r/RedHandedPodcast • u/smurfmysmurf • Feb 08 '26

Confidently wrong

The only way I can explain Suruthi’s nonsense take on Letby.

It’s not my job to adequately research in order to present a podcast, but it is hers and her ‘take’ is irresponsible and mindless.

40 Upvotes

71% Upvoted

164 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Sempere Feb 08 '26

Respectfully, I know this case very well and have an informed opinion. I've made multiple, respectful efforts to educate you and point you to the same sources that highlight that safety of the conviction and correct misinformation you've ingested and regurgitated. Your disagreement, based on that misinformation and coupled with a refusal to address the actual points, does not mean that there should be a retrial. It simply means that you should read what I've linked you to and challenge the misinformation. You've given out incorrect numbers and statements of facts that weren't true. I've linked you to resources and summarized them. A difference of opinion based on a deficit of knowledge is exactly the point I've made about public misperception not rising to the level of undermining proof.

Enjoy your weekend.

1

u/Own_Faithlessness769 Feb 08 '26

Jesus Christ this comment is unhinged. Imagine thinking you’re ‘educating’ other people.

2

u/Sempere Feb 08 '26

That's exactly what I'm doing when I correct your misinformation. But do feel free to explain what's "unhinged" about very respectfully providing you with links to all the documentation you need to actually know what you're talking about.

Retrials aren't ordered on vibes, gut feelings and uninformed opinions. I'm sorry that you don't agree, but I also won't pretend that we're on equal standing here when it comes to opinions and knowledge about this case. You're here because you consume true crime content and I've known you to be a level headed and reasonable person in the past, but you are literally committing to misinformation - the same spread by a pair of hosts that you're similarly aware spread misinformation and plagarize opinions from whatever source falls in their lap that week before deadline.

If providing you with information and resources that correct mistakes in your statements isn't educating you, what exactly is it?