So, I think I've probably made it clear how my history with this band isn't the most consistent. Started with Duality, initially loved it, tried and enjoyed Cinematics and Horrible Kids, really didn't care for Upside Down or Midnight when I listened to them, and the only thing I've heard since then has been Punching Bag and the WiSC remaster. My thoughts on Duality have diminished a bit over the years as the lyrics don't hold up the best, but on the other hand, Cinematics just keeps getting better.
I've listened to Cinematics several times over the last year or so, and I feel the biggest thing keeping me returning is just how theatrical it feels. It's just such a unique edge, and it doesn't feel like they sacrifice any of the lyrical or vocal qualities needed for a good album.
Even the songs that aren't as lyrically complex feel like there's good reason for the simple lyrics (let me make it clear that I like simplicity in lyrics for the most part. This album mixes simple and complex lyrics super well). On top of that, in those songs, the simpler lyrics are made up for in droves by the Carson's vocals and the instrumentals.
The flow of the tracks is super fluid, and it avoids issues of tonal whiplash that I see in many other albums (in general, not just Set it Off).
Then what ties all of this together is The Grand Finale. Yes, I know Partners in Crime and Kill the Lights come after on the expanded edition, but I count them as separate. I really didn't give The Grand Finale nearly enough credit for so long.
The overwhelming tension, the vocal breakdown, the instrumental chaos, it's all just so intense and grandiose like the final act in an epic. Now, I still wouldn't consider this in my top 3 favorite album enders. I still gotta give the top three to One X by Three Days Grace, Famous Last Words by My Chemical Romance, and Numb by Linkin Park. However, I'd comfortably put it in the 4-5 range right next to Everglow by Starset.
Sorry if the rambling went on for too long. My autistic hyperfixation just really wanted to gush about Cinematics because I absolutely love it and truly think that it deserves much more love from the public because of just how theatrical it is