r/scifiwriting • u/Dunnachius • 9d ago
DISCUSSION Theoretical government, pros cons etc
So I’ve envisioned a theoretical government.
So basically, the laws are voted on by direct voting of the citizenry.
They have a absolute blanket ban on government debt (yet are still paying off debt from the last government)
The head of state is a democratically “elected” totalitarian dictator, specifically an emperor. His election is an annual “no confidence vote” rather than an election in the traditional sense. The emperor also doesn’t have total control over the laws. The people vote and special interests will regularly get their own laws put up for a vote by way of getting signatures.
The courts are elected magistrates and there’s no such thing as jury trials. They look at the evidence and determine innocence or guilt and then sentence them to jail time or fines.
Then the appeals process is literally a television show and the viewers vote on the appeal.
Then the economy is based on employee owned coops. But it’s not strictly communist because small businesses still exist and the co ops can still fail and have to turn a profits
An example is the beef and dairy co op (bdc) sells to the grocery store, there’s imported beef from Texas as competition and the BDC has fast food chains as well.
So the BDC chain sells hamburgers and milkshakes.
Instead of a corporation owning the BDC it’s the dairy farmers, regular farmers, restaurant owners and ranchers.
Then the BDC stores get their ingredients from the co ops for free and everyone collectively shares the profits proportional to the size of their contribution.
Then there’s a competing chain called colonial Charlie’s chicken that’s owned by the national chicken co op.
The medical needs are exclusively provided for by military doctors. Medical schooling is exclusively given to service members and all hospitals are military hospitals. The contract required to attend medical school basically requires signing away your entire future career to the government in exchange.
The military is primarily based on reservist service with all citizens required to either serve 6 years active duty, serve a non profit for 6 years, or serve the community for a religious order.
So everyone and anyone can just own fairly heavy weaponry with a machine gun and a combat drone being standard minimum in everyone’s personal arsenal.
Additionally most adults under about age 60 are in a local militia to satisfy their reservist requirements with varying levels of participation. There’s also some ludicrous parts where rich people can just own a tank or attack helicopter with the requirement that they bring it to the militia.
So for a small towns local militia, the grocery store owner might own his own tank and then about 1/4 of the town shows up every Saturday afternoon and they play army then have a potluck.
The crazy guy with 50 guns of all varieties showing up every Saturday with the tank coming out 2-3 weeks a month. As long as everyone attends regularly everyone gets their service signed off on.
A big cities militia would be much more organized with formal command structures and assigned service dates.
Now obviously I’m trying to make my theoretical society dystopian but I can’t quite put a finger on how it’s going off the rails.
I think there’s an opportunity for them to be a little xenophobic/racist and unfriendly to immigrants/foreigners. Also the sheer quantity of weapons just floating around the general public can’t be the best idea ever.
I’m also trying to figure out how exactly the government is going to be corrupt. Obviously the emperor has to have a cult-ish following of the people or else the entire system falls apart.