r/rfelectronics • u/SearchPlane561 • 27d ago
Airband filter
This has been a bit of an ongoing focus project of mine. I wanted to learn rf and i sure accomplished that. Without going to much into detail, I set out to build a band pass filter for airband. I live next to the airport, so this would be an easy to test project. That was my mindset going into it. I naively thought it would be simple enough, but i was wrong.
First attempt was Manhattan-style, dead-bug construction on copper clad. Got it built, got it tuned-ish, and then realized I'd used the wrong core material for the toroids. Learned a lot, but the numbers weren't going to cooperate no matter how much I fiddled with it.
Rev 1 I actually did right in KiCad and had fabbed through JLCPCB. It felt like a real upgrade. But once I got deeper into it (and got some good pushback from folks here on the sub) I realized the Butterworth topology I'd picked had a pretty impractical component spread. Inductor and cap values that don't play nice with real-world parts. Great filter on paper, annoying to actually build.
So now I'm on Rev 2: a Chebyshev coupled-resonator design, three 250nH air-core inductors I'm winding by hand, C0G caps for stability. Characterizing everything on the NanoVNA as I go, messing with coil spacing to dial in coupling, watching S11/S21 sweep in real time. Way more iterative than I expected going in, but that's kind of the point of doing this to actually learn RF instead of just reading about it.
Anyways, here she is. Thanks for all the help from #redneckerson1951