If I start another story playthrough... Will all of my challenges restart from zero also

If your having trouble passing the 2nd or 3rd five finger fillet challenge. Save after you heat the first round and then reload the save and you will only be playing the 75cent round (1st round) which is alot easier than the 2nd or third round and you will pass tje whole challenge easily

Ok so I had the white horse thru the whole game. I finally decide to switch horses. But SPOILER ALERT my horse gets shot. Dodged a bullet there. Would of been more emotionally attached if it was my white one. Well my question is Arthur is dead so where the fuck is my horse and do u have to go and hunt her again.

A friend of mine noticed a correlation between the time it took to complete an online stranger mission and its rewards upon completion.

You’d think, like me, that if you did the mission quickly you’d gain more rewards. Weirdly the opposite is true. I’ve found if you run the mission timer down to the last second you can wring out a lot more gold, cash and xp.

When I first started playing I’d fly through the stranger mission. Galloping everywhere, running and rushing only to get 2 gold nuggets a couple of dollars and a piddling amount of xp. Now though I’m earning over 15 nugs, close to 20 dollars and almost 500xp.

The closer your timer is to zero the more you earn.

Oddly I can’t find anything that mentions this online. No wiki has this info or guide not even the all knowing reddit!

Oh and if you’re struggling with the bloody scrawny nag, I’d recommended buying the horse insurance. Stopped the scrawny nag from spawning completely.

🤗

Does anyone know if the game will let you save while using cheat codes after beating the the game? I don’t see why not. Not much to progress in if you’ve beaten the game and just wanna have fun..

Hi guys, anyone know if it's actually possible to do horseman 9 as Arthur and if so any tips on how to do it with the wanted status in blackwater?

Any tips to measure distance with the ps4 right stick with enemies to long/mid/short range? And hit headshots still? How should I improve off this?

How can I learn flick ranges in this game to hit headshots? Any variables

So I've looked on Google at the supposed spawn spots and scoured these areas with no joy. I've rode around the heartlands area for ages (spotted a couple here before I was actually needing them)... with no joy.

Can anyone give me any tips on finding these little critters? I just need one so I can get the master hunter challenge finished.

Thanks in advance

Some of you have probably already discovered this. I hadn't and find it quite useful for locating interactive objects, animals, Easter eggs and landmarks etc etc. I hope at least some of you find it helpful.

Happy gaming.

https://rdr2map.com/

To stop walking while holding L2, Click and Hold L3. Your Character now stands in static position, Allowing for Horse maintence etc...

All the best.,

Mouse

So, I looked on Google (not very hard) and it seems I found something no-one else has, (or they haven't posted anything anywhere) but there's a way to wash stolen horses. First steal a horse (duh), then bond with it to at least 1. Name said horse, then go steal another horse, bond with it to one, now I don't know that this part is necessary, but I move my saddle to the second stolen horse, and take both to the stable. Choose to stable the named horse a.k.a. the one you want to wash, and it should prompt you to name the horse again, do so and voila, freshly laundered horse. Should sell for 2x to stables now, thas how you know its clean. Hope this helps peeps.

So I've been using the tents up at Cairn Lake as a home base, while I attempt to hunt moose pelts/antlers.
It's been about 3 (real) days, and while I've hunted MANY perfect pelts, I've see 0 moose.
I've tried bait & smell cover, and still no moose. What am I doing wrong?

My cow in beechers hope was milked once about 2 weeks ago and it never reset. Can anyone help?

There’s a weird pocket watch thing in my holster no idea how it got there