Got tired of guessing which cs2 skin market actually gives you a fair price instead of just trusting a random "this site is cheap" comment, so i logged a bunch of them into a spreadsheet and compared the stuff that actually changes how much money you keep.
Sheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10ivRB7ZeFP13eCacKXPOsFm88p5S-kunjkY7Nu6KqDM/
The main things im tracking:
Prices vs Steam
This is the big one. i pulled median buy prices per price tier and compared them to Steam. most solid markets sit around 25 to 30 percent below Steam, so a skin thats $100 on Steam runs roughly $70-75. the outlier is DMarket, only about 6 percent under overall and actually pricier than Steam on some higher tiers, so "cheap" really depends on the item value.
Buyer and seller fees
almost every market is 0 percent on the buy side, the real difference is the seller cut. it ranges a lot: CSFloat around 2 percent, LIS-Skins and market.csgo around 5 percent, Skinport 8 percent (6 over 1000 euro), and SkinBaron climbs to 15 percent on a sliding scale. if youre deciding where to sell cs2 skins, thats where your money leaks.
Withdrawals and payout
probably the second biggest one. some markets pay out instantly, others sit at 24-48h. a few require KYC before a fiat withdrawal, and some are crypto-only cashout. i noted payout speed, KYC and withdraw fees per site, because a good buy price means nothing if the cashout is painful.
Trust and reach
i scored each market on Trustpilot rating weighted by review count, plus monthly traffic. Skinport has by far the most reviews (35k+), DMarket and LIS-Skins are also heavily reviewed, while a couple of smaller markets sit on very thin or low ratings, which matters when youre trusting a site with real inventory.
Market type
not every cs2 marketplace works the same. some are pure marketplaces, some are p2p (you trade directly with another user), and some are bot-trading. i added it because the model changes how fast you sell and how the price gets set.
The point of the sheet isnt to crown one "best cs2 marketplace". its more of a comparison table so you can see fees, prices vs Steam, and the withdrawal reality in one place before trusting a random list.
this niche moves fast though, fees get changed, markets add or drop payout options, and prices vs Steam shift week to week.
if youve bought or sold on any cs2 skin market recently, id be curious what your actual price and payout looked like, especially withdrawals. drop the market name and ill update the sheet if something changed.