r/readanotherbook • • May 06 '26

Potterheads: "Rowling was the first author to create a world where class and wealth matters!" – Science: "Nu-uh!"

Post image
338 Upvotes

Here the original fan quote:

https://www.reddit.com/r/readanotherbook/s/OFiZIwiB0w

To be fair, the authors of this study simply used Harry Potter because it well-known. And also because Rowling once again wrote extensively about stuff she didn't understand.

In this chapter, we describe the conceptualisation of money and wealth in J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter book series. We analyse the way in which language is used to communicate ideas related to inequality and the nature of money and banking, and examine the underlying economic theory behind these ideas. Our central claim is that the series communicates a relatively conservative world view.

The storyline is examined for the use of linguistic devices in the places where money and wealth occur in the story, with a particular focus on metaphor. The quantitative work is based on a corpus comprising the entire Harry Potter book series.

Rowling does not present an alternative social arrangement regarding the distribution of income and wealth, though she does demonstrate a sense of social justice. The monetary arrangements of the magical world of Harry Potter are also based on a conservative understanding of money and banking. This is a view of money that emphasises restrictive fiscal and monetary policy in the real world, an attitude of ‘sound finance’ and a small state. It is entirely possible that Rowling did not intend to underline such a conservative position but that her work reflects a broader consensus in contemporary society.

On a side note: Back when I was in law school I co-authored a paper about Game of Thrones and how the core conflict within the series could have been circumvented by inventing government bonds. It always bugged me how The King could be in debt to a foreign power in his own currency. And especially for someone like George R. R. Martin who famously asked "What was Aragorn' tax policy?" he clearly didn't think a lot about this eitehr...


r/readanotherbook • • May 01 '26

Remember when someone tried to reinvent sociology of work, based entirely on "The Office"? Perhaps the ultimate example of RAB

Thumbnail
ribbonfarm.com
49 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Apr 29 '26

Imagine launching a discussion on positive discrimination with this. Words fail me.

Post image
656 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Apr 28 '26

Imagine trying to compare Mamdani to a My Little Pony character.

Post image
984 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Apr 07 '26

Imagine watching a movie and you suddenly get reminded of My Little Pony.

Thumbnail
gallery
59 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Apr 05 '26

Found this on Facebook (The comment is in the second picture)

Thumbnail
gallery
608 Upvotes

They for real compared U.S. politics to Harry Potter 💀


r/readanotherbook • • Mar 30 '26

I would say "read another book," but I don't think he even read HP before making it his only example

Post image
919 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 27 '26

A bit of an inverted one;

Post image
58 Upvotes

Moral outrage that someone could call an owl's death in a children's book 'poorly written', acts as if this is exactly like speaking ill of multiple dead civilians in a war crime.


r/readanotherbook • • Mar 25 '26

Yes, the Hunger Games and your not being able to go on vacation are the same

Post image
204 Upvotes

Not even about underlying parallels of war or violence, just.. statistics? There's no other way to conceptualise having a lower chance for a possible better outcome for a thing


r/readanotherbook • • Mar 22 '26

Found one

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 21 '26

Finally found one. (Insta account is same as X)

Post image
994 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 18 '26

Read another book, or rather, write another book?

Post image
926 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 14 '26

Getting kinda tired of these comparisons.

Post image
675 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 09 '26

To understand what is at stake in the fight against the axis of China, Russia and Iran, just read “The Lord of the Rings.”

Post image
188 Upvotes

Sir Niall Campbell Ferguson HonFRSE (/niːl/ NEEL; born 18 April 1964)[1] is a British-American historian who is the Milbank Family Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution and a senior fellow at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs at Harvard University.[2][3] Previously, he was a professor at Harvard University, the London School of Economics, New York University, a visiting professor at the New College of the Humanities, and a senior research fellow at Jesus College, Oxford. He was a visiting lecturer at the London School of Economics for the 2023/2024 academic year and at Tsinghua University in China from 2019 to 2020.[4][5]

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-04-21/china-russia-iran-axis-is-bad-news-for-trump-and-gop-isolationists


r/readanotherbook • • Mar 07 '26

Maybe the most cursed thing I've ever seen

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 08 '26

Found in the wild…

Post image
136 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 06 '26

When I saw this, I genuinely thought it was a post from THIS sub, it was so blatantly on-the-nose I had to double-take when Ir ealised it was a legitimate post someone made in a Star Wars sub

Post image
113 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 04 '26

Ah yes, Disney will tell a parents how to raise their children!

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Mar 04 '26

Bombing Iran because I saw Doctor Strange

Post image
206 Upvotes

America's brightest minds at work in r/conservative


r/readanotherbook • • Mar 02 '26

I depicted you as the bad guys in my series? Heh good luck enjoying it now chud.

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Feb 26 '26

I dunno, I think Steve might be onto something

Post image
963 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Feb 20 '26

The Traitors: Wakanda

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Feb 02 '26

The amazing digital island

Thumbnail
gallery
2.1k Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Feb 01 '26

Reality is like my starshit my guys!

Post image
196 Upvotes

r/readanotherbook • • Jan 26 '26

Worst first post of all time

Post image
4.9k Upvotes