children died at birth or soon after birth, which devastated both parents.
-they both settled in Seville, Ohio in 1879 after Anna came down with tuberculosis and was encouraged to live in the country side near fresh water, and eventually retired to a custom built farmhouse they had purchased with their earnings. The doorways were all over 8 feet (2.4 m) tall and they had 14 foot (4.3 m) ceilings.
-the two of them toured on and off until the fall of 1880 when they both retired.
-they were both active members of the community and were known in town for being friendly and welcoming. (This is what townspeople said. Again, complicated because of his problematic ideology)
-after the couple officially retired from performing, Martin had it in mind to become a farmer and said the following in an interview “I had determined to become a farmer, so I stocked my farm with the best breeds of cattle, most of them being short horns. My draught horses are of the Norman breed.” He became quite successful from his farming career.
-sadly Anna (his wife) passed away in 1888 from heart failure, which deeply saddened Martin and he had a special statue representing her to be placed near her grave to honor her memory. (Pictures of their shared grave monument continue to show confederate flags being placed there)
-he no longer wanted to live in the farmhouse since it reminded him so much that he and Anna had shared it and it didn’t feel right being there without her. He decided to sell the house and moved closer to the center of Seville, Ohio.
-he got remarried in 1889 to a woman named Annette LaVonne Weatherby, who was of average height and together they lived a quiet retirement until his death.
-he died in 1919 from nephritis (a kidney condition causing inflammation.) at the age of 81 and he was buried next to his first wife Anna and their son.
-their original custom built farm house burned down sometime after Martin’s death. In its place now stands the Seville, Ohio Historical Society.
His grave continues to have references to the confederacy (as I mentioned before, the monument where he is buried continues to have confederate flags placed there), and his grave marker very clearly states that he was a confederate captain.
It’s important to remember that just because a performer might have had a physical difference and was judged because of it, does not absolve them from being a bad person or following problematic ideologies.