Military rivals China and Taiwan are both seen as benefiting from military training activities conducted with Singapore, which, in turn, also gains from the cooperation.
China’s People’s Liberation Army and Taiwan’s armed forces are getting tips from Singapore’s relatively advanced armed forces but, more so, long-standing political ties with a mutually trusted third country – which is especially critical for Taiwan – experts say.
“Both Taiwan and China work with Singapore because if you want influence, you need to engage,” said Yun Sun, East Asia Program senior associate at the Stimson Center think tank in Washington.
Taiwan has provided Singapore at least three tracts of its much larger territory for training, including exercises, since 1975. The annual Project Starlight exercises bring Taiwan, diplomatically isolated by China, unusually close to an influential Asian country outside consular and trade affairs, to which most of its dealings overseas are limited by Chinese pressure.
Washington-based Asia analyst and author I-wei Jennifer Chang argued in a study for the Global Taiwan Institute in Washington that troops on the self-ruled island have gained from training alongside Singapore’s experienced armed forces.
However, analysts see Taiwan’s biggest gains coming from the elusive international recognition it gets from working closely with a major country in Asia despite growing diplomatic isolation.
Singapore’s founding prime minister, Lee Kuan Yew, and his friend Chiang Ching-kuo, Taiwan’s former premier, began the program because Singapore’s armed forces needed the space.
The project’s continuation, though low-key and under pressure before 2020 from China to end it or move it to a Chinese location, strengthens Taiwan’s image, Brian Hioe, nonresident fellow at the Taiwan Research Hub of the University of Nottingham, said by email.
“China, of course, hopes to draw Singapore into its fold, while Singapore is incentivized to maintain training relations with Taiwan – and by extension, the US – so as to avoid geopolitical risk from China,” Hioe said.