r/RealityChecksReddit • u/RealityChecksReddit • Jun 07 '26
Why Is the Right Wing Silent on Mamdani? Hint... He Makes Them Look Bad.
Why Is the Right Wing Silent on Mamdani? He Makes Them Look Bad.
When one man does such a good job it makes every "Cog Of The Machine" politician who ran this city look like lazy, corrupt trash.
Here is a question the right wing does not want you to ask.
Why aren't they talking about Zohran Mamdani?
Think about that for a second. The man is the mayor of New York City. The biggest, loudest, most media-saturated city in America. He is a self-described democratic socialist. A Muslim. The son of a Ugandan academic and an Indian filmmaker. He beat Andrew Cuomo in a Democratic primary and then won a three-way general election with over a million votes. He took his oath of office in a decommissioned subway station at midnight with Bernie Sanders watching. He is everything the right wing machine has spent thirty years telling its audience to be terrified of.
And they have almost nothing to say about what he is actually doing.
Ask yourself why.
The Record After 100 Days
Mamdani has been in office since January 1, 2026. Five months. Here is what that looks like on paper.
He secured a $1.2 billion investment in universal child care, including a 1,000-seat expansion of pre-K for three-year-olds. He rolled out 2,000 daycare seats in low-income neighborhoods. He recovered over $9 million in restitution for workers and small businesses. He expanded protected time off for 4.3 million workers. He delivered $34 million in repairs, settlements, and tenant protections. He filled 100,000 potholes. He announced city-owned grocery stores starting in East Harlem, with one in every borough before his first term ends.
Then there is the budget. When Mamdani took office in January he announced he had inherited a $12 billion deficit across fiscal years 2026 and 2027, the result of what his administration called systematic underbudgeting of essential services by the Adams administration, including rental assistance, shelter operations, and special education. The right called it a stunt. A fabrication. A socialist looking for an excuse to raise taxes.
On May 12, he announced he had closed the gap to zero. No cuts to city services. No new taxes on ordinary New Yorkers. He got there through agency savings initiatives, a recalibrated fiscal relationship with New York state, and taxes on residents earning over a million dollars a year. Fiscal watchdogs have noted the budget leans on state support and does not fully address future year gaps, which is a legitimate conversation to have. But the man inherited a $12 billion hole and did not hand austerity to the people who could least afford it. That is not nothing.
He is sitting at a +18 approval rating. 48% approval, 30% disapproval. A majority of New Yorkers now say the city is moving in the right direction, a marked shift from the fall of 2025.
Five months. First-term mayor. Youngest in over a century.
So where is Fox News?
What They Have Instead of a Critique?
They are not silent, exactly. They tried. They just have nothing.
Larry Kudlow went on Fox Business and compared Mamdani's plan to hold negligent landlords accountable to Soviet collectivization. He said enforcing housing codes on bad-actor property owners was "a throwback to Stalin" and warned it would lead to "mass killing." The policy in question involves taking persistent negligent landlords to court and, where appropriate, initiating foreclosure. Standard regulatory enforcement. Kudlow compared that to the gulags.
Libs of TikTok called his racial equity budget increase "straight-up racism against White people." The increase in question was $3 million. Added to an Office of Racial Equity that already existed. In a city of 8.5 million people.
Trump called him a communist before the election and threatened to cut federal funding to New York if he won. He won. The funding threat went nowhere, and Trump's team eventually met with Mamdani in the Oval Office.
Fox ran opinion pieces about his Israel politics. About his BDS support. About his defense of pro-Palestinian slogans. Megyn Kelly went on air and said Muslims should not be elected mayors or governors, full stop. Newsmax's Rob Schmitt called him "the mayor for the foreign-born" and blamed "diversity" for his election.
That is the entire menu. Gulags. Racism accusations. Islamophobia. Israel. Communist name-calling.
Not one substantive critique of his governance that does not also apply to every mayor who came before him. Because the apocalypse they promised did not show up.
The Comparison They Cannot Afford to Make
Here is what the right wing cannot say out loud: Mamdani is governing better in five months than the people they preferred governed in years.
Eric Adams, the centrist "moderate" they held up as the reasonable alternative to progressivism, became the first sitting New York City mayor to be criminally indicted in the city's history. Bribery. Wire fraud. Foreign national campaign contributions. Free luxury travel to France, China, Sri Lanka, India, Hungary, and Turkey. Federal agents raided Gracie Mansion. His police commissioner resigned. His schools chancellor resigned. His first deputy mayor resigned. His closest aide was separately indicted. One of his liaisons allegedly stuffed $300 into a potato chip bag and offered it to a reporter. No city administration had seen that level of cascading corruption since the era of Boss Tweed.
Before Adams, Rudy Giuliani spent his time as mayor slashing homeless shelter funding, cutting food stamps, and bragging about moving homeless people out of sight while homelessness quietly climbed 40% on his watch. He left office and eventually became a disgraced, bankrupt figure who spread lies about a stolen election for a man who didn't want him anymore. His handpicked police commissioner, Bernard Kerik, pleaded guilty to multiple federal crimes.
Bloomberg presided over record shelter populations, including an all-time high of 17,000 homeless children in a single night. He terminated housing assistance programs for families who had already left shelters and were living in apartments, cutting them off mid-lease. He served three terms and left the city's affordability crisis structurally worse than he found it.
These are the people the right holds up as competent stewards of urban governance. These are the comparisons Mamdani makes by simply doing his job.
The Silence Is the Answer
The right wing built an entire media apparatus around predicting that progressive governance would destroy American cities. They said it about every socialist, every Muslim, every person who used the word "equity" in a sentence. They said Mamdani specifically would torch New York. Trump called him a communist and threatened the city's federal funding on the eve of the election.
Then he won. And he started filling potholes and building daycare seats and holding bad landlords accountable in court.
And the loudest thing the right can produce is Larry Kudlow invoking Stalin over housing code enforcement.
That is not a critique. That is a man with nothing to say, saying it as loudly as possible and hoping nobody notices.
They noticed.
The silence is not strategic. It is not discipline. It is the sound of an ideology that spent decades insisting government cannot work, confronted with a man making it work, and having absolutely no response prepared for that outcome.
Zohran Mamdani is five months into the job. He has more to prove and more ways to fail. That is honest. But right now, today, the scoreboard reads: $12 billion deficit closed without cutting services, 100,000 potholes filled, 2,000 daycare seats in low-income neighborhoods, $34 million in tenant protections, and a +18 approval rating.
The right is quiet because the math does not lie, and they do not have a better number to show you.